What can go wrong: 15 problems court papers can reveal, and what they cost you
Short answer
The main risks of buying at an Italian court auction are problems the sale does not remove: occupants or leases that bind you, building work that was never approved, condominium arrears, easements and other surviving rights, partial ownership, missing certificates and poor access. The court papers usually reveal them; the cost depends on which apply and how serious they are.
Key facts
- A court sale carries no warranty for defects, so a problem described in the papers becomes the buyer's problem.
- The transfer decree cancels mortgages and seizures, but not easements, leases that bind the buyer or planning irregularities.
- Condominium arrears for the current and previous year can be claimed from the new owner.
- Some building work can be legalised after the sale; some cannot, and may have to be removed.
- Most problems in Italian court papers are not reasons to walk away; they are costs and delays to price in before you bid.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- Why do court papers reveal so many problems?
- How much can a problem cost you?
- Who lives there, and what exactly is being sold
- Is the building legal and correctly recorded?
- What follows the home after the sale
- Services, land and place
- The sale itself
- What do the court papers not reveal?
- Does a low price mean a problem?
- Who should check each problem before you bid?
- Problems in proportion
Buyers from the United States often ask what the catch is. In an American foreclosure sale the catch is usually the title: junior liens, tax liens or homeowners' association claims that may survive, which is why title insurance and title searches matter so much there. In Italy the title side is unusually clean, because the judge's transfer decree orders the old mortgages and seizures removed. The catch sits elsewhere: in the building, in the people living in it, in rights that other people hold over it, and in the paperwork that the town hall never received.
Italian court sales are also sold with no warranty for defects. That makes the court papers, and the court expert's report (perizia) in particular, the closest thing to a disclosure statement you will get. Here are the fifteen problems those papers most often reveal, what each one means, what it tends to cost in money and time, and who can confirm it for a particular home. Several have their own guide, linked below. Our guide to the perizia explains the papers themselves.
Why do court papers reveal so many problems?
Partly because the homes are often in poor shape. A family that cannot pay its mortgage rarely spends on maintenance, and some homes stand empty for years while the case runs. But mostly it is because the court expert is required to look. Article 173-bis of the implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure lists what the report must cover: who occupies the home and on what basis, the charges that will survive the sale and those that will be cancelled, the planning and building status, whether unauthorised work can be legalised and at what cost, whether the land carries civic-use rights, and the running and unpaid condominium charges.
A private seller in Italy is not required to volunteer most of this, and many do not. So a court auction home can look worse on paper than a similar home on an estate agent's window, simply because someone has written its problems down. That is useful. The problems you know about can be priced. The ones you do not know about are the real risk.
This guide explains what each problem is and why it matters. It is not a method for reading a particular report. Every case is different, and a lawyer or surveyor (geometra) should confirm the position of any home before you bid.
How much can a problem cost you?
It helps to think about the cost of a problem in three ways rather than one. First, a one-off sum: arrears to pay, a fee to legalise a balcony, a fine, a professional's bill. Second, time: months before you can live in the home, rent it or sell it, which costs you rent elsewhere, a mortgage on an empty flat, or simply a summer lost. Third, the problems that cannot be fixed at any price, such as a lease you must honour for years or an extension that has to be demolished. Those change what the home is, not just what it costs.
The court expert's valuation already makes deductions for many of these, which is one reason the starting price sits below market value. Our guide to sold as-is and the court valuation explains how those deductions work and why they do not always match the real cost to you.
Who lives there, and what exactly is being sold
1. Occupants and leases
What it means: the home may be empty, lived in by the debtor and their family, let to a tenant, or occupied by someone with no right to be there. Most occupants can be removed after the sale through the order to free the property, which the court custodian carries out. Under the rules for cases started after 28 February 2023, that happens at no cost to the buyer. A lease with a legally certain date before the seizure, usually because it was registered, is different: it binds the buyer, generally within the limits the Civil Code sets, and a home assigned by a court to a separated spouse can also be protected.
