Sold as-is: what visto e piaciuto means, the court valuation, and how far below it auctions start
Short answer
Visto e piaciuto means "seen and liked": the home is sold as it is, with no warranty for defects. At an Italian court auction this is the law, under article 2922 of the Civil Code. The court expert deducts for that missing warranty and other known problems, so the starting price sits below market value, and falls after failed rounds.
Key facts
- Article 2922 of the Civil Code: a forced sale carries no warranty for defects and cannot be undone for an unfair price.
- A forced sale can be challenged only if the property is substantially different from the one sold (aliud pro alio), by an objection within twenty days of the decree or of discovering the problem.
- Article 568 of the Code of Civil Procedure makes the expert deduct for the lack of warranty, irregularities, condition, occupancy, surviving burdens and arrears.
- The deduction for the missing warranty is set by the expert or by court practice and varies; there is no single legal percentage.
- A starting price below the valuation reflects known problems and the rules on price cuts, not necessarily a bargain.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What does visto e piaciuto mean?
- Is there a warranty when you buy at an Italian court auction?
- What you cannot complain about after the sale
- What the court still stands behind
- The exception: when you get something different (aliud pro alio)
- How does the court expert value a home?
- How big is the discount for the missing warranty?
- Why do Italian auctions start below market value?
- Why below the valuation is not the same as a bargain
- An invented example
- Can a buyer challenge the valuation?
- How to think about an as-is purchase
Every Italian court notice says it in one form or another: the property is sold in the state it is in, with its rights and burdens, visto e piaciuto. Americans know the idea as an as-is sale, the British as sold as seen, and many Australians and New Zealanders from mortgagee sales. In Italy, at a court auction, it is not a seller's choice but the law, and it explains both the main risk of buying this way and the main reason prices start low.
Here is what the phrase means in law, what you can and cannot complain about afterwards, how the court expert turns a home's market value into a valuation, why the starting price is usually below that market value, and why a price below the valuation is not the same as a bargain. Our guide to the starting price and auction day covers how the price rules work in the auction itself.
What does visto e piaciuto mean?
Literally, "seen and liked". The buyer is taken to have seen the property, or had the chance to, and to accept it as it is. It is an old trading phrase, used for cars, horses and second-hand goods as well as houses, and in a private sale it is a clause the parties can agree to limit the seller's warranties. At a court auction no agreement is needed. The phrase in the notice simply restates what the law already says.
Is there a warranty when you buy at an Italian court auction?
Article 2922 of the Civil Code has two short sentences. In a forced sale there is no warranty for defects in the thing sold. And a forced sale cannot be challenged for lesione, the rule that in some contracts lets a party who sold for less than half the true value ask for relief.
Both halves matter. The first means the debtor gives you no promise about the home's condition, and neither do the creditors, the delegate or the court. If the roof leaks, the heating is dead, the walls are damp or the floor is smaller than you thought, there is no seller to claim against. The second means the debtor cannot later undo the sale on the ground that the price was far too low. That protects you, and it is one reason the system can sell at low prices at all.
Why does the law work this way? Because the owner is not selling voluntarily. A debtor forced to sell has no interest in disclosing defects and no money to stand behind a warranty, and creditors who never lived in the home cannot be asked to guarantee it. Instead, the system puts the information up front, through the court expert's report, and leaves the buyer to judge it.
What you cannot complain about after the sale
- Hidden defects: damp, rot, cracks, failed systems or anything else wrong with the building, whether or not anyone knew.
- Missing qualities you assumed: a view, quiet neighbours, good light, a garden that was larger than it turns out to be in the registers.
- Problems the papers described: occupancy, arrears, unauthorised work or surviving rights. These were part of what you bid for.
- The price: that you paid more than the home is worth, or that a later round of a similar home sold for less.
- Changes before the sale: wear and deterioration between the report and your offer are yours to spot, because you bid on the home as it stands. Serious damage after the award but before the decree is a separate question for a lawyer.
Withdrawing is not an option either. A valid offer is binding, and if you win and then fail to pay the balance the judge revokes the award and the procedure keeps your deposit, at least a tenth of your offer. If the home then sells for less, you can be made to pay the difference.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
What the court still stands behind
The lack of warranty covers the condition of the home, not your title to it. The transfer decree gives you ownership and orders the mortgages and seizures cancelled. Article 2929 of the Civil Code protects the buyer against most faults in the enforcement steps before the sale, unless the buyer colluded with the creditor. And article 2921 deals with the rare case where a third party proves a better right and the buyer loses the property: the buyer can recover the price from what has not yet been paid out, or from the creditors and the debtor who received it. Our guide to liens, condo fees and easements explains what the decree clears and what it does not.
