Unauthorised building work and land registry mismatches: what can still be legalised after the sale
Short answer
A court can sell a home with unauthorised building work, and the buyer inherits it. Some differences fall within legal tolerances; many can be legalised through a sanatoria for a fine and fees; a narrow 120-day window lets court buyers use the old amnesties for qualifying older works. Work that cannot be legalised may have to be demolished.
Key facts
- The rule that voids private deeds for homes without valid permits does not apply to court sales.
- Court buyers may apply under the old amnesty laws within 120 days of the transfer decree, but only where the conditions are met.
- Work too recent or too large for the old amnesties goes through an ordinary sanatoria under articles 36 or 36-bis of the Building Code, as amended by the Salva Casa decree of 2024.
- Small differences within the legal tolerances are not violations at all.
- A land registry mismatch is a separate, usually cheaper, problem from unauthorised work.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What counts as unauthorised building work in Italy?
- Why can a court sell a home with unauthorised work?
- What is the 120-day window for court buyers?
- Condono or sanatoria: what is the difference?
- How sanatoria works after the Salva Casa decree
- Tolerances: when a difference is not a violation
- What cannot be legalised?
- What if the land registry plan does not match the home?
- How much does legalising work cost?
- Why the expert's estimate is only an estimate
- Who checks a home's planning status?
- How irregularities affect resale and lending
- Is an irregularity a reason to walk away?
Americans call it unpermitted work, the British speak of works without planning permission or building regulations approval, and Italians call it abuso edilizio. It is one of the most common findings in Italian court papers and one of the most misunderstood. Some buyers walk away from any home with an irregularity. Others assume that anything can be fixed with a fee. Both are wrong, and the difference between a closed-in balcony and a house built without a permit can be the difference between a small bill and a demolition order.
Here is what counts as unauthorised work, why a court can sell a home that a private seller could not, the special 120-day window for court buyers and its narrow limits, the ordinary routes to legalise work after the Salva Casa reform, what cannot be fixed, and how land registry mismatches fit in. It explains the law in general. Whether a particular home can be legalised is a technical judgement that a geometra or architect makes after looking at its file.
What counts as unauthorised building work in Italy?
Every building and every significant change to one needs the right permission from the town hall. The Building Code (DPR 380 of 6 June 2001) sets the categories: a building permit (permesso di costruire) for new buildings and major works, and simpler filings that a technician sends to the town hall, known as a SCIA or CILA, for many renovations. Work done without the right permission, or differently from what was approved, is unauthorised.
The law grades the seriousness. In broad terms:
- Total difference (totale difformità): a building or part of one that is substantially different from what was approved, or built with no permit at all.
- Essential variations (variazioni essenziali): changes the regions define as major, such as a large increase in volume or floor area, a change of use that alters planning standards, or a substantial change in height or position.
- Partial difference (parziale difformità): smaller departures from the permit, such as a room a little larger than approved or a window in a different place.
- Works without a simpler filing: internal changes, new partitions or changes to openings done without the SCIA or CILA they needed.
In the papers these differences are usually described as difformità, and the expert says whether each is sanabile, capable of being legalised. Our glossary defines the terms. The perizia guide explains where planning status fits in the report as a whole.
Why can a court sell a home with unauthorised work?
In a private sale, Italian law makes a deed transferring a building void if it does not state the permit under which the building was built. Notaries therefore check, and a home with serious irregularities is hard to sell privately until they are dealt with. Article 46 of the Building Code, and article 40 of Law 47 of 28 February 1985 for older buildings, set out that rule.
Both articles also make an exception: the nullity does not apply to transfers arising from enforcement and insolvency procedures. A court can therefore sell a home with unauthorised work, and the transfer decree is valid. That protects the creditors, who would otherwise be unable to recover their money from any building with a problem. But it does not legalise anything. The buyer receives the home exactly as it is, with its irregularities and with the town hall's powers over them intact.
What is the 120-day window for court buyers?
