Prices and rounds

Failed rounds and price cuts: why prices fall, what happens when nobody bids, and the risks of waiting

Short answer

When nobody makes a valid offer, an Italian court auction round is declared deserted (asta deserta) and a new round follows, usually at a lower price. Each cut can be up to a quarter, and up to half after four deserted rounds. The 75% offer floor falls too, but waiting is a gamble: more bidders arrive, and sales can stop.

Key facts

  • A round with no valid offer is declared deserted, and the delegate sets a new one.
  • Each new starting price can be up to 25% lower; after four deserted rounds, up to 50% lower.
  • Valid offers start at 75% of whatever the current starting price is.
  • The cuts are maximums set by the judge's order, not automatic, and courts differ.
  • A creditor can ask to take the property instead, and a judge can close a case that is going nowhere.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. What happens if nobody bids?
  2. How much the price can fall
  3. The 75% floor moves too
  4. Why homes fail to sell
  5. What can stop the cuts
  6. When a winner fails to pay
  7. Can the price go back up?
  8. One home, three rounds: an example
  9. How long between rounds
  10. The risks of waiting for a lower price
  11. Bidding on a home that has failed before
  12. How a lower price changes your costs
  13. Prices in insolvency sales
  14. Reading the numbers in a notice
  15. Who benefits when prices fall

Many Italian court auction homes do not sell the first time. Some come back once, some three or four times, and a few return again and again for years. Each time a round passes with no buyer, the price usually falls. That is the main reason court auction prices can end up far below the court's own valuation, and it is the part of the system that most surprises new buyers.

Here is what a deserted round is, how far the price can fall, what happens to the 75% offer floor, what stops the cuts, and why waiting is less of a sure thing than it looks. The rules below are the general ones; each case follows its own sale order.

What happens if nobody bids?

A round is deserted (asta deserta) when the offer deadline passes and no valid offer has arrived. That includes the case where offers were sent but all were void, for example because the deposit arrived late or the price was below the floor. The delegate records it in the minutes, reports to the judge, and sets a new round.

Australians and New Zealanders would say the property was passed in. Unlike an auction in Australia or Britain, there is no secret reserve: the starting price and the lowest valid offer are printed in every notice.

A round can also fail in other ways. A single offer below the starting price can be refused if the delegate thinks a new round will do better, or if a creditor has asked to take the property. A winner can fail to pay the balance, which forfeits their deposit and sends the home back to sale. Each of these leads to another round, though not always at a lower price.

How much the price can fall

The rule sits in article 591 of the Code of Civil Procedure. When a round is deserted, the judge, or the delegate under the sale order, can set a new starting price up to a quarter lower than the last one. After the fourth deserted round, the cut can go up to half.

Two words in that rule matter: up to. The cuts are limits, not fixed steps. Many sale orders tell the delegate to cut by the full quarter each time, because that is the quickest way to find a buyer. Others choose smaller cuts, or ask the delegate to report to the judge after a set number of rounds. The notice of each round shows the new starting price, so you never have to work it out.

The 75% floor moves too

An offer is valid if it is at least 75% of the current starting price. So every cut lowers both the starting price and the floor. A home that starts at €100,000 accepts offers from €75,000. After one full cut the starting price is €75,000 and the floor is €56,250. After two, €56,250 and €42,188. After three, €42,188 and €31,641.

If a fourth round is also deserted and the court applies a cut of half, the next starting price is €21,094 and offers become valid from €15,820. In five rounds the lowest valid offer has fallen from €75,000 to under €16,000, about 16% of the first starting price and less still of the original valuation.

These figures show the maximum the rules allow. Real lots often fall more slowly, and many sell long before the price gets this low.

Why homes fail to sell

A home can fail to sell for good reasons or bad ones. Knowing which is which is the whole skill of buying late in the rounds.

  • The starting price was too high. The valuation may predate a fall in local prices, or the expert may have been optimistic.
  • The home has a serious problem in its papers: a tenant who can stay, building work that cannot be legalised, a partial share, a court claim.
  • It is in a place with little demand: a remote village, an empty town centre, an area with many similar homes for sale.
  • It is hard to judge: the expert could not get in, the photos are poor, or the report leaves gaps.
  • It is the wrong kind of property for most buyers: a ruin, a large commercial building, a share of land.
  • It was hard to understand. Notices are in legal Italian, and many potential buyers cannot judge them.

