Court auction basics

At the court door: a short history of Italian judicial sales

Short answer

Italian court sales go back to Rome, where public sales were held under a spear (hasta), the origin of asta. Creditors sold debtors' estates in the bonorum venditio. Medieval cities held public incanti. Unified Italy wrote codes in 1865 and 1940, then from 1998 handed sales to notaries and other professionals, moved bidding online and reformed again with Cartabia.

Key facts

  • The Italian word for auction, asta, comes from the Latin hasta, the spear set up at Roman public sales.
  • Roman creditors could have a defaulting debtor's whole estate sold in the bonorum venditio.
  • The Code of Civil Procedure of 1940 is still the base of today's rules, much amended.
  • A law of 1998 let judges delegate sales to notaries; reforms in 2005 and 2006 added lawyers and accountants.
  • Since the 2015 reform, sealed offers are the rule and the old open incanto is used only exceptionally.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. Why is an Italian auction called an asta?
  2. How did medieval Italian cities run public auctions?
  3. Unified Italy: the codes of 1865 and 1940
  4. Why was 1998 a turning point?
  5. The reforms of 2005 and 2006
  6. Sealed offers, a price floor and online bidding
  7. What did the Cartabia reform add?
  8. What two thousand years add up to

Every public sale ordered by an Italian court, whether a flat in a city suburb or a farmhouse in the hills, is the latest step in a tradition more than two thousand years old. The words in a modern notice still carry its traces: the asta, the incanto, the creditor and the debtor. Knowing where they come from is not just a curiosity. Many of the rules that puzzle buyers today, from sealed offers to the role of the delegate, exist because of problems that earlier generations ran into and tried to fix.

Our own name echoes one of those traditions. In the United States, foreclosed land was long sold at public auction at the courthouse door, and old newspaper notices announcing those sales are what gave Courtdoor its name, as our about page explains. Italy's story is different but runs in parallel, and our guide to Italian and US foreclosure auctions compares the two systems as they work today. This guide follows it era by era, and ends each one with what it still means for a buyer today.

This is a short popular history, not legal scholarship. Where historians disagree or details are uncertain, we keep to what is well established.

Why is an Italian auction called an asta?

Romans sold all kinds of things at public auction (auctio, from the verb for increasing, the root of the English word). A crier (praeco) called out the bids, and a banker (argentarius) often managed the money and the records. When the sale was a public one, held by or for the state, a spear (hasta) was planted in the ground where the sale took place.

Why a spear? The Roman jurist Gaius, writing in the second century AD, explained that the spear was a sign of rightful ownership, because Romans thought nothing was more truly theirs than what they had taken from an enemy. War booty was sold under the spear, and the habit spread to other public sales, including the sale of property confiscated by the state. Cicero mentions the spear set up for the sales of confiscated estates under Sulla. The centumviral court, which heard inheritance cases in Rome, also sat under a spear.

From this came the Latin phrase sub hasta vendere, to sell under the spear, meaning to sell at public auction. Italian kept the spear and dropped the rest: an auction is still an asta, and a court auction an asta giudiziaria. Spanish kept the preposition too: an auction there is a subasta.

The bonorum venditio: selling a debtor's estate

Rome also had a procedure for creditors that will sound familiar. When a debtor would not or could not pay after a judgment, the praetor, a senior magistrate, could put the creditors in possession of the debtor's entire estate. After public notice, the creditors chose a manager (magister bonorum) who organised a sale of the whole estate to a single buyer, the bonorum emptor. The buyer was the bidder who offered the creditors the highest percentage of what they were owed, and then stepped into the debtor's shoes. Gaius records that the procedure was said to have been introduced by a praetor called Publius Rutilius.

It was harsh. The debtor lost everything at once and suffered infamia, a formal loss of social standing. A law of the Julian era allowed a debtor to surrender their goods voluntarily (cessio bonorum) and avoid that disgrace. In later centuries the sale of the whole estate gave way to the sale of single assets by a curator (distractio bonorum), closer to what courts do today: sell what is needed, item by item, and pay the creditors from the proceeds.

What Rome means for buyers today

The skeleton of a modern Italian court sale is already there: a public sale, announced in advance, run by someone acting for the creditors under a magistrate's authority, with the proceeds shared among those owed money. So is the idea that the sale must be open to anyone, because a public price is the fairest one available. That idea is why every Italian court sale today is public by law and published in court notices, and why no buyer can see a sale before it is made public.

How did medieval Italian cities run public auctions?

After the fall of the western empire, Roman procedure faded but never quite disappeared. From around the end of the eleventh century, scholars at Bologna began to study Justinian's compilation of Roman law again, and their work spread across Europe. The Italian city states of the Middle Ages, the communes, mixed that learned law with their own statutes and customs, and debt enforcement was one of the things their statutes regulated closely.