The same two articles give court buyers something no private buyer has. Where the conditions are met, the buyer may apply for a building amnesty (condono) within 120 days of the transfer decree. Article 46 of the Building Code refers to an application for a permit in sanatoria; article 40 of the 1985 law, extended by the 1994 and 2003 amnesty laws, lets the buyer use the amnesty rules even though the general deadlines for those amnesties closed long ago.
This window is real, but it is narrow, and it is often misdescribed as a general fix. In broad terms:
- It only covers work of a kind, size and date that one of the three national amnesties (1985, 1994 or 2003) would have covered. Work done after the last amnesty's cut-off, or too large for it, does not qualify.
- The law itself requires the creditor's claim behind the sale to date from before the amnesty law in question came into force, and the work to have been finished by that amnesty's cut-off date (1 October 1983, 31 December 1993 or 31 March 2003). The other conditions differ between the three amnesties and are technical.
- Work in protected areas faces the stricter limits those amnesties applied there, and some protected areas were largely excluded.
- The clock starts with the transfer decree: the Building Code counts from its notification, the 1985 law from the transfer itself. The Council of State has held that the 120 days do not start again because the buyer finds the problem later, unless the irregularity could not have been detected at all, which the buyer must prove. A gap in the expert's report does not count.
The court expert is required to say whether the home appears to meet the conditions for this route. That makes the report the first place the question is raised, but not the last word: a buyer who means to rely on the window needs a technician and often a lawyer to confirm it before bidding, and to be ready to file soon after the decree. Many auction irregularities do not qualify, and the ones that do are mostly older homes with older problems.
The 120-day window is a chance to use old amnesty rules, not a promise that the application will succeed. The town hall still examines it, and the amnesty fees and the building contributions still have to be paid.
Condono or sanatoria: what is the difference?
The two words are often used loosely, but they are different things. A condono is an amnesty: a one-off law that allowed work which broke the planning rules to be legalised anyway, on payment. Italy has had three, and none is open to the general public. A sanatoria is the ordinary, permanent route to legalise work that meets the rules the law applies to it, by applying after the event and paying a sum.
For a court buyer, the 120-day window is the only way back into a condono. Everything else goes through the ordinary sanatoria, which any owner can use at any time and which the Salva Casa decree (Decree-Law 69 of 29 May 2024, converted by Law 105 of 24 July 2024) reshaped.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
How sanatoria works after the Salva Casa decree
Article 36: full double conformity
For the most serious cases, such as work with no permit at all or totally different from it, article 36 of the Building Code still applies. The work can be legalised only if it complied with both the planning rules and the building rules in force when it was built and those in force when the application is made. This double test is strict. Many older extensions fail it because the planning rules were tighter then, or have tightened since.
Article 36-bis: the simplified route
The Salva Casa decree added article 36-bis for partial differences, essential variations and work done without or unlike a SCIA. Here the test is easier: the work must comply with the planning rules in force when the application is made, and with the building rules in force when it was built. The town hall can attach conditions, such as safety works or removing the parts that cannot be legalised.
The law sets the payment. For a permit or SCIA in sanatoria under article 36-bis it is in principle twice the building contribution the work would have attracted, with an increase for partial differences and essential variations that do not meet full double conformity. For other works it is linked to the increase in the property's value, within limits the article sets. Either way, the legalisation takes effect only once the full sum is paid.
Protected areas
Where a home sits in an area protected for its landscape, or is itself a listed building, legalisation also needs the protection authority's approval, and the rules are narrower. Work that created new volume or floor area in a protected area is very hard to legalise. Our guide to listed and historic buildings at auction covers the extra layer.
Tolerances: when a difference is not a violation
Not every difference between plans and reality is unauthorised work. Article 34-bis of the Building Code says that a difference of up to 2% in height, distances, volume, covered area or other measures of a single unit is not a violation. For work completed by 24 May 2024, the Salva Casa decree widened that tolerance on a sliding scale for smaller homes: 3% for units of 300 to 500 square metres of usable area, 4% for 100 to 300, 5% for 60 to 100, and 6% for units under 60 square metres. The basic 2% tolerance also applies to minimum distances and hygiene requirements; the wider scale is generally read as not extending to them, and a technician confirms how it applies to a particular home.
