Court auction basics

Who runs a court sale: judge, delegate, custodian, expert, creditors and lawyers

Short answer

An Italian court sale is overseen by the enforcement judge and run day to day by a court-appointed delegate (professionista delegato), usually a notary, lawyer or accountant. A court custodian (custode giudiziario) looks after the home and shows it to buyers, and an expert values it. None of them works for the buyer, and none takes money outside the procedure.

Key facts

  • The judge orders the sale, settles disputes and signs the transfer decree.
  • The delegate runs the sale: the notice, the offers, the bidding, the balance and the draft decree.
  • The custodian looks after the home, arranges viewings under the judge's rules and frees it where the law allows.
  • The expert writes the perizia; their fee is tied to the sale price.
  • Court professionals are paid by the procedure under fixed tariffs; a buyer pays only a share of the delegate's fee for the transfer.
  • Only a lawyer (avvocato) can bid on someone else's behalf.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. The enforcement judge
  2. What does the delegate (professionista delegato) do?
  3. What does a court custodian (custode giudiziario) do?
  4. What does the court expert (esperto stimatore) do?
  5. The creditors
  6. The debtor
  7. Do you need your own lawyer?
  8. Others you may meet
  9. Insolvency sales: different names, similar jobs
  10. Who pays the judge, delegate, custodian and expert?

An Italian court sale has no seller in the usual sense, no listing agent and no closing attorney who acts for both sides, which is one of the differences from US foreclosure auctions. Instead there is a cast of people, each appointed or recognised by law, each with a defined job. Buyers who know who does what ask the right person the right question, and avoid expecting help from someone whose role does not allow it.

This guide goes through each role in an ordinary foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare): who they are, who appoints and pays them, what they can and cannot do for a buyer, and how a buyer usually deals with them. It ends with insolvency sales, where some roles change names. For the process itself, from seizure to sale, see how Italian court auctions work.

The rules here are the general ones in the Code of Civil Procedure and its implementing provisions. Many were changed by the Cartabia reform for cases started after 28 February 2023, and older cases can follow the earlier text. Each court also issues its own standing instructions. Where the notice or the sale order says something different, that is what counts.

The enforcement judge

Every foreclosure is assigned to a judge of the local court (tribunale), the enforcement judge (giudice dell'esecuzione). The judge is a career magistrate, paid by the State like any judge, and receives no fee from the case.

What the judge does

  • Appoints the expert who values the property and, in most cases, a custodian to replace the owner in looking after it.
  • Holds the hearing on the sale under article 569 of the Code of Civil Procedure, hears the creditors and the debtor, and issues the sale order.
  • Delegates the sale to a professional. Under the current text of article 591-bis, delegation is the rule, and the judge keeps the sale only where the parties' interests require it.
  • Decides complaints about what the delegate has done, and objections from the debtor and others.
  • Orders the home to be freed of occupants where the law allows.
  • Signs the transfer decree (decreto di trasferimento) once the buyer has paid, ordering the cancellation of mortgages and seizures.
  • Approves the plan for sharing the price among the creditors.

Some powers stay with the judge even when the sale is delegated. The most important for a buyer is in article 586: after the price is paid, the judge can suspend the sale if the price obtained is far below a fair one. This is rare, and usually linked to irregular conduct at the sale, but it is the reason the award is not the end of the story.

What the judge does not do for a buyer

The judge decides between parties; a would-be buyer is not yet a party. You do not write to the judge with questions about a home, and the judge does not answer them. If a problem arises after you have made an offer or won, your lawyer raises it formally, usually by a complaint against the delegate's act (reclamo, article 591-ter) or an objection to the procedure's acts (opposizione agli atti esecutivi, article 617). These have short deadlines, which is one reason to have a lawyer on hand.

What does the delegate (professionista delegato) do?

The delegate is the person a buyer deals with most. Article 591-bis of the Code of Civil Procedure lets the judge hand the sale operations to a notary, a lawyer or a chartered accountant (commercialista) enrolled on the court's list of delegates. The list is kept under article 179-ter of the implementing provisions, and professionals must meet training and experience requirements to be on it. Notaries were the first delegates, from 1998, and many courts still use them heavily; others rely mostly on lawyers and accountants.

What the delegate does

  • Sets the value for the sale, taking account of the expert's report and the parties' comments.
  • Prepares and publishes the notice of sale, which must appear in public court notices at least 45 days before the offer deadline.
  • Receives the offers, opens them on the date set, checks that each one is valid, and runs the bidding if there are several.
  • Awards the property and writes the minutes of the sale (verbale).
  • Decides on a creditor's request to take the property instead of selling it (assegnazione).
  • Sets new rounds, usually at a lower price, when a round fails, and returns deposits to bidders who did not win.
  • Collects the balance, works out the costs of the transfer, and drafts the transfer decree for the judge to sign.
  • After the decree, registers it and arranges the cancellation of mortgages and seizures and the updates to the land registry.
  • Prepares the plan for sharing the price among the creditors.