What it can cost: for an occupant without a right to stay, mainly time, often months. For a binding lease, years of rent at the agreed figure instead of vacant possession, which can sharply lower what the home is worth to someone who wants to live in it. Who to ask: a lawyer, who reads the lease and its dates. Our guide to occupied homes at court auction covers this in depth.
2. Partial rights
What it means: not every lot is full ownership. Some are a share of a home owned with others, bare ownership while someone else keeps the right to live there for life (usufruct), or a right of residence. Each is a lawful thing to buy, but none is the same as buying a house.
What it can cost: a share gives you no right to move in alone, and turning it into something usable can mean a court action to divide the property, which takes years and legal fees. Bare ownership can leave you waiting decades. These lots are priced low for good reason. Who to ask: a lawyer. See bare ownership, usufruct and shares at auction.
3. Access to the property
What it means: a home or plot may have no recorded legal right of way to the public road. The track everyone uses may cross a neighbour's land by habit rather than by right. In flats, a cellar or parking space may only be reached through someone else's property. Separately, the expert may not have got inside at all, so the report rests on files and the outside of the building.
What it can cost: a landlocked property can usually obtain a right of way in the end, but by agreement or by a court case, with compensation to the neighbour and legal fees. Until then, building work, deliveries and resale all get harder. A report written without access adds uncertainty rather than a fixed cost. Who to ask: a lawyer for rights of way; a surveyor for the physical position.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
Is the building legal and correctly recorded?
4. Unauthorised building work
What it means: the building differs from what the town hall approved. It may be a closed-in balcony, a converted loft, an extra room, a larger footprint, or a whole house built without a permit. The gap between paper and reality is common in older homes; Italy has had three national building amnesties for exactly that reason.
What it can cost: small differences may fall within the tolerances the law allows and cost little or nothing beyond a technician's declaration. Larger ones can often be legalised for a fine and a technician's fees, sometimes with building work to bring them into line. Some cannot be legalised and may have to be demolished at the owner's expense, which on a home built largely without permission can wipe out most of its value. Who to ask: a geometra or architect. Our guide to unauthorised building work at court auction explains the special 120-day window for court buyers and its limits.
5. Land registry mismatch
What it means: the land registry (catasto) plan, category or size does not match the home as it is. A wall has moved, a storeroom has become a bedroom, or the building was never registered at all. This is a different question from planning legality: a home can be correctly recorded and still unauthorised, or approved and wrongly recorded.
What it can cost: usually modest. A surveyor files an update, and the registry fees are small. But it has to be done before most later steps, such as a resale before a notary or a mortgage on the home. Who to ask: a geometra.
6. No certificate of fitness for use
What it means: the agibilità (sometimes still called abitabilità) certifies that a building meets safety, hygiene and energy rules and can be used. Many older homes never had one, and homes with unauthorised work cannot obtain one until the work is dealt with.
What it can cost: its absence does not stop the court sale, and a home without one is not automatically illegal to live in. Obtaining it later means a technician's filing, and sometimes works to the systems or the building first. It can matter to a bank lending against the home and to a later buyer. Who to ask: a geometra or architect.
7. Energy certificate
What it means: the energy performance certificate (APE) rates the home's energy use. In a private sale it is required at the deed. The research office of Italy's national council of notaries takes the view that the obligation does not apply to court sales, and practice varies: some courts have the expert prepare one, many sales go ahead without.
What it can cost: little in itself, as a certificate is a short job for an accredited technician. You will need one to rent the home out or sell it. A poor rating tells you more than the missing paper does: an old, uninsulated home costs more to heat and to bring up to standard. Who to ask: an accredited technician.
What follows the home after the sale
8. Condominium arrears
What it means: in a building with shared parts (condominio), the debtor has usually stopped paying the building's charges. Article 63 of the implementing provisions of the Civil Code makes a new owner jointly liable with the old one for the current year's charges and the previous year's. Older arrears stay with the debtor.
What it can cost: two years of charges, which in a modest building may be a manageable sum and in a large building with a lift, heating and a caretaker can be considerable. The figure in the report is the one known when it was written, and it has usually grown by the time of the sale. Who to ask: the building's manager (amministratore), through your lawyer. See liens, condo fees and easements.