There are also execution tolerances for small faults in building work, such as minor shifts in internal openings or small changes in finishes, again extended for older work. A technician declares them in a filing or a statement, and no fine is due. For a court buyer, tolerances matter because a difference the report lists as a problem may, on a closer technical look, turn out not to be one.
What cannot be legalised?
Some work fails every test: built where nothing could be built, too large for any rule, in breach of a landscape protection or of anti-seismic rules that cannot be met after the event. The town hall can then order it removed. Article 31 of the Building Code governs work with no permit or totally different from it: the owner must demolish within 90 days, and if they do not, the law allows the town hall to take the building and the land it stands on.
Demolition orders are not cancelled by the transfer decree. An order made by the town hall, and an order of demolition made by a criminal court as part of a sentence, follow the building into the buyer's hands. For partial differences, article 34 allows a fine instead of demolition where removing the unauthorised part would damage the lawful part, but that is a decision for the town hall, and the work does not thereby become fully legal.
If a report says that work cannot be legalised, treat it as a serious finding. The expert normally deducts the cost of removing it from the valuation, but the real cost can be higher, and a home that relies on that work, such as a flat whose only bathroom sits in an illegal extension, may be worth far less once it is gone.
What if the land registry plan does not match the home?
The land registry (catasto) is a tax register. It records each property's plan (planimetria catastale), category, size and cadastral income. It is not a planning record: a home can be correctly recorded and still unauthorised, and a fully legal home can have an out-of-date plan. The two questions are often confused, because both are about how the building is recorded.
In a private sale, the deed must include the owner's statement that the registry data and plan match the property, and a deed without it is void. The notaries' view, followed in practice, is that this rule covers deeds and private agreements between the parties, not a judge's transfer decree, so a court sale can go ahead with a mismatch. Some courts nonetheless have the expert or the delegate correct the records before the sale; others leave it to the buyer.
Correcting a mismatch is usually a modest job: a surveyor compares the registry plan with the building and files an updated plan and data with the registry. Operation Sicily covers a geometra's cadastral check. It matters because the next deed will need the conformity statement: a resale, a mortgage on the home, a gift. If the mismatch reflects unauthorised work, the registry update does not legalise it, and the planning problem has to be solved first or alongside.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get a lot report for every home, with its planning and land registry findings in plain English, and a lawyer summary pack to hand to a surveyor.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
How much does legalising work cost?
Costs vary too much from home to home and town to town for a fair general figure, and the report's estimate is exactly that. What can be said is where the money goes:
- The technician's fees for the survey, the drawings, the application and any structural checks. These are often the largest part for small irregularities.
- The fine or payment the law sets for the route used: the amnesty sums under the 120-day window, or the payment under article 36 or 36-bis.
- Building contributions and other charges the town hall levies.
- Works needed to bring the building into line: removing part of an extension, changing a window, adding a ventilation duct, or structural work in a seismic area.
- Registry and filing fees, which are usually small.
A routine internal difference may cost little more than a technician's afternoon and a filing. A larger extension can run to a significant share of a cheap home's price. Demolition, where it is required, can cost more than the work it removes. Renovation on top is a separate cost, outside the scope of this guide.
Time matters as much as money. An application can take months, longer with a protection authority involved, and some steps, such as a mortgage or a resale, wait until it is done.
Why the expert's estimate is only an estimate
The court expert has to say whether irregularities can be legalised and roughly at what cost, and deducts that cost from the valuation. It is a useful anchor, but there are good reasons to treat it with care. The expert works to a deadline and a fee, often without the full planning history. Town halls differ in how they apply the same rules. The law itself changed with the Salva Casa decree, so a report written before it may describe a route that has since become easier, or assess a tolerance that has since been widened. And the cost of a technician's work and of building work changes over time.
