Court auction basics

What the Cartabia reform changed for Italian court auction buyers

Short answer

The Cartabia reform (Legislative Decree 149/2022) changed Italian foreclosure sales for cases started after 28 February 2023. It brought custodians in earlier, fixed when occupied homes must be freed, set delegate deadlines, let debtors propose a direct sale at the valuation, and added a money-laundering declaration before the decree. Older cases keep the earlier rules.

Key facts

  • The new foreclosure rules apply to cases started after 28 February 2023; older cases follow the earlier text.
  • A debtor can ask for a direct sale (vendita diretta) by bringing an outside offer at no less than the court valuation, with a 10% deposit.
  • Under the reform, a custodian is appointed within 15 days of the creditor's documents being filed, at the same time as the court expert.
  • An occupied home lived in by the debtor is ordered freed together with the transfer decree, at no cost to the buyer.
  • The delegate must hold at least three sale rounds within a year of the sale order and report to the judge after each one.
  • A buyer must file an anti-money-laundering declaration within the balance term; the 2024 corrective decree treats a missing one like an unpaid balance.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. Which court auctions does the Cartabia reform apply to?
  2. The custodian arrives earlier
  3. Can the owner refuse viewings?
  4. When must an occupied home be freed under Cartabia?
  5. What is the direct sale (vendita diretta)?
  6. Deadlines for the delegate
  7. Online sales
  8. Paying the balance with a mortgage
  9. The transfer decree
  10. What did the Cartabia reform not change?
  11. Old case or new case: the differences side by side
  12. Is the reform good news for buyers?

A major reform of Italian court auctions carries the name of the justice minister who led it, Marta Cartabia. The reform covered the whole of civil procedure. For anyone buying a home at a court auction, the parts that matter sit in the chapter on the forced sale of property: who looks after the home, when occupants must leave, how quickly the delegate has to move, a new route the owner can open to sell directly, and what a buyer must do before the court will transfer the home.

This guide walks through each change in plain English and says what it means in practice for a buyer. It also explains the one detail that trips up most summaries: the new rules do not apply to every home on sale. They depend on when the court case began. If you are new to the process, our guide to how Italian court auctions work gives the full picture first.

Which court auctions does the Cartabia reform apply to?

The reform is Legislative Decree no. 149 of 10 October 2022. It was due to take effect on 30 June 2023, but the budget law passed at the end of 2022 brought that forward. Under article 35 of the decree as amended, its civil procedure rules take effect from 28 February 2023 and apply to proceedings started after that date, unless the decree says otherwise. Proceedings already pending on that date carry on under the rules that were in force before. Our short history of Italian court sales shows how often reforms have left older cases on older rules.

In a foreclosure, the case starts with the seizure (pignoramento), the formal act served on the owner that ties the property to the debt. Article 491 of the Code of Civil Procedure says so in as many words. So the practical test is simple: was the seizure served before or after the end of February 2023?

Foreclosures in Italy take years. A home seized before March 2023 can still be on sale years later, on its second or third round, and it will usually follow the older text. A home seized after February 2023 follows the Cartabia rules. Both kinds sit side by side in public Italian court notices, and the notice does not always say which regime applies. Your lawyer can confirm which rules apply, and members' bidding plans state it for each home.

Where this guide says "under the new rules", it means cases started after 28 February 2023. Older cases may differ on the points marked below. Courts also issue their own practice guidelines, so details vary from one court to another.

The custodian arrives earlier

From the day of the seizure, the owner is by law the custodian of the seized home. For years the courts have replaced the owner with a professional custodian (custode giudiziario), usually a lawyer or an accountant, because an owner under pressure is not always the best person to look after a home the court is selling.

Under the earlier text of article 559, the professional custodian was usually named when the judge ordered the sale, although many courts already appointed one earlier under their own guidelines. Under the new text, the judge must appoint one within fifteen days of the creditor filing the property documents, and at the same time as the court expert (esperto stimatore) who writes the *perizia*. The judge can skip the appointment only if replacing the owner would serve no purpose for keeping, managing or selling the home. The custodian is chosen from a court list.