9. Approved or unpaid works
What it means: the building may have approved major works, such as a new roof, a facade or a lift, before the sale. Separately, the home itself may have half-finished works, sometimes started under a tax bonus scheme and abandoned when the money ran out, with builders still unpaid.
What it can cost: as a general rule, condominium works approved before you became owner are the previous owner's responsibility, but disputes over timing are common and the building may come to you first. Unfinished works in the home mean finishing them, and abandoned bonus works can bring their own complications. Builders' unpaid bills are the debtor's debt, not yours, unless they were secured on the home and the decree cancels them. Who to ask: a lawyer and the building's manager. See Superbonus homes at auction.
10. Easements and rights of way
What it means: an easement (servitù) is a right someone else holds over your property: a path across the garden, a drain under the floor, a ban on building above a certain height, a neighbour's window that must not be blocked. Easements are not cancelled by the transfer decree. They belong to the land, whoever owns it.
What it can cost: most are harmless and some are invisible in daily life. A few limit what you can build or how private the home is, which matters if you planned an extension or a pool. Who to ask: a lawyer, with a surveyor for the physical position.
11. Other charges that survive the sale
What it means: the decree clears mortgages and seizures, not everything. Court claims recorded before the seizure, planning restrictions, heritage listings with their own rules on sale and use, restrictions tying a parking space to a flat, price limits on some subsidised housing and civic-use rights on some rural land can all survive.
What it can cost: from nothing at all to the loss of the home, in the rare case where a court claim recorded before the seizure succeeds. Most buyers meet these as limits on use or resale rather than as bills. Who to ask: a lawyer. The liens guide linked above sets out what survives and why.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get flood, landslide and earthquake flags for each home, alongside its red flags from the court papers.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Services, land and place
12. Shared or missing utilities
What it means: water, gas or electricity may come through a neighbour's meter, from a shared well or tank, or through pipes that cross other land without a recorded right. Rural homes may have no mains sewer and a septic system that does not meet current rules. Supplies to an empty home have often been cut off.
What it can cost: reconnecting a supply in your name is routine, though it takes time. Separating a shared supply, bringing a septic system up to standard or paying for a new connection where none exists can be a real expense, and an informal arrangement with a neighbour can end when the neighbour changes. Who to ask: a surveyor, and the utility companies once you own the home.
13. Flood, landslide and earthquake zones
What it means: much of Italy sits in areas of seismic hazard, and many towns have zones exposed to floods or landslides. Public flood, landslide and earthquake hazard maps exist, but turning them into an answer for one building is technical work. A court expert describes the building and its legal position, and is not asked to assess these risks.
What it can cost: it can affect insurance, what you may build, whether a planning fix is possible, and what the home is worth to a later buyer. In seismic areas, structural work and some legalisations need extra technical checks. Who to ask: a structural engineer or geologist for a particular site.
14. Boundaries
What it means: the fence, the wall or the line of olive trees may not follow the boundary on the land registry map. Part of a garden may belong to a neighbour, or part of yours may be used by them. Where a neighbour has openly used a strip of land for twenty years, they may claim to own it by long possession (usucapione).
What it can cost: small differences are common in rural Italy and often left alone. Settling one formally means a survey, an agreement or a court case. A boundary dispute can hold up a resale or a building permit. Who to ask: a surveyor for the facts, a lawyer for a dispute. Rural lots carry more of this risk; see land, farmhouses and ruins at auction.
The sale itself
15. A sale postponed, suspended or cancelled
What it means: a sale can be postponed or cancelled before the offers are opened, most often because the debtor has paid or the creditors have settled. Rarely, a sale is suspended after the balance is paid, where the price is well below a fair one. The law protects a buyer whose award stands even if the case later ends.
What it can cost: your deposit is returned if the sale does not go ahead before the award. What you spent preparing, on a surveyor, a lawyer or a trip, is generally not. Who to ask: the delegate running the sale, through your lawyer. See suspended and cancelled sales.