For cases under the Cartabia rules, the delegate must hold at least three rounds within a year of the sale order, and report to the judge at the start, after each round and at the end. A delegate who misses deadlines can be replaced.

Who pays the delegate

Delegates are paid under a ministerial tariff (decree 227 of 2015), not a fee they choose. The judge settles the amount. Most of it is a cost of the procedure, paid from the sale price before the rest is shared among the creditors. One part is charged to the buyer: half of the fee for the transfer stage, with the costs of registering and recording the decree and updating the land registry. Who pays to cancel mortgages and seizures depends on the court and the sale order, and the notice says which. The notice states the buyer's share, and the delegate tells the winner how much to pay with the balance. Our guide to buying costs explains it.

What the delegate can and cannot do for a buyer

The delegate is neutral. Their job is to run a correct sale for the court and the creditors, not to help any one buyer win or to advise anyone whether to buy. In general terms, a delegate can explain the rules of the sale as set in the notice and the order, receive your offer, tell you whether it was valid and why, and tell you after the award what to pay and by when.

A delegate cannot change the terms of the notice for you, accept an offer outside the rules, extend a deadline the order fixes, tell you what other bidders are offering, advise you on whether the home is a good buy, or take a deposit into any account other than the procedure's. Delegates are busy professionals with many cases. Questions about the home itself, its condition, its papers and its risks, belong with your own advisers, not with the delegate.

What does a court custodian (custode giudiziario) do?

When a property is seized, the owner automatically becomes its custodian, unpaid, and must look after it. Article 559 of the Code of Civil Procedure tells the judge to replace the owner with a court custodian, unless that would serve no purpose. Under the current rules this happens early, within 15 days of the creditor filing the property documents, at the same time as the expert is appointed. The judge also replaces any custodian who fails in the job.

The custodian is chosen from the court's list, often a lawyer or accountant and frequently the same professional as the delegate, or a specialist body the court authorises for this work. Custodians are paid under a separate ministerial tariff, settled by the judge and charged to the procedure. A buyer does not pay the custodian.

What the custodian does

  • Looks after the property: checks its condition, reports problems to the judge, and with the judge's authority manages it and takes legal steps to protect it.
  • Collects any rent from tenants and keeps accounts for the procedure.
  • Watches over the debtor's family if they still live there, making sure the home is kept with reasonable care.
  • Shows the home to people who want to buy, under the rules the judge sets in an order. The debtor must allow these viewings.
  • Carries out the order to free the home of occupants, where the law allows, and deals with belongings left behind.

Viewings, in general terms

Viewings of court sale homes are a right, not a favour, and they are free. The judge's order sets how they are requested and arranged, and the custodian, or someone working for them, accompanies visitors. Courts set their own practical rules, such as group visits, time slots and the period before the offer deadline in which visits happen. If the owner obstructs viewings, the judge can order the home freed earlier.

What the custodian can and cannot do for a buyer

The custodian can show you the home, describe its current state and occupancy as far as they know it, and, after the decree, hand over the keys or carry out the order to free it. Under article 560, the custodian frees the home in the buyer's interest and at no cost to the buyer, unless the buyer expressly releases them from that task. For a home lived in by the debtor, the order to free it is normally made with the transfer decree; for other homes it comes no later than the sale order. Older cases can follow the earlier wording of this article.

The custodian cannot take offers or deposits, cannot promise a date when the home will be empty, cannot authorise works before you own the home, and cannot vouch for the building's structure or systems. Treat what you see and hear on a viewing as one source among several. The perizia and your own surveyor tell you more.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

What does the court expert (esperto stimatore) do?

The expert values the property and writes the report that every buyer relies on. The judge appoints them, usually an architect, engineer, surveyor (geometra) or agronomist, from the court's register of experts, within 15 days of the property documents being filed. The expert swears to do the job faithfully.

Article 173-bis of the implementing provisions lists what the report must cover: an identification of the property and its boundaries, a description, its occupancy and any leases, charges and rights that will survive the sale, planning compliance and whether any unauthorised work can be legalised, condominium arrears, and the valuation, with the deductions applied. The expert sends the report to the parties at least 30 days before the hearing on the sale, and the parties can comment.