The custodian also works with the expert from the start to check that the creditor's documents are complete, and reports to the judge, so that gaps in the paperwork surface before the home is offered for sale.

What the earlier custodian means for a buyer

  • A home in a newer case has had a professional looking after it for longer, which tends to mean better information on who lives there and in what state the home is kept.
  • Paperwork gaps are more likely to have been caught before the first round, so fewer sales should collapse late for document reasons.
  • Viewings run through the custodian, who knows the home from the start of the case. Our guide to who runs an Italian court sale explains each role.

Can the owner refuse viewings?

Article 560, as rewritten, sets out what the owner and the custodian must do while the case runs. The owner and the family living with them keep possession of their home until the transfer decree. That is a deliberate protection: a family is not put out of its home simply because a foreclosure has begun. In exchange, the owner must keep the home with ordinary care, and must let prospective buyers view it, in agreement with the custodian and in the way the judge's order sets.

The custodian supervises and, with the judge's permission, manages the home and can take legal steps to recover it.

If the owner blocks viewings, lets the home fall into disrepair or breaks the other duties the law sets, the judge can order the home freed early, after hearing the parties and the custodian. For a buyer, that is the main reason viewings in Italian court sales usually go ahead even when the family still lives there: refusing them has a real consequence.

When must an occupied home be freed under Cartabia?

For buyers from the United States, Canada or Australia, this is the change that matters most, because it decides when you can expect the keys. An Italian court auction has no separate eviction lawsuit after the sale. The court itself orders the home freed, and the custodian carries it out. The reform fixed the timing in the law.

  • A home not lived in by the owner, or occupied by someone with no right that binds the procedure, must be ordered freed no later than the order that authorises or delegates the sale. In practice, these homes are often already empty, or on their way to being empty, when the first round is published.
  • A home lived in by the owner and their family is ordered freed together with the transfer decree, unless the judge acts earlier because of a breach of the owner's duties.
  • A tenant with a lease that binds the buyer is a different case: the tenant stays until the lease ends, and the buyer becomes the landlord.

The custodian carries out the order to free the property (ordine di liberazione) on the judge's instructions, without the formal eviction steps that apply elsewhere in Italian law, and can do so even after the decree. The law says this happens in the buyer's interest and at no cost to the buyer, unless the buyer expressly releases the custodian from the task. The custodian can ask for police assistance where needed, and gives the occupants at least thirty days to remove their belongings, after which anything left behind can be treated as abandoned.

Under the version of article 560 in force before the reform, the custodian also carried out the release after the decree, but in many cases only if the buyer asked for it. Under the new text the order comes with the decree as a matter of course. Courts have applied both versions differently, which is why our guide to what happens after you win says to ask the custodian what to expect in that court.

What the release rules mean for a buyer

If the owner's family lives in the home, plan on getting the keys some time after the decree, not at the award. The family has the right to stay until the decree is signed, and then needs time to move. Some leave on their own; others need the custodian to return with a court officer. The free release by the custodian is a real advantage over many foreclosure systems, such as US foreclosure auctions, where the buyer must start and pay for an eviction. But it is not instant, and a buyer who needs to move in on a fixed date should allow for months, not weeks.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

What is the direct sale (vendita diretta)?

The best-known change is the direct sale (vendita diretta), set out in two new articles, 568-bis and 569-bis. It lets the owner, who is the debtor in the case, ask the judge to sell the home directly to a buyer the owner has found, instead of putting it up for auction. It was designed to let a sale happen sooner and at a fair price, which helps both the creditors and the family.

How the request works

  1. The owner files the request no later than ten days before the hearing at which the judge would normally order the sale.
  2. The request must come with a written offer from the buyer, at a price no lower than the value in the court expert's report, and a deposit of at least one tenth of the price offered. Without these the request is inadmissible.
  3. The request and the offer must be served on the creditors at least five days before that hearing.
  4. The offer is irrevocable. The buyer can only walk away if 120 days pass after the judge's order without the offer being accepted.
  5. The owner can make this request only once in a case.

