Court papers and red flags

Liens, unpaid condo fees (HOA dues) and easements: what the court clears and what you inherit

Short answer

An Italian court auction clears liens that secure debts: the transfer decree orders every mortgage and seizure cancelled, including those recorded after the seizure. It does not clear easements, court claims recorded before the seizure, binding leases, planning burdens or demolition orders. Condominium arrears for the current and previous year can also be claimed from you.

Key facts

  • Article 586 of the Code of Civil Procedure orders the cancellation of the mortgages and seizures on the property, except a loan the buyer chooses to take over.
  • Easements, heritage and planning restrictions and demolition orders survive the sale.
  • A court claim recorded before the seizure can bind the buyer; one recorded after it cannot.
  • An Italian auction buyer is jointly liable with the debtor for condominium charges for the current and previous year.
  • Who pays the duties to cancel the old entries depends on the court.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. Do Italian court auctions clear liens?
  2. Who does the title search at an Italian court auction?
  3. What survives an Italian court sale?
  4. Entries that stay on the register but do not bind you
  5. Who pays to cancel the old entries in the registers?
  6. Do you pay unpaid condo fees after an Italian court auction?
  7. What about property tax, utilities and other bills?
  8. Comparing Italy with the United States, Canada, Australia and the UK
  9. Which charges matter most before you bid?

In the United States, the question "do foreclosure auctions clear liens?" has an awkward answer: it depends on the state, the kind of sale and the kind of lien. A mortgage foreclosure usually wipes out junior liens, but property tax liens survive, some states give homeowners' associations a super-priority claim, and federal tax liens have rules of their own. That is why American buyers run title searches and buy title insurance.

Italy is simpler on the debt side and more complicated on everything else. The judge's transfer decree clears every mortgage and seizure on the property, whoever holds them. But some rights are not debts at all and are not cleared, and the building's unpaid charges have their own rule. Here is what the court clears, what you inherit, how the condominium rule works, who pays to tidy up the registers, and how to think about all of it before you bid. Our guide to closing and the transfer decree covers the decree itself.

Do Italian court auctions clear liens?

For debts secured on the home, yes. Article 586 of the Code of Civil Procedure says the transfer decree orders the cancellation of the recorded seizures (pignoramenti) and mortgages (ipoteche), including those recorded after the seizure. That covers the bank's mortgage that started the case, second mortgages, judicial mortgages that other creditors registered after winning a court judgment, and mortgages registered by the tax collector. Precautionary attachments that have turned into seizures go too.

Italy has no general lien for unpaid property tax, utility bills or builders' invoices that attaches to the home the way some American liens do. A creditor who wants security on a property must register a mortgage or a seizure in the property registers, and those are exactly the entries the decree clears. The creditors are paid, in their order of priority, from the price you pay, not from you.

Cancellation is not instant. After the decree, the delegate registers it and sends the cancellation orders to the property registers. Until that is done the old entries still appear on a search, which matters if you want to borrow against the home or sell it quickly.

Who does the title search at an Italian court auction?

Before a sale can be ordered, the creditor must file a history of the property in the registers covering at least the twenty years before the seizure, either as register extracts or as a notary's certificate. The court expert then checks it and reports, under article 173-bis of the implementing provisions, which charges will be cancelled and which will remain the buyer's concern. In US terms, the court has done the title search for you, and the decree clears what a title search would worry about most, though nobody insures the result.

That does not make the papers infallible. Errors in the history, an entry missed by the expert, or a report written before a new claim was recorded can all leave gaps. A lawyer acting for you can review the position, and for any home with an unusual history, such as an inheritance never formally accepted or a co-owner outside the case, it is worth doing.

What survives an Italian court sale?

Some rights and burdens attach to the land itself or to the building's legal status. They are not debts of the owner, so selling the home to pay the owner's debts does not remove them.

Easements and rights of way

An easement (servitù) gives a neighbour, a utility or the public a right over your property: a path, a drain, a power line, a limit on building height, a right to light. Easements recorded before the seizure bind the buyer, and so do visible ones acquired by long use or created by the layout of the land, which may not be recorded at all. Most are harmless; some decide where you can build. Our glossary defines the term.

Court claims recorded before the seizure

Certain lawsuits about a property can be recorded (trascritte) in the registers: a claim that an earlier sale should be set aside, a claim to enforce a promise to sell, a claim to ownership. Under article 2915 of the Civil Code, a claim recorded after the seizure does not affect the creditors or the auction buyer. One recorded before the seizure can, and if it succeeds the buyer can lose the home, or part of it. This is rare, but it is one of the few ways a court buyer can lose the property itself. If that happens, the Civil Code lets the buyer recover the price from the proceeds of the sale or from the creditors who received it, which is cold comfort after years of litigation.