The judge settles the expert's fee. Under article 161 of the implementing provisions, it is calculated on the price the sale actually fetches, and no more than half can be paid in advance before the sale. The procedure pays it, not the buyer. The rule was designed to discourage valuations that are wildly out of line with what a home will sell for.

What the expert means for a buyer

The expert works for the judge. After filing the report, the expert's job is largely done, unless the judge asks for an update or correction. A buyer does not commission the expert, and the expert does not answer buyers' questions about the home. The report is careful and detailed, but it is a valuation for a court, not a building survey for you. If the report is old, or the home has changed since, ask whether the judge has ordered an update. Our guide to the perizia explains what it covers.

The creditors

Without creditors there would be no sale. They start the case, keep it moving and share the price at the end. Many of them are banks or investors who bought bundles of bad loans, managed by debt servicers.

The creditor who starts the case (creditore procedente)

The creditor who has the home seized is the creditore procedente. It must ask for the sale and file the land registry and property register documents, or a notary's certificate covering them, within the legal term. Under the current rules, the request for sale must be made within 45 days of the seizure, and the documents filed within the same term, extendable once for good reasons. Older cases had longer terms. If the creditor misses these steps, the seizure can lose effect. The procedente usually advances the costs of the expert, the custodian and the notices, and recovers them first from the price.

Creditors who join (creditori intervenuti)

Other creditors can join the case under article 499: those with an enforceable title such as a court judgment, those with a mortgage or other right registered on the property, and some others the law lists. A joining creditor with an enforceable title can keep the case going even if the creditor who started it drops out.

What creditors can do that affects buyers

  • Ask to take the property themselves at no less than the starting price, instead of letting it go to a single low offer (assegnazione). This is why a single offer below the starting price can be refused.
  • Agree together to suspend the case once, for up to two years, if they ask no later than 20 days before the offer deadline; or settle with the debtor and withdraw, which can stop a sale at any point before the award.
  • Comment at the hearing on how and when the sale should run.
  • Buy at the sale themselves. A creditor can bid like anyone else, and a mortgage creditor can set the price it owes against the amount due to it, within the limits the law sets.

Creditors are paid from the price according to their rank: costs of the procedure first, then mortgages in order, then unsecured creditors. A buyer never deals with them directly about the purchase. What they owe each other is settled by the court, and the transfer decree frees the home from their mortgages.

The debtor

The debtor (debitore esecutato) still owns the home until the transfer decree. Often it is a family's home, and the sale is the end of a long, hard road. That is worth keeping in mind on a viewing.

Under article 560, a debtor who lives in the home can normally stay with their family until the decree, provided they look after the property, allow viewings and keep to the other rules. If they obstruct viewings or let the home deteriorate, the judge can order it freed earlier. The debtor cannot let the property without the judge's permission, and any lease signed after the seizure does not bind the buyer.

The debtor cannot bid at the sale. Until the sale order, they can ask to replace the property with a sum of money paid to the creditors (conversione). Under the Cartabia rules they can also propose a direct sale to a buyer they have found, at no less than the valuation. And at any point before the award they can pay the debt and end the case. Our guide on other kinds of sale explains these routes, and why Courtdoor never suggests that buyers contact owners.

For members

Every deadline, worked out for each home

Members get a bidding plan for each home, showing who the delegate and custodian are, the dates and deposit, and what the buyer pays at the end.

See membership
Bidding planExample
  • Offer deadlineOffer and deposit lodged12 Mar
  • AuctionOffers opened; bidding if more than one13 Mar
  • Balance duePrice less deposit, plus costs11 Jul
  • Transfer decreeWeeks to months after paymentSep

Do you need your own lawyer?

Everyone above is appointed by the court or is a party to the case. The only people in a court sale who work for you are the ones you hire yourself.

What the law requires

The law does not require a buyer to have a lawyer. You can make an offer in your own name, online or on paper, if you have what the notice requires. But only a lawyer (avvocato) can bid on someone else's behalf, with a special power of attorney. A lawyer can also bid "for a person to be named" (per persona da nominare), declaring the buyer's name within three days of the award. A friend, relative, accountant or estate agent who is not a lawyer cannot bid for you. For many buyers abroad, a lawyer bidding for them is the simplest way in. Our guide to buying from abroad covers powers of attorney.

What a buyer's lawyer does

  • Reads the notice, the sale order and the perizia with you, and checks the land and property registers for anything the papers missed.
  • Explains which charges will be cancelled by the decree and which will stay with the home.
  • Prepares and files the offer, or bids for you, and attends the opening.
  • After the award, deals with the delegate on the balance, tax reliefs and the decree, and raises any formal complaint within its deadline.
  • If the home is occupied, follows the custodian's progress in freeing it.