At the hearing, the judge checks the request. If the judge sets the starting price above the offer, the buyer has ten days to raise the offer and the deposit to match, or the request fails and the ordinary sale goes ahead.

If no creditor objects

If the offer is admissible and no creditor with an enforceable claim objects by the hearing, the judge awards the home to that buyer. The buyer must then pay the price within ninety days, a shorter term than the 120 days that apply at an ordinary auction. If the buyer fails to pay, the law applies the same rule as at an ordinary auction (article 587): the buyer loses the award and the deposit, and the judge orders a new sale.

If a creditor objects

An objection does not end the direct sale. It opens it up. The judge orders the offer to be published, within at most 45 days, and allows 90 days for anyone else to make a better offer, at a price no lower than the first one and with the same deposit of at least one tenth. A hearing follows within fifteen days of that window closing, with the owner, any co-owners, the creditors and everyone who made an offer. If there are several offers, the judge holds a contest between them, usually online.

How the home is transferred

Once the price is paid, the judge issues a transfer decree, as in any court sale. The direct sale adds one option: if the buyer asks, the judge can authorise the transfer by a notary's deed instead, and order the old seizure and mortgages cancelled once that deed is registered.

The direct sale is in the owner's hands, not the buyer's. Courtdoor does not suggest contacting owners or families in a foreclosure, and nor should anyone else. A buyer meets a direct sale only when it is published for competing offers.

What the direct sale means for a buyer

  • A home can occasionally leave the auction route before its first round, because the owner has found a buyer at the full valuation.
  • If a creditor objects, the home is published with the first offer as the floor. You can compete, but you start at the valuation, not at 75% of a reduced price.
  • The deadline to pay is 90 days, so a buyer who needs a mortgage has less time than at an ordinary auction.
  • The price floor is high, which is why direct sales remain a small part of the market. For most buyers, the ordinary rounds, with their price cuts after each unsold round, are still where homes are sold.

Deadlines for the delegate

Most Italian court sales are not run by the judge but by a professional delegate (professionista delegato): a notary, a lawyer or an accountant from a court list. Delegation was already the rule. The reform added deadlines, rewriting article 591-bis.

  • In the sale order, the judge sets a final deadline for the delegated work and orders at least three sale rounds within a year of the order.
  • Within thirty days of the order being served, the delegate files an initial report. After each round, the delegate files a periodic report. Within ten days of the plan for paying out the proceeds being approved, the delegate files a final report.
  • The judge can ask the delegate for information at any time and, after hearing them, replaces a delegate who misses deadlines or ignores directions, unless the delay was not the delegate's fault.
  • Once the balance is paid and the buyer's declaration checked, the delegate prepares the transfer decree and sends the file to the judge without delay.

The 2024 corrective decree (Legislative Decree no. 164 of 31 October 2024) did not change article 591-bis itself, but it changed the rules for the court lists that delegates are drawn from. Joining the list and the three-yearly confirmation, which already required specific training, can be done largely by sworn declaration, and a judge may appoint a delegate from the list of another court in the same court of appeal district without having to give specific reasons.

What the delegate deadlines mean for a buyer

Three rounds in a year means shorter gaps between rounds in newer cases, and less time for a home to sit unsold. A buyer waiting for a lower price has less time to think, and a home that has failed once may be back on sale sooner than expected. In older cases, and in courts with heavy workloads, gaps can still be longer. Our guide to the court auction timeline shows how the stages fit together.

Online sales

Online offers and bidding did not start with the Cartabia reform. A 2016 law already required the judge's sale order to provide that deposits, offers, bidding and payment take place online, unless that would harm the creditors or slow the case down. That rule in article 569 still applies, to old and new cases alike. Some courts use fully online sales, others a mixed format in which some bidders take part in person.

What the reform added is that the contest in a direct sale also runs online, on the same terms. For a buyer abroad, this keeps the whole process within reach from another country, with a digital signature and a certified email address, or through an Italian lawyer. An offer from abroad follows the same rules as any other.

For members

Every deadline, worked out for each home

Members get a bidding plan for each lot that sets out the deadlines that apply to that case, from offer to balance, declaration and decree.