Leases and family homes that bind the buyer

A lease with a legally certain date before the seizure, usually because it was registered, binds the buyer under article 2923 of the Civil Code, generally within the limits that article sets, and a home assigned to a separated spouse by a court can also be protected depending on when the assignment was recorded. These are covered in detail in our guide to occupied homes at court auction.

Planning and heritage burdens

Restrictions that come from planning and heritage law survive because they attach to the land and the building: landscape protection, a heritage listing, a ban on building in a hazard zone, an undertaking given to the town hall to keep part of a plot free. Some garages and parking spaces built under the Tognoli law are tied to homes in the same town and can be sold separately only under strict conditions. Some homes built under subsidised-housing agreements carry limits on resale price or on who may buy. Our guide to listed and historic buildings at auction covers the heritage side.

Demolition orders

An order to demolish unauthorised work, whether made by the town hall or by a criminal court, is not a debt and is not cleared. It follows the building. Our guide to unauthorised building work explains what can still be legalised and what cannot.

Civic-use rights

Some land, mostly rural and in particular regions, is subject to ancient civic-use rights (usi civici), such as the right of local people to graze animals or gather wood. These lands follow special rules and can be unsaleable in the ordinary way until the rights are formally released. The court expert must check for them, and where they exist the question is one for a specialist lawyer.

Family funds

A married couple or civil partners can place a home in a family fund (fondo patrimoniale). Creditors cannot seize it for debts they knew were taken on for purposes outside the family's needs, provided the fund was properly recorded before the seizure; a fund set up to dodge existing debts can in turn be attacked by the creditors. The debtor can raise the fund to challenge the seizure, and the court resolves that during the case. It is not normally a burden you take over, but it is one reason a sale can be suspended or a case can end, and an issue a lawyer will want to see settled in the papers.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Entries that stay on the register but do not bind you

The decree orders only mortgages and seizures cancelled. Other entries recorded after the seizure, such as a later court claim or a later sale by the debtor, do not bind the buyer, but they can stay in the registers. They are harmless in law but untidy in practice, because a later buyer's notary or a bank will ask about them. Removing them can need a separate application to the judge. A good report flags them, and a lawyer can deal with them after the decree.

Who pays to cancel the old entries in the registers?

Cancelling each mortgage and seizure carries duties in the registers. Our guide to buying costs explains how they are worked out. The law does not set one rule for who pays them, and courts differ. In some, the standard instructions treat cancellation as a cost of the procedure, paid from the sale proceeds before the creditors. In others, the sale order puts it on the buyer, who pays it with the transfer costs. It is one of the points a lawyer checks, because on a lot with many creditors the difference can be noticeable.

For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members get a lot report for every home, with the charges that survive the sale and the condominium arrears from its papers set out in plain English.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

Do you pay unpaid condo fees after an Italian court auction?

If the home is a flat or a house in a building with shared parts, its owner pays a share of the building's running costs (spese condominiali): cleaning, lighting, insurance, the lift, sometimes heating, and maintenance. North Americans know these as condo fees or HOA dues, Australians as strata levies, the British as service charges. An owner in financial trouble usually stops paying them early.

Article 63 of the implementing provisions of the Civil Code says that anyone who takes over an owner's rights is jointly liable with that owner for the charges of the current year and the previous year. The courts apply it to buyers at forced sales. The years are counted back from when you become owner, which is the date of the transfer decree. Charges older than that remain the debtor's debt alone, and the building must pursue the debtor for them, often by joining the court case as a creditor.

Joint liability means the building can ask you for the whole of the two years and leave you to recover it from the debtor, which in practice is rarely possible. So treat the sum as a cost of buying. Whether "year" means the calendar year or the building's own accounting year is a point on which the courts have not settled, and it can change the figure.

The court expert must report the unpaid charges of the last two years known when the report was written. By the sale, the figure has often grown, because nobody has paid since. A lawyer or surveyor acting for you can ask the building's manager (amministratore) for an update before you bid.

Major works already approved

Large one-off works, such as a new roof, a facade repair or a lift, are approved by the owners' meeting and charged separately. As a general rule, the Court of Cassation has held that works approved before the new owner's arrival are the previous owner's responsibility. But the line between approval, start and payment can be blurred, buildings often send the bill to whoever owns the flat when the payment falls due, and disputes are common. If a report mentions approved works, a lawyer should look at the minutes of the meeting.

What the building can and cannot do

A building cannot refuse to let you move in because of the old owner's arrears, and it cannot claim from you more than the two years the law allows. It can sue you for those two years and recover them with interest and costs. Once you own the home, you pay the charges as they fall due like any other owner, and you take part in the meetings that decide them.