What do the court papers not reveal?
The fifteen problems above are the ones a report can catch. Others it rarely can. The expert does not open walls, test wiring, check drains or measure damp. They visit once, sometimes briefly, sometimes not at all. The report can be a year or more old by the round you are looking at, and empty homes deteriorate, occupants come and go, and arrears grow in the meantime.
Nor does a report say whether the neighbours are noisy, the street floods in a storm, the village empties in winter or the views will be built over. Those are questions for a viewing and for local knowledge. A low price can hide any of them as easily as it can reflect them.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get a lot report for every home, with the problems in its court papers set out in plain English and a lawyer summary pack to hand to their own professional.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Does a low price mean a problem?
Often, but not always. Homes that fail to sell over several rounds fall in price, and sometimes the reason is a serious problem in the papers. Sometimes it is a starting price set too high, a place with little demand, or papers that few buyers could understand. Each deserted round can bring the price down. The useful question is not whether a home is cheap, but whether its price is low enough once its particular problems are counted.
Many of these costs are fixed whatever the price. Two years of condominium charges, a technician's fee and a fine for an old extension cost the same on a lot that has fallen to a small sum as on a large one, so on the cheapest homes they make up a much larger share of the total. Taxes and fees come on top of all of them.
Who should check each problem before you bid?
A lawyer, a geometra or architect, and sometimes a structural engineer each cover different problems from the list above. Our guide on who checks what before you bid explains each role, what it costs to send someone, and what none of them can tell you. The cost of these checks is small next to a deposit of at least a tenth of your offer, which you lose if you win and then cannot complete.
Problems in proportion
A list of fifteen problems can make court auctions sound like a minefield. They are not. Many homes carry one or two routine issues, such as a land registry mismatch and a small sum of arrears, that cost little to settle. Most families who lost these homes did not neglect them by choice; they ran out of money. Buyers who do well are the ones who learn which problems are routine, which are expensive, and which change what the home is, and who set their top price with all three in mind.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
What are the main risks of buying a house at auction in Italy?
Problems the sale does not remove: occupants or leases that bind the buyer, unauthorised building work, condominium arrears for the current and previous year, easements and other surviving rights, partial ownership, missing certificates and access issues. There is no warranty for defects, so what the papers describe becomes yours.
Does the court tell you about problems with an auction property in Italy?
Yes, to a point. The court expert must report on occupancy, surviving charges, planning status, condominium arrears and more. But the report is a snapshot, the expert does not open walls or test systems, and sometimes could not get in. It is the best source you have, not a guarantee.
Are Italian court auction homes in worse condition than other homes?
Often they look worse on paper, because the court expert must write down problems a private seller need not mention. Many have had little maintenance while the owner was in difficulty or the home stood empty. A low price can reflect real problems, or simply papers that few buyers took the time to read.
Which court auction problems are usually cheap to fix?
Land registry mismatches, small building differences within the legal tolerances, a missing energy certificate and modest condominium arrears are often routine. A binding lease, building work that cannot be legalised, a partial share or a court claim recorded before the seizure are the problems that can change what a home is worth.
Are Italian auction homes in flood or earthquake zones?
Some are, as are many ordinary homes in Italy. Public hazard maps exist, but the court expert is not asked to assess these risks for the home being sold. A structural engineer or geologist can advise on a particular site.
Do problems in the court papers make an Italian auction home harder to resell?
Some do. A land registry mismatch or unauthorised work has to be put right before a notary will draw up a later deed, and a bank lending to your buyer will want the same. Easements, binding leases and other surviving rights pass to the next owner too, so they weigh on the resale price as well as on yours.
Sources
- Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 173-bis: what the expert's report must cover (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree and cancellation of charges (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 560: the custodian and freeing the property (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2922: no warranty in a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2923: leases that bind the buyer at a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Implementing provisions of the Civil Code, article 63: condominium arrears and the new owner (Normattiva)
- Building Code (DPR 380/2001), article 46: court sales and the 120-day window (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