The exception: when you get something different (aliud pro alio)
Italian case law draws a line between a defective thing and a different thing. A flat with a leaking roof is a defective flat. A "building plot" that turns out to be unbuildable farmland, or a home that cannot serve as a home at all, may be a different thing from the one the court sold. Lawyers call this aliud pro alio, Latin for "one thing for another".
The Court of Cassation has accepted that a buyer at a forced sale can raise it, but within narrow limits. In its case law the property must belong to a different kind from the one described in the sale order, or lack the qualities it needs to serve its economic purpose, or be unusable for the purpose that led to the offer. Ordinary defects, however serious, do not count.
The remedy is procedural and fast. The buyer must challenge the sale by an objection to the enforcement acts (opposizione agli atti esecutivi, article 617 of the Code of Civil Procedure), within twenty days of the decree or of when they learned, or could have learned, of the problem. The burden of proving when they learned is on the buyer. According to the Court of Cassation, once the plan for paying out the proceeds has become final, the objection is no longer available in the case itself. In short, it exists, it is hard to win, and it is no substitute for checking the home before you bid. Our glossary defines the term.
Whether a particular problem amounts to aliud pro alio is a question for a lawyer, and the deadlines are short. Courts have not treated every serious planning problem as one.
How does the court expert value a home?
Article 568 of the Code of Civil Procedure tells the judge to set the value of the property from its market value, on the basis of the court expert's report. The expert must show the working: the floor area, the value per square metre, the overall value, and then each adjustment and reduction separately. The law lists them:
- A reduction for the absence of a warranty for defects.
- The cost of regularising planning and building irregularities.
- The state of use and maintenance.
- The occupancy, such as a tenant who can stay.
- Legal restrictions and burdens that the sale will not remove.
- Unpaid condominium charges that may fall on the buyer.
To reach the market value, experts usually compare similar sales nearby and published price ranges for the area, and adjust for the home's size, floor, condition and position. That figure is then reduced by the items above. The result is the value the judge adopts, and the first round normally starts there. Our perizia guide explains where the valuation sits in the report.
Every price cut, on record
Members see each lot's price history: how many rounds it has been through and how its price has moved from the court valuation.
See membership- First round
- €60,000
- Second round
- €48,000
- Now, third round
- €38,400
How big is the discount for the missing warranty?
The law requires a reduction but does not set its size. In practice it varies by court and by expert. Many reports apply a flat percentage, often somewhere between 10% and 20% of the market value, and some courts fix a figure in their standard instructions to experts: one court's instructions, for example, set a flat 15% meant to cover the missing warranty, unpaid charges and the incentive to buy at auction together. Other experts fold the reduction into a wider adjustment, or vary it with the condition of the home.
There is a logic to it. A buyer who cannot inspect freely, cannot negotiate, cannot claim for defects and must pay on fixed deadlines takes more risk than a buyer in a private sale, and a rational buyer pays less for that. The reduction prices the risk in advance. Whether it is enough for a particular home depends on what is wrong with it, which no percentage can know.
Why do Italian auctions start below market value?
Several things push the starting price below what a similar home would fetch on the open market, and they add up.
- The deductions. The warranty reduction alone takes off a slice, and arrears, irregularities, occupancy and condition take off more.
- The age of the valuation. The report may have been written a year or more before the round, sometimes several. Where local prices have risen, the figure lags behind; where they have fallen, it can sit above the market.
- The price cuts. If a round passes with no valid offer, the next can start up to a quarter lower, and after the fourth deserted round up to half lower. Our guide to failed rounds and price cuts explains the rules.
- The 75% rule. An offer is valid from three quarters of the starting price, so the lowest price at which a home can sell in a round is lower still.
A home on its first round may start close to its adjusted value. A home on its fifth round may start at a small fraction of it. The starting price on its own says little about which kind you are looking at.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get a lot report for every home, with its valuation, deductions and red flags from the court papers set out in plain English.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Why below the valuation is not the same as a bargain
It is natural to read the gap between the starting price and the valuation as a discount. It is better read as a set of reasons, some of which you can see and some of which you cannot.
The problems are already priced in
The deductions exist because the home has problems. A flat valued at a figure that already subtracts the cost of an unauthorised extension, two years of arrears and a tenant is not cheap by that amount; it is priced for those problems. If you then subtract them again in your head, you count them twice. If the expert underestimated them, you count them too little.