Only the last reason says nothing about the home itself. The others are reasons the price has to fall before someone will take the risk. A lot on its sixth round with a low price may be a sound home that was simply hard to read, or a home whose papers explain exactly why nobody wanted it.

What can stop the cuts

Prices cannot fall forever, and several things can interrupt the cycle.

A creditor takes the property

A creditor can ask the court to assign the property to them instead of selling it (assegnazione), at no less than the current starting price. If that request is on file, a single low offer can be refused in favour of the creditor. Banks and loan investors use this when they think the price has fallen below what the home is worth to them.

The judge closes the case

If the sales keep failing and the price has fallen so far that the creditors are unlikely to be paid anything meaningful, the judge can close the case as pointless (chiusura anticipata per infruttuosità). The seizure is lifted, and the property stays with its owner, mortgages and all. This usually happens only after many rounds, but it means the cheapest prices may never arrive.

The debtor pays, or the creditors stop

At any point before the award the debtor can settle the debt, or the creditors can agree to stop. The case then ends, sometimes days before a round. All the creditors together can also ask the judge to suspend the sale, for up to two years.

Other routes

The judge can order the property to be managed and let for a time instead of sold, or change the sale format. In insolvency cases the liquidator can choose other ways to sell, within the rules of the Business Crisis Code.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

When a winner fails to pay

Not every failed round is deserted. Sometimes a buyer wins and then does not pay the balance on time (after you win explains that deadline). The judge then revokes the award, the buyer's deposit is kept by the procedure, and the home goes back to sale. If it later sells for less, the defaulting buyer can be ordered to pay the difference, on top of the deposit they have already lost.

A home that comes back this way does not always come back cheaper. The new round is often set at the same starting price, because someone was willing to pay it. For other buyers this can be a second chance at a home they missed, sometimes with less competition than the first time.

Can the price go back up?

Usually not, but it can happen. If a case is suspended for a long time and then restarts, or if the property changes, for example because an occupant leaves or a planning problem is solved, the judge can ask the expert to update the valuation. A new valuation can be higher than the last starting price. Sales can also be split or merged into different lots, which changes the prices too.

One home, three rounds: an example

Picture a three-room flat in a provincial town, valued at €95,000 and put up for sale at €85,000. It has a small unauthorised extension that the expert says can be legalised for a few thousand euros, and it is empty. The first round draws no offers: the starting price sits above what local buyers pay for flats that need work.

The second round, at €63,750 with offers valid from about €47,800, also passes quietly over the summer. On the third round, at €47,800, two buyers make offers. One offers the floor of about €35,900; the other offers €41,000. Bidding starts from €41,000 and finishes at €49,500, above the starting price of that round and well above the floor that tempted both of them to wait.

Nothing about this example is unusual. The price fell because the first figure was too high, not because the flat was bad, and the moment it reached a fair level, buyers competed for it. A buyer who had decided to wait for the fourth round would never have had the chance.

How long between rounds

There is no fixed gap. Once a round is deserted, the delegate needs to set the new terms and publish a new notice, and the law requires the notice to be public for a period before the new deadline. In practice the gap between rounds is often a few months, longer in busy courts or over the summer, and shorter in courts that schedule rounds in batches.

Add the steps up together and a home that goes through five rounds can easily spend a year or more on the market. For a buyer, that is a long time to wait for a price that may never come.

For members

Every price cut, on record

Members see when a home's price has been cut, by how much, and how many rounds it has been through, with alerts when a cut matches their searches.

See membership
Price historyExample
First round
€60,000
Second round
€48,000
Now, third round
€38,400

The risks of waiting for a lower price

It is tempting to spot a home and wait for the next cut. Sometimes it works. Often it does not, for reasons buyers tend to underestimate.