You agree your lawyer's fee privately, and it is not part of the court costs. Ask for a written quote that says what is included. The same goes for a surveyor or geometra you hire to look at the building or the planning file, and for a bank if you borrow. These people are on your side; everyone else in the sale is neutral.

Estate agents and consultants

Estate agents have no formal role in a court sale. Some offer an "auction assistance" service for a fee. That is a private arrangement between you and them, and only a lawyer can bid for you. If anyone presents themselves as part of the court, check that their name appears in the court's papers for that case. Our guide to fake sales and scams lists the warning signs.

Others you may meet

  • The court clerk's office (cancelleria) keeps the case file. Buyers rarely deal with it directly.
  • Tenants and other occupants. A tenant with a lease that has a legally certain date before the seizure can stay, under the lease's terms, after the sale.
  • Co-owners. Where only a share of a home is seized, the other owners may be involved in a division of the property.
  • The online sale operator. For online sales, an approved technology company provides the system on which offers are made and bids placed. It provides the technology, but the delegate runs the sale.

Insolvency sales: different names, similar jobs

When the seller is a failed business, or a person in a liquidation, the cast changes. In a liquidazione giudiziale (a fallimento in older cases), the court appoints a liquidator (curatore) who runs the sale, under the supervision of a delegated judge (giudice delegato) and, in larger cases, a creditors' committee. The liquidator follows a sale programme approved in the case, may use competitive procedures with an approved operator, and has more freedom over the format than a delegate in a foreclosure.

After the sale and full payment, the delegated judge orders the cancellation of mortgages, seizures and other charges by decree, as in a foreclosure. Our guide to bankruptcy and foreclosure sales explains the differences that matter to buyers, including VAT.

Who pays the judge, delegate, custodian and expert?

  • The judge: paid by the State. No fee from the case.
  • The delegate: ministerial tariff, settled by the judge, paid from the procedure; the buyer pays half of the fee for the transfer stage.
  • The custodian: ministerial tariff, settled by the judge, paid from the procedure.
  • The expert: settled by the judge on the sale price, paid from the procedure.
  • The creditors' lawyers: paid by the creditors, and partly recovered from the price.
  • Your lawyer, surveyor and other advisers: paid by you, under your own agreement.

The deposit and the balance go to the procedure's own account, controlled by the delegate under the judge. No one in this list collects money for themselves from a buyer, and no one can ask you for a deposit or a fee into a personal account.

For the order in which these people appear, from seizure to keys, see our court auction timeline. For definitions of each Italian term, see the glossary.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What does a professionista delegato do in an Italian court sale?

The delegate, usually a notary, lawyer or accountant on the court's list, runs the sale for the judge: publishes the notice, receives and opens offers, runs the bidding, awards the property, collects the balance and drafts the transfer decree.

What is a court custodian in Italy?

The custode giudiziario looks after a seized property for the court, collects any rent, shows the home to interested buyers under the judge's rules, and frees it of occupants where the law allows, at no cost to the buyer unless the buyer waives this.

Does the buyer pay the custodian or the court expert?

No. Both are paid by the procedure under fees settled by the judge. The buyer pays only half of the delegate's fee for the transfer stage, together with taxes and the costs of registering the decree.

Can the delegate advise me whether to buy?

No. The delegate is neutral and runs the sale for the court. They can explain the rules in the notice and tell you about your offer, but questions about the home's condition, risks or value belong with your own lawyer and surveyor.

Who do I complain to about an Italian court auction?

The enforcement judge. Complaints about the delegate's acts go to the judge, usually through a lawyer, within short deadlines. The judge can also suspend a sale after payment if the price is far below a fair one.

Can the owner choose who buys a foreclosed home in Italy?

Not at the auction. The debtor cannot bid and cannot choose the winner. Before the sale order they can propose a direct sale to a buyer at no less than the valuation, and before the award they can pay the debt and end the case.

Sources

  1. Code of Civil Procedure, article 559: the custodian (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 560: the custodian's duties, viewings and freeing the home (Normattiva)
  3. Code of Civil Procedure, article 569: the expert, the hearing and the sale order (Normattiva)
  4. Code of Civil Procedure, article 591-bis: delegating the sale (Normattiva)
  5. Code of Civil Procedure, article 499: creditors who join the case (Normattiva)
  6. Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: who can make an offer, in person or through a lawyer (Normattiva)
  7. Code of Civil Procedure, article 579: bidding for a person to be named (Normattiva)
  8. Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 173-bis: the expert's report (Normattiva)
  9. Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 161: the expert's fee (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.