The market may disagree with the valuation
Repeated failed rounds tell you something. Sometimes the first figure was too high, and the market is correcting it. Sometimes the home has a problem that buyers saw and the price has to fall far enough to compensate. Sometimes nobody could understand the papers. Each is a different reason, and only the last is good news for a careful buyer.
Fixed costs do not fall with the price
Taxes have minimums, condominium arrears are the same whatever you pay, and legalising work or renovating costs what it costs. On a home that has fallen through many rounds, these can add a large share to the price. Our guide to buying costs sets out the taxes and fees, and our overview of what can go wrong the problems that add to them.
Competition decides the final price
The starting price is a legal threshold, not a forecast. A sound home in a popular area can draw several offers and sell well above it, sometimes above the valuation. The homes that sell far below their valuation are, more often than not, the ones with a reason.
An invented example
Picture an invented two-bedroom flat in a provincial town. The expert finds that similar flats sell for about €100,000. The flat needs work, so the expert takes off €10,000 for condition. A small closed-in balcony can be legalised for an estimated €4,000, and the arrears for the current and previous year are €2,000. That leaves €84,000. A 15% reduction for the missing warranty brings it to about €71,000, which the judge adopts as the value and the first starting price.
Nobody bids. The second round starts at about €53,500, with valid offers from about €40,000. A buyer who reads "€40,000 for a €100,000 flat" sees a 60% discount. A buyer who reads the papers sees a flat that needs work, a planning fix and arrears, with no warranty, priced on a report that may be a year old, and asks why nobody wanted it at €71,000. The second reading is the useful one. The answer might be harmless, a round held in August and a notice few people read, or it might be a defect the photos hint at. The price alone cannot say which.
Invented example with round figures. Real reports use different deductions, and courts set different percentages.
Can a buyer challenge the valuation?
Not in any useful way. The valuation is set before the sale, and the debtor and creditors can raise objections to it at that stage. A buyer who disagrees with it simply offers what the home is worth to them, within the rules on the lowest valid offer. If a buyer later finds the expert made a serious error, the commentators discuss possible claims against the expert, but these are uncertain, slow and no part of a sensible plan.
What a buyer can do is ask whether the report is still current. If many months have passed, if the home has been empty, or if the case has been suspended, the facts may have moved. Some courts ask the expert to update the report before a later round; many do not.
How to think about an as-is purchase
An as-is sale shifts the work of finding problems from the seller to the buyer. In Italy the court expert does part of that work for you, in public, before the sale. The rest falls to you and the professionals you hire: a viewing with the custodian, a surveyor for the building and the planning file, a lawyer for the legal position. Our guide on who checks what before you bid explains each role.
Then set your top price from the home's value to you, with every known problem counted once, a margin for the ones nobody could see, and the buying costs on top. If the lowest valid offer in the current round sits below that figure, the auction may be worth it. If it does not, no gap between price and valuation will make it so.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
What does visto e piaciuto mean in an Italian property sale?
It means "seen and liked": the buyer accepts the property as it is, with its defects, rights and burdens. In a private sale it is a clause limiting the seller's warranties; at a court auction it restates the law, because a forced sale carries no warranty for defects.
Can I get money back if an Italian auction home has hidden defects?
Generally no. Article 2922 of the Civil Code excludes any warranty for defects in a forced sale. Only if the property is substantially different from the one sold (aliud pro alio) can the sale be challenged, by objection within twenty days of the decree or of discovering the problem.
How far below market value do Italian court auctions start?
The first round usually starts at the court valuation, which is already below market value because the expert deducts for the missing warranty, irregularities, condition, occupancy and arrears. Each failed round can cut the price by up to a quarter, and by up to half after the fourth, and offers are valid from 75% of the starting price.
How much is the discount for no warranty in an Italian court valuation?
There is no fixed legal figure. Experts often apply a percentage somewhere between 10% and 20%, and some courts set a flat figure in their standard instructions. Others build it into a wider adjustment. The report should show the reduction separately.
Can the debtor undo an Italian court sale because the price was too low?
Not on the ground that the price was unfair: article 2922 rules out challenges for lesione in forced sales. Separately, a judge can suspend a sale after payment if the price is far below a fair one, but this is rare.
Is a court auction home below its valuation a good deal?
Not necessarily. The valuation already subtracts known problems, it may be out of date, and repeated failed rounds can signal a problem. Judge the price against what the home is worth to you once every cost is counted, not against the valuation.
Sources
- Civil Code, article 2922: no warranty and no challenge for lesione in a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2921: the buyer evicted after a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2929: faults in earlier enforcement steps and the buyer (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 568: how the value is set (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 591: price cuts after deserted rounds (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 617: objections to enforcement acts (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