Public sales were part of city life. A town crier (banditore) announced them in the squares; goods were sold to the highest bidder; and the city itself sold rights and property in the same way. In Venice, the state put up for public auction the right to run its merchant galley voyages, in sales known as incanti. The word incanto for a public auction is usually traced to a medieval Latin verb built on in quantum, "for how much", the question an auctioneer asks.

Medieval Latin also had a word for a sale under the spear, subhastatio, a reminder that the Roman image survived in the language of lawyers long after anyone stopped planting spears in the ground.

What the medieval sale means today

The word incanto is still in the Italian Code of Civil Procedure. It names the open auction, in which bidders raise one another in turn, as opposed to a sale by sealed offers. And the crier announcing a sale in the square has become the published notice of sale, the avviso di vendita, which must appear a set time before the deadline for offers so that anyone can take part. Our guide to how Italian court auctions work explains what the notice contains.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Unified Italy: the codes of 1865 and 1940

When Italy was unified in the 1860s, the new kingdom inherited several legal systems, from the Austrian-influenced north to the Bourbon south. It replaced them with national codes. The Code of Civil Procedure of 1865, drafted under Giuseppe Pisanelli and strongly influenced by French procedure, set out a single national system for seizing and selling a debtor's property. The sale itself was an open auction, an incanto, held under the court's control.

Seventy-five years later Italy replaced that code with a new one, issued by royal decree on 28 October 1940 and in force from 1942. Some of the leading jurists of the century, among them Piero Calamandrei, Francesco Carnelutti and Enrico Redenti, worked on it. The 1940 code is still in force. Its third book, on enforcement, contains the articles that every Italian court notice cites today, from the seizure in article 555 onwards, to the transfer decree in article 586.

The 1940 code set out two ways of selling a seized home. In a sale without incanto (vendita senza incanto), bidders sent in sealed offers by a deadline, and the court opened them together. In a sale with incanto, bidders met and raised one another in open bidding, and the highest bid stood if nobody raised it within a short time. After an incanto, the law also allowed anyone to reopen the sale within ten days by offering a set fraction more, which today's text puts at a fifth.

The Criminal Code of 1930 had already made it a crime to disturb the freedom of public auctions by violence, threats, gifts or collusion (turbata libertà degli incanti, article 353). The fact that the offence had to be written down says something about the risks of a sale held in a crowded room.

What the 1940 code means today

When a notice cites article 569 for the sale order, or article 591 for price cuts after a round with no buyers, it is citing the 1940 code. The numbering has survived decades of reform, which is why a lawyer reading a modern notice and one from the 1960s would find the same article numbers with very different contents. If you read a law firm's explanation of court sales, check that it reflects the current text: older summaries can be badly out of date.

Why was 1998 a turning point?

For decades after the war, Italian foreclosures were slow. Judges handled every step themselves, alongside their other cases, and sales were held in court in front of the judge. Few ordinary buyers took part. Court sales gained a reputation as a closed world of specialists, and homes could sit unsold for years.

Law no. 302 of 3 August 1998 changed the system. It let the enforcement judge hand the sale itself to a notary from the area, under a new article 591-bis of the Code of Civil Procedure. The notary would value the home, publish the sale, receive the offers, run the auction and prepare the transfer decree, while the judge kept control of the case and signed the decree. The same law allowed a notary's certificate to replace the bundle of land registry and property register documents a creditor had to file. Italian commentators describe the 1998 law as a turning point: the first big step in taking routine work away from judges.

What 1998 means today

This is why the person you deal with in an Italian court sale is usually not a judge but a professional delegate (professionista delegato), and why the auction takes place at the delegate's office or online rather than in a courtroom. Our guide to who runs an Italian court sale explains the delegate's role alongside the judge, the custodian and the court expert.

The reforms of 2005 and 2006

Delegation worked, and the reforms of 2005 and 2006, passed as a series of laws and decrees over those two years, built on it. Lawyers and accountants joined notaries as possible delegates, which widened the pool and spread the work. The same reforms strengthened the role of the professional custodian who looks after a seized home in place of the owner, and set out in detail what the court expert's report must contain.

What 2005 and 2006 mean today

Much of what a buyer relies on comes from these years. The court report (perizia), with its standard headings on ownership, occupancy, planning and costs, is a product of them, and so is the custodian who shows you round. Our guide to the court report explains what it covers.

For members

Every price cut, on record

Members see each lot's full price history, with every round it has been through and every cut, so the story of each sale is there before they bid.

See membership
Price historyExample
First round
€60,000
Second round
€48,000
Now, third round
€38,400

Sealed offers, a price floor and online bidding

In the decade that followed, lawmakers tried to make sales faster and open them to more buyers. Reforms in 2015 made the sale by sealed offers the rule, keeping the open incanto only where the judge expects it to fetch more than one and a half times the valuation. In practice the incanto is rarely used. The same reforms introduced the lowest valid offer: a bid of at least 75% of the starting price is valid, though below the starting price it can be refused.

Price cuts were also written into clearer limits. After a round with no buyers, the next starting price can be up to a quarter lower, and after the fourth such round up to half. Our guide to price cuts explains how these work in practice.