What about property tax, utilities and other bills?

Local property tax (IMU) and the waste charge (TARI) are owed by whoever owned or occupied the home for the period in question. The debtor's unpaid amounts are the debtor's debt, not a charge on the home, unless a creditor secured them with a mortgage that the decree then cancels. From the decree onwards, the taxes are yours.

Utility companies generally cannot make a new owner pay the previous occupant's unpaid bills. What they can do is require a new contract, and supplies to an empty home have often been cut off, so reconnection takes time and sometimes a fee. Shared supplies and services are a different matter, covered in our overview of what can go wrong.

Comparing Italy with the United States, Canada, Australia and the UK

Buyers from abroad bring assumptions from home. A few comparisons help:

  • United States: in many states junior liens are wiped out by a mortgage foreclosure, but property tax liens survive and some states give associations a limited super-priority. In Italy the decree cancels every recorded mortgage and seizure, and there is no super-priority lien; instead, the building has a two-year claim against the new owner.
  • Canada: in a judicial sale or power of sale, the purchaser normally takes free of the mortgages being enforced, but buyers still check for other registered claims. In Italy the court has already checked, and the expert reports what remains.
  • Australia and New Zealand: in a mortgagee sale, the buyer usually takes free of the mortgage but may face unpaid strata levies or council rates, depending on the rules. In Italy council-type taxes stay with the debtor, while building charges follow the two-year rule.
  • United Kingdom: a repossession sale is a sale by the lender, with ordinary conveyancing and searches. In Italy there is no seller's solicitor and no searches pack; the court's papers take their place, and the decree replaces the deed.

Our guide comparing Italian and US foreclosure auctions covers the wider differences.

Which charges matter most before you bid?

Put the charges on a property into three groups. Debts secured on the home are cleared by the decree; you can largely set them aside, apart from who pays the cancellation duties. Condominium arrears for the current and previous year are a sum of money to add to the price, with a margin because the figure grows. Rights and burdens that survive are not sums of money at all: they are features of what you are buying, such as a path across the garden, a lease, a limit on building, or a demolition order. Those change what the home is worth to you, sometimes slightly and sometimes entirely.

The last group is where buyers go wrong. A low price can look like compensation for an easement or a lease, when in fact the right is one you could never accept. Decide first whether you can live with it, and only then whether the price is right. Where a court claim was recorded before the seizure, have a lawyer assess it before anything else, because it is one of the very few things that can take the home itself away from you.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

Does an Italian court auction wipe out the mortgage on the property?

Yes. The transfer decree orders every recorded mortgage and seizure cancelled, including those recorded after the seizure and those of creditors who were not paid in full. The creditors are paid from the price, in order of priority, and the buyer takes on none of the debtor's secured debts.

Which rights survive an Italian court sale?

Easements, court claims recorded before the seizure, leases with a legally certain date before the seizure, heritage and planning restrictions, demolition orders, civic-use rights and some limits on subsidised housing. They attach to the land or the building, not to the debt, so the decree does not remove them.

How many years of unpaid condo fees does an auction buyer in Italy pay?

Up to two: the current year and the previous year, counted back from when the buyer becomes owner at the transfer decree. The buyer is jointly liable with the debtor for those charges. Older arrears stay with the debtor.

Who pays for major building works approved before an Italian court auction?

As a general rule, works approved by the owners' meeting before the buyer became owner are the previous owner's responsibility. In practice the building may send the bill to the current owner, and disputes over timing are common, so a lawyer should read the meeting minutes.

Can a lawsuit recorded against a property survive an Italian court auction?

Yes, if it was recorded in the property registers before the seizure. A claim recorded after the seizure does not affect the auction buyer. A claim recorded before it can, and if it succeeds the buyer can lose the property, recovering the price only from the proceeds or the creditors. A lawyer should assess any such claim before you bid.

Are unpaid property taxes a lien on an Italian auction home?

Not as such. Unpaid local property tax and waste charges are the debtor's personal debts for the time they owned or occupied the home. Only if a creditor secured a debt with a mortgage does it attach to the property, and the decree cancels that mortgage.

Sources

  1. Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree and cancellation of mortgages and seizures (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 567: the twenty-year register history (Normattiva)
  3. Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 173-bis: what the expert's report must cover (Normattiva)
  4. Civil Code, article 2915: acts and claims recorded after the seizure (Normattiva)
  5. Civil Code, article 2921: the buyer evicted after a forced sale (Normattiva)
  6. Civil Code, article 2923: leases that bind the buyer at a forced sale (Normattiva)
  7. Implementing provisions of the Civil Code, article 63: condominium arrears and the new owner (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.