Bidding and offers

Starting price, the 75% lowest offer and what happens on auction day

Short answer

An Italian court auction starts from a price set by the judge from the court valuation. Offers are valid from 75% of that price. A lone offer at the starting price wins; a lower one can be refused. With two or more, a contest starts from the highest, rising by a set minimum. If nobody raises, the best offer wins.

Key facts

  • The starting price (prezzo base) comes from the value the judge sets under article 568, and falls after deserted rounds.
  • The lowest valid offer (offerta minima) is 75% of the starting price, printed in every notice.
  • A single offer below the starting price can be refused if a better price looks likely or a creditor has asked to take the home.
  • With two or more valid offers, a contest (gara) starts from the highest, with raises of at least the minimum in the notice.
  • If nobody raises, the judge or delegate picks the best offer on price, deposit, payment terms and other useful elements.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. How is the starting price set?
  2. Can you offer less than the starting price?
  3. What happens if there is only one offer?
  4. What happens when two or more people bid?
  5. Who wins if nobody raises?
  6. Creditors who ask to take the home: assignment
  7. The minutes and the award
  8. A worked example
  9. What the rules mean for your offer

Two numbers sit at the top of every Italian court notice: the starting price and the lowest offer the court will consider. Buyers from the US, the UK, Canada, Australia and New Zealand tend to read them through their own auction habits, as an opening bid and a reserve, and both readings are slightly wrong. This guide explains where the numbers come from, what the law does with them, and what happens on the day the offers are opened, from a single offer through to a full contest between bidders.

It goes deeper than the overview in how to bid at an Italian court auction, which covers the whole process from preparing an offer to paying the balance. Here the focus is the price rules in articles 568 to 573 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the creditor's right to take the home instead, and a worked example with round numbers. Where a notice sets a rule of its own, such as the size of the minimum raise, the notice applies.

How is the starting price set?

Every court sale begins with a valuation. Under article 568, the judge sets the value of the property on the basis of its market value, using the report of the court-appointed expert (*perizia*) and anything the parties add. The law tells the expert to show the working: the floor area, the value per square metre, the total, and then each adjustment separately.

Article 568 makes the expert deduct for the lack of any warranty against defects, planning or building irregularities, the state of repair, occupation, burdens the sale will not remove and unpaid condominium charges. That is why the figure usually sits below what an estate agent would ask for a similar home. A buyer who reads those deductions knows what the court has already priced in.

The first round normally starts at the value set by the judge. That figure is the starting price (prezzo base). If a round passes with no valid offer, the next round can start up to a quarter lower, and after the fourth deserted round up to half lower, under article 591. Our guide to failed rounds and price cuts explains how those cuts work.

So the starting price you see may be the first-round value or a much lower figure after several cuts. Either way it is not the market value, and it is not a prediction of the final price. It is the reference point for the rules below.

The starting price is not a guide price in the British or Australian sense. It is a legal threshold. The real price is decided by the offers, and a popular home can sell well above it.

Can you offer less than the starting price?

Article 571 says an offer is not effective if it is more than a quarter below the price set in the sale order. In other words, an offer is valid from 75% of the starting price. Article 569 tells the judge to state that lowest offer (offerta minima) in the sale order, and every notice prints it. On a starting price of €100,000, the lowest valid offer is €75,000.

Three points about the 75% rule often trip people up.

  • Valid does not mean accepted. An offer between 75% and 100% of the starting price is admitted, but the law lets the delegate refuse it in some cases, explained below.
  • The 75% applies to the starting price of the current round. After a price cut, both the starting price and the lowest offer fall. An offer based on an older notice can be wrong in either direction.
  • There is no reserve beyond what is printed. Unlike a British or Australian auction, the seller has no undisclosed figure below which the home will not sell. The rules are public.

Other conditions also make an offer ineffective under article 571: arriving after the deadline, or coming without a deposit of at least one tenth of the price offered, paid as the sale order requires. Our guide to making a valid offer covers those in depth.

What happens if there is only one offer?

Article 572 deals with the single offer. The judge, or the delegate under the sale order, first hears the parties and any registered creditors who have not joined the case. Then:

  • If the offer equals or exceeds the starting price, it is accepted.
  • If the offer is below the starting price, but by no more than a quarter, the delegate can still sell to that bidder, as long as there is no serious likelihood of a higher price from a new sale and no creditor has asked for assignment.

In practice, many single offers below the starting price are accepted, because another round costs time and money and usually brings a lower starting price anyway. But it is a decision, not an automatic result. Some courts' orders tell delegates to accept below-base single offers in most cases; others ask for a reason to believe a new sale would do better before refusing. If you send a single offer at 75%, you are accepting the risk that it will be turned down.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

What happens when two or more people bid?