Then came the move online. A 2016 law required the sale order to provide that deposits, offers, bidding and payment take place online, unless that would harm the creditors or slow the case. Courts phased it in, and most sales became either fully online or mixed, with some bidders online and some in person. For the first time, a buyer in another country could take part in an Italian court auction without travelling, using a digital signature and certified email, or through a lawyer.

What the 2015 and 2016 rules mean today

The 75% floor, the cuts of up to a quarter, the sealed offers and the online bidding are the rules a buyer meets in almost every notice. They exist because the old system attracted too few buyers and sold too slowly. A buyer from Australia or New Zealand, used to open-cry auctions with a hidden reserve, will find the Italian method quieter: everyone starts with a sealed written offer, the floor is printed in the notice, and there is no reserve to guess.

What did the Cartabia reform add?

The next large reform carries the name of the justice minister Marta Cartabia. Legislative Decree no. 149 of 10 October 2022 reshaped the whole of civil procedure, and its rules on foreclosures apply to cases started after 28 February 2023. For buyers, the main changes are an earlier professional custodian, fixed timing for the order to free the property, deadlines for delegates, a direct sale that the owner can propose at no less than the valuation, and a declaration on the source of the buyer's money before the transfer. A corrective decree in 2024 adjusted the details.

Our guide to what the Cartabia reform changed covers each change and explains which homes still follow the older rules.

What Cartabia means today

Two sets of rules run side by side, depending on when each case started. That is nothing new: many reforms since 1998 came with transitional rules that left cases already under way, or sales already ordered, under the earlier text. It is one reason the papers of each case need reading on their own terms.

What two thousand years add up to

Looked at as a whole, the history of Italian court sales is a long effort to solve the same few problems: how to sell a debtor's property publicly and fairly, how to attract enough buyers to get a decent price, how to stop a sale being rigged, and how to do it without taking forever. Each era answered in its own way.

  • Rome made the sale public and competitive, under public authority, for the benefit of the creditors.
  • The medieval cities kept public sales part of everyday life, and gave Italian the word incanto.
  • The codes of 1865 and 1940 wrote the procedure into national law, with the article numbers still in use.
  • The 1998 law and the reforms of 2005 and 2006 moved the work from judges to notaries, lawyers and accountants, and gave buyers a custodian, a fuller court report and auction mortgages.
  • The reforms of 2015 and 2016 made sealed offers the near-universal method, added the 75% floor and moved bidding online.
  • The Cartabia reform tightened timings and added the owner's direct sale.

Some things have never changed. The sale is still public, because the law has always trusted an open market more than a private deal when someone is being made to sell. The buyer still takes the property as it is, without warranty. And behind each sale there is still someone who could not pay, often a family losing a home. A buyer who keeps that in mind tends to deal better with the people who run these sales, and to understand why the rules protect the owner as well as the creditors.

If you are thinking of buying, the place to start is not two thousand years ago but with the process as it stands. Our guide to the court auction timeline shows each stage from seizure to keys.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What does sub hasta mean?

Latin for under the spear. Romans planted a spear at public sales, originally of war booty, and to sell sub hasta meant to sell at public auction. It gave Italian the word asta and Spanish subasta.

What was the bonorum venditio in Roman law?

A procedure in which a defaulting debtor's whole estate was sold to a single buyer, who offered the creditors the highest percentage of their claims. It was later replaced by the sale of single assets, closer to modern court sales.

Where does the Italian word incanto come from?

It is usually traced to a medieval Latin verb built on in quantum, for how much, the question an auctioneer asks. Medieval Italian cities, Venice among them, used incanto for public auctions, and the word is still in the Code of Civil Procedure.

When did notaries start running Italian court sales?

With Law no. 302 of 3 August 1998, which let judges delegate the sale of seized property to a notary. Reforms in 2005 and 2006 extended delegation to lawyers and accountants.

Is the Italian law on court sales still based on the 1940 code?

Yes. The Code of Civil Procedure issued in 1940 and in force from 1942 is still the base, but its articles on forced sales have been rewritten many times, including by the Cartabia reform.

Why does Courtdoor have that name?

Because in the United States foreclosed land was long sold at public auction at the courthouse door, and old notices of those sales inspired the name. Italian court sales are mostly held online, but they are still public sales ordered by a court.

Sources

  1. Law 3 August 1998 no. 302: delegation of forced sales to notaries (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 591-bis: delegating the sale (Normattiva)
  3. Code of Civil Procedure, article 569: the sale order, the incanto and online sales (Normattiva)
  4. Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: offers and the lowest valid offer (Normattiva)
  5. Code of Civil Procedure, article 584: offers after an incanto (Normattiva)
  6. Criminal Code, article 353: disturbing the freedom of auctions (Normattiva)
  7. Legislative Decree 10 October 2022 no. 149 (Cartabia reform), article 35: when the new rules apply (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.