A careful report can be right on every point. A thin one can miss a problem altogether, especially where the expert could not get in. That is why buyers who are serious about a home with irregularities have their own technician look at the planning file before they bid.
Who checks a home's planning status?
A geometra or architect registered in Italy, ideally local, who knows the town hall and its records. They can review the planning history held by the municipality, compare it with the building and the registry plan, say which differences are tolerances, which can be legalised and by which route, and estimate the work and fees. A lawyer joins in where the 120-day window, a demolition order or a dispute is involved. Our guide on who checks what before you bid explains the roles.
Remember the deadlines. You have until the offer deadline to decide, and from the award until the balance is due to arrange finance. If a bank is lending, it will want to know the planning position too. Our guide to auction mortgages explains why banks are cautious about unauthorised work.
How irregularities affect resale and lending
Because the nullity rule applies to private deeds, a home you buy at auction with serious unauthorised work cannot easily be sold on until the work is legalised or removed. A notary will not draw up a deed without the permit references and, where needed, the sanatoria. Banks lending against the home usually want the same. The court sale was the exception; your resale will not be. Our guide to selling or renting an auction home covers what a later buyer will ask for.
Put simply: buying at auction lets you acquire a home with problems, but it does not let you pass those problems on. Plan to deal with them as part of the purchase, and price them in from the start.
Is an irregularity a reason to walk away?
Most homes in Italy built before the 1990s differ from their plans somewhere, and many court auction homes carry a minor irregularity that a technician can settle. The serious cases are fewer: whole buildings without permits, large extensions in protected areas, demolition orders already issued. Knowing which kind you are looking at is what turns a frightening line in a report into a cost you can plan for, or a reason to let the home go. Our overview of what can go wrong puts planning problems alongside the other risks in court papers.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
Can you buy a house with unauthorised building work at an Italian court auction?
Yes. The rule that voids private deeds for homes without valid permits does not apply to court sales, so the transfer decree is valid. But nothing is legalised by the sale: the buyer takes the home with its irregularities and must deal with them.
What is the 120-day rule for building amnesty after a court auction?
Court buyers may apply under the old amnesty laws of 1985, 1994 or 2003 within 120 days of the transfer decree, but only for work those amnesties would have covered and where the other conditions are met. The window does not restart if the problem is found later, save in the rare case where it could not have been found at all.
What is the difference between condono and sanatoria in Italy?
A condono is a one-off amnesty that legalised work breaking the rules; Italy has had three, all closed to the general public. A sanatoria is the permanent route for work that meets the rules, under articles 36 and 36-bis of the Building Code, paid for with a sum the law sets.
Did the Salva Casa decree make it easier to legalise auction homes?
For smaller irregularities, yes. It widened the tolerances for older homes, especially small ones, and created a simplified sanatoria for partial differences under article 36-bis. It did not change the rules for work with no permit, and it opened no new amnesty.
Does a land registry mismatch stop an Italian court sale?
Generally not. The conformity statement required in private deeds is not treated as a condition of the court's transfer decree. But the mismatch must be corrected before a resale, a mortgage on the home or most later deeds.
Can a demolition order survive an Italian court auction?
Yes. Demolition orders by the town hall or a criminal court are not cancelled by the transfer decree and follow the building to the new owner. If an order is ignored, the law can let the town hall take the building and its land.
Sources
- Building Code (DPR 380/2001), article 46: court sales and the 120-day window (Normattiva)
- Building Code (DPR 380/2001), article 36-bis: simplified sanatoria (Normattiva)
- Building Code (DPR 380/2001), article 34-bis: building tolerances (Normattiva)
- Building Code (DPR 380/2001), article 31: work without a permit and demolition (Normattiva)
- Law 47 of 28 February 1985, article 40: amnesty application after a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Decree-Law 69 of 29 May 2024 (Salva Casa) (Normattiva)
- Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 173-bis: what the expert's report must cover (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