Article 573 says that where there are several offers, the bidders are invited to a contest on the highest offer. In everyday Italian this is the gara tra gli offerenti, the contest between bidders. Only those whose offers were valid can take part. Nobody can join on the day without having made an offer and lodged a deposit.

The contest starts from the highest offer received. If one bidder offered €80,000 and another €92,000, the contest starts from €92,000, and the first raise must take it higher. A bidder who offered less is not shut out: they can raise from the highest figure like everyone else.

The minimum raise (rilancio minimo)

Each raise must beat the previous bid by at least the minimum raise set in the sale order and printed in the notice. The law does not fix the amount. Courts usually set it as a fixed sum that grows with the starting price, so a low-value garage might move in steps of a few hundred euros and a large house in steps of several thousand. A raise smaller than the minimum is not valid.

Time between raises

How long bidders have to answer a raise depends on the format of the sale.

  • In a synchronous online sale or a mixed sale, the sale order sets a short reply time. If it passes without a new raise, the contest ends.
  • In an asynchronous online sale, raises can be made at any time in a window set by the sale order, often a day or more. Many orders extend the window by a short period when a raise arrives near the end.
  • In the rare open incanto, article 581 sets three minutes after the last bid.

Our guide to how court sales run explains the formats in detail.

When the contest ends

The highest bid when time runs out wins, subject to the assignment rule explained below. The delegate records the raises and the result in the minutes. In an online sale, the delegate also receives a signed list of the raises and the bidders.

Who wins if nobody raises?

Sometimes several offers arrive but nobody wants to raise. Perhaps the bidders do not connect, or each one had already offered their limit. Article 573 then asks the judge or delegate to identify the best offer. In doing so, the law says they take account of:

  1. the price offered;
  2. the size of the deposit;
  3. the forms, time and methods of payment;
  4. any other element in the offer that is useful to judge it.

Sale orders usually turn this into a sequence. The higher price wins. If prices are equal, the larger deposit wins. If that is equal too, the shorter payment term wins. If everything is equal, the offer that arrived first wins. The order matters to bidders because a larger deposit or a shorter term is a legitimate way to stand out in a tie. Check the notice: the exact sequence varies between courts.

For members

Every deadline, worked out for each home

Members get a bidding plan for each home with its own starting price, lowest valid offer, deposit and minimum raise set out in one place.

See membership
Bidding planExample
  • Offer deadlineOffer and deposit lodged12 Mar
  • AuctionOffers opened; bidding if more than one13 Mar
  • Balance duePrice less deposit, plus costs11 Jul
  • Transfer decreeWeeks to months after paymentSep

Creditors who ask to take the home: assignment

The rule that surprises foreign buyers most is assignment (assegnazione). Under article 588, any creditor can ask, at least ten days before the sale hearing, to be assigned the property, for itself or for a third party, in case the sale does not take place. Under article 589, the request must offer at least the starting price of that round, and enough to cover the costs of the case and any creditors who rank ahead.

An assignment request changes what happens to offers below the starting price.

  • A single offer below the starting price cannot be accepted if an assignment request has been filed (article 572).
  • If the best offer, where nobody raises, is below the starting price and an assignment request has been filed, the sale does not take place and the home is assigned (article 573).
  • If the contest ends below the starting price and an assignment request has been filed, the same happens (article 573).

In plain terms: if a creditor has offered the starting price, a bidder has to reach the starting price to win. A creditor's request is not normally shown in the notice of sale, so a buyer sending an offer below the starting price should always allow for this outcome. Offers at or above the starting price are not affected.

If assignment is granted, the judge makes an order under article 590 and sets a term for the creditor to pay any difference. For bidders, the effect is that their offers are not accepted and their deposits are returned.

The minutes and the award

Everything that happens at the opening is recorded in minutes (verbale): who offered, which offers were valid and why any were excluded, the raises in the contest, and the result. The winning bidder becomes the aggiudicatario, and the award (aggiudicazione) is recorded in the same minutes.

In a sale without incanto the award is final once made. Nobody can reopen it by offering more a few days later, as the law still allows after an incanto. From the award the clock for paying the balance starts, within the term in the notice, which the law caps at 120 days. Once the price is paid, the judge issues the transfer decree, which makes the buyer the owner. In rare cases, after payment, the judge can refuse the decree and suspend the sale if the price is far below the fair one; our guide to suspended and cancelled sales explains when.

Losing bidders get their deposits back. In an online sale they go back to the account they were paid from; in a paper sale a banker's draft is usually handed back at the opening. The steps after the award are covered in what happens after you win.