  • A lower price brings more bidders. A home that drew no offers at €80,000 may draw five at €60,000, and the bidding can push it back above where it started.
  • The case can end. A debtor who pays, or a creditor who settles, takes the home off the market without warning.
  • A creditor can take it. If the price falls below what the bank thinks the home is worth, it may ask for assignment.
  • The home can change. Empty homes deteriorate, and occupied ones can acquire new problems.
  • Your own position can change: interest rates, exchange rates, your savings, your plans.

The honest way to think about a later round is not "how low will it go" but "what is this home worth to me, with all its problems, and is the current floor below that figure?" If it is, and the papers are sound, waiting risks losing it. If it is not, no cut may ever make it right.

Bidding on a home that has failed before

Lots on later rounds deserve the most careful reading of all. Ask why the earlier rounds failed. Read the *perizia* again with that question in mind, and check whether anything has changed since it was written: arrears, occupancy, the state of the building. If several rounds have passed, ask whether the report is still current, and whether a surveyor should look again.

Remember that the lowest valid offer is a floor, not a target. If you are the only bidder, an offer below the starting price can still be refused. If you are not, the bidding starts from the highest offer, not from the floor. Our guide to bidding explains how the opening works.

How a lower price changes your costs

A cut lowers more than the price. Registration tax is a percentage of the price, so it falls too, down to its minimum of €1,000. The delegate's fee scale steps down at €100,000 and €500,000. The deposit, at least 10% of your offer, shrinks with the offer.

Some costs do not move at all. Condominium arrears, the cost of legalising works and the cost of a renovation are the same whatever you pay for the home, so on a cheap lot they make up a much larger share of the total. On a home that has fallen to €15,000, the current and previous year's condominium arrears and a planning fix can add half as much again. The tax relief that lets private buyers pay on the cadastral value also stops helping once the price falls below that value. Our guide to buying costs explains each one.

Prices in insolvency sales

Bankruptcy and liquidation sales follow the liquidator's sale programme, approved by the court, rather than the foreclosure rules. Prices still fall when sales fail, and many programmes follow the same pattern of cuts, but the liquidator has more freedom over how much and how often. The notice of each round always shows the current price and the minimum offer.

Reading the numbers in a notice

Every notice gives the starting price and the lowest valid offer for that round. On its own, a single notice says little about how the price got there. Members see each lot's price history and how many rounds it has been through.

Neither figure tells you what the home will sell for. Starting prices are set by rules, not by the market, and a lot can sell well above its starting price or fail at a fraction of it. What the numbers do tell you is where the floor is today, and how much risk the court has already priced in.

Who benefits when prices fall

Falling prices are hard on the people the system was built to protect. Each cut means less for the creditors and a larger share of the debt left unpaid, and the debtor, often a family, remains liable for what the sale does not cover. Courts cut prices because a sale at a fair price, found quickly, is better for everyone than a home that sits empty for years. Buyers who understand that are better placed to judge when a price is fair, rather than simply low.

For the full process from seizure to sale, see how Italian court auctions work.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What happens if nobody bids at an Italian court auction?

The round is declared deserted (asta deserta) and the delegate sets a new one, usually at a starting price up to a quarter lower. After several failed rounds a creditor may ask to take the home instead, and if sales keep failing the judge can close the case.

How much does the price drop after a failed Italian court auction?

By up to a quarter each time, and by up to half after the fourth deserted round. These are maximums set in the Code of Civil Procedure; the judge's sale order decides the actual cut, and some courts cut by less.

Is there a lowest price an Italian court auction can reach?

There is no fixed floor, but a creditor can ask to take the property instead, and a judge can close a case when continuing to sell would be pointless. Either can end the cuts before the price gets very low.

Should I wait for the next price cut?

It is a gamble. A lower price brings more bidders, the case can end without warning, and a creditor can take the property. Decide what the home is worth to you and bid if the current floor is below that.

Why do some Italian auction homes fail to sell many times?

Often because of a problem in the papers, such as a tenant who can stay or building work that cannot be legalised, a starting price set too high, or a location with little demand. Sometimes simply because few buyers could make sense of the papers.

Sources

  1. Code of Civil Procedure, article 591: new rounds and price cuts (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 588: a creditor's request to take the property (Normattiva)
  3. Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 164-bis: closing a pointless case (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.