A worked example

The figures below are invented and rounded to make the rules easy to follow. They are not drawn from any real sale.

A flat has a court value of €120,000. It went unsold in the first round, and the second round starts at €100,000. The notice sets the lowest valid offer at €75,000 and a minimum raise of €2,000. Four offers arrive by the deadline.

  • Bidder A offers €75,000 with a deposit of €7,500, payment within 120 days.
  • Bidder B offers €90,000 with a deposit of €9,000, payment within 120 days.
  • Bidder C offers €90,000 with a deposit of €18,000, payment within 60 days.
  • A fourth offer of €70,000 is excluded, because it is below the lowest valid offer.

Scenario one: a contest

With three valid offers, the delegate opens a contest from €90,000. Bidder A raises to €92,000. Bidder B raises to €94,000. Bidder C raises to €96,000. A and B stop. The contest ends at €96,000 and C is the winner. Because €96,000 is below the starting price of €100,000, the result stands only if no creditor has filed an assignment request. If one has, the sale does not take place, the home goes to the creditor, and all three deposits are returned.

Scenario two: nobody raises

Suppose none of the three bidders raises. The delegate must pick the best offer. B and C offered the same price, €90,000, but C lodged a larger deposit and offered to pay sooner. Under a typical order C wins at €90,000. If a creditor has asked for assignment, the same problem arises as before, because €90,000 is below the starting price.

Scenario three: one offer

Now suppose only Bidder B had offered, at €90,000. That is within a quarter of the starting price, so the offer is valid. The delegate can accept it unless a new sale seems likely to fetch more or a creditor has asked for assignment. If B had offered €100,000, the starting price, it would have been accepted.

In each scenario, the winner then pays the balance, the price less the deposit already paid, plus the sum for transfer costs the delegate asks for, within the term in the offer.

What the rules mean for your offer

None of this tells you what to offer on a particular home, and no general rule can. But the law does shape a few sensible principles.

  • An offer at the starting price removes two risks at once: refusal of a lone offer and loss to an assignment request.
  • An offer near 75% is a legitimate choice, especially after several deserted rounds, but it accepts both risks.
  • Your written offer is your floor in any contest, not your ceiling. Decide your true limit before the opening, including buying costs, arrears and works.
  • In a tie, a larger deposit or a shorter payment term can decide the result, so only offer terms you can truly meet.
  • If you win and then fail to pay, you lose the deposit and can be made to pay the difference if the home later sells for less.

The buying costs guide sets out the taxes and fees that sit on top of the price, which every limit should include.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What is the minimum offer at an Italian court auction?

The lowest valid offer (offerta minima) is 75% of the starting price of the current round, printed in the notice. Anything lower is ineffective. An offer between 75% and 100% is valid but can still be refused in some cases.

Can I raise in the contest if my written offer was the lowest?

Yes. Every bidder whose offer was valid can take part in the contest, and it starts from the highest offer received. A lower written offer does not shut you out; your first raise simply has to beat the highest figure by at least the minimum raise.

What is the gara tra offerenti?

The contest between bidders that follows when two or more valid offers arrive. It starts from the highest offer, and each raise must beat the last by at least the minimum raise in the notice. The highest bid when time runs out wins.

How is the minimum raise set at an Italian court auction?

By the judge's sale order, and printed in the notice of sale. The law does not fix it. Courts usually set a fixed amount that rises with the starting price.

Is the starting price at an Italian court auction a reserve price?

Not quite. Offers from 75% of the starting price are valid, so a home can sell below it, and a single offer between 75% and 100% can be accepted or refused. It is a legal threshold set by the court, not a seller's undisclosed reserve or a British guide price.

What is assegnazione in an Italian court sale?

A creditor's request to take the property itself, or for a third party, if the sale does not take place. It must offer at least the starting price. If one is filed, offers below the starting price cannot win.

Is the starting price the same as the court valuation?

In the first round it usually is: the judge sets the value from the expert's report, and the first starting price normally equals it. After deserted rounds the starting price is cut, so it can sit well below the valuation; our guide to price cuts explains how.

Sources

  1. Code of Civil Procedure, article 568: how the value is set (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 569: the sale order, the lowest offer and the payment term (Normattiva)
  3. Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: the 75% rule and the deposit (Normattiva)
  4. Code of Civil Procedure, article 572: deciding on a single offer (Normattiva)
  5. Code of Civil Procedure, article 573: the contest and the best offer (Normattiva)
  6. Code of Civil Procedure, article 588: who can ask for assignment, and when (Normattiva)
  7. Code of Civil Procedure, article 589: what an assignment request must offer (Normattiva)
  8. Code of Civil Procedure, article 591: price cuts after deserted rounds (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.