See membership
Bidding planExample
  • Offer deadlineOffer and deposit lodged12 Mar
  • AuctionOffers opened; bidding if more than one13 Mar
  • Balance duePrice less deposit, plus costs11 Jul
  • Transfer decreeWeeks to months after paymentSep

Paying the balance with a mortgage

A buyer can still fund the balance with a bank loan that pays the procedure directly and is secured by a first mortgage on the same home. The transfer decree then refers to the loan, and the transfer and the bank's mortgage are recorded together in the property registers. This long-standing rule in article 585 was left in place by the Cartabia reform.

What the reform added is a new duty for every buyer, cash or mortgage. Within the term for paying the balance, the buyer must give the judge or the delegate a written declaration with the information Italian anti-money-laundering law requires: who the buyer is, where the money comes from and, if the buyer acts for someone else, who ultimately benefits. The declaration is made under civil and criminal liability for false statements.

The 2024 corrective decree closed a gap. Under its amendment to article 587, failing to file this declaration on time has the same effect as failing to pay: the award is revoked and the deposit is lost. Courts apply this rule to cases started after 28 February 2023.

What the declaration means for a buyer

Treat the declaration as part of the payment, not paperwork for later. If a bank is funding the balance, both the loan and the declaration must be in place within the same term, which is never more than 120 days at an ordinary auction and 90 days in a direct sale. Our guide to buying costs covers the sums due alongside the balance.

The transfer decree

The judge still makes the buyer the owner by signing a transfer decree (decreto di trasferimento) under article 586. The reform added one condition: the judge signs only after checking that the price has been paid and that the buyer has filed the anti-money-laundering declaration. The decree still orders the seizures and mortgages to be cancelled, still orders the occupants to leave, and still serves as the buyer's title and as an enforceable order for possession.

What did the Cartabia reform not change?

Much of what a buyer meets in a notice stayed exactly as it was. The reform did not touch these core rules of the ordinary sale:

  • The lowest valid offer is still 75% of the starting price.
  • The deposit is still at least one tenth of the price offered.
  • The balance is still due within the term in the notice, at most 120 days from the award, with instalments over up to twelve months only for good reasons.
  • Starting prices still fall by up to a quarter after a round with no buyers, and by up to half after the fourth.
  • The sale is still as seen, with no warranty for defects.
  • Open bidding by incanto is still used only where the judge expects it to fetch more than one and a half times the valuation.

Old case or new case: the differences side by side

  • Custodian: older cases often had one named at the sale order; newer cases have one within fifteen days of the documents being filed.
  • Release of the owner's home: older cases followed the earlier text, under which the custodian often acted after the decree on the buyer's request; newer cases have the order made with the decree, carried out at no cost to the buyer.
  • Direct sale: not available in older cases; available once, at the owner's request, in newer ones.
  • Delegate: older cases follow the deadlines in the sale order; newer cases need at least three rounds within a year and reports after each round.
  • Anti-money-laundering declaration: required by the new text of article 585 in newer cases, with forfeiture if missed; older cases follow the court's practice.

Some courts apply parts of the new practice to old cases through their own guidelines, so the line is not always sharp. When it matters to your plans, for example because you need the keys by a certain date, ask before you bid.

Is the reform good news for buyers?

On balance, yes, though not in a dramatic way. The changes make the process more predictable: a professional looks after the home from early on, viewings are harder to refuse, the timing of orders to free the property is written into the law, delegates have to keep rounds moving, and the paperwork is checked sooner. None of that makes a court auction risk free. The home is still sold as seen, the papers still need careful reading, and an occupied home still takes time to free.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

When did the Cartabia reform start applying to Italian court auctions?

Its foreclosure rules apply to cases started after 28 February 2023. A case starts with the seizure. Cases already pending on that date continue under the earlier rules, and many of them are still being sold.

What is a vendita diretta in an Italian foreclosure?

A direct sale the owner can ask for, by bringing an outside buyer's offer at no less than the court valuation with a deposit of at least 10%. If a creditor objects, the offer is published and others can bid against it.

Can a buyer ask for a direct sale of a foreclosed home in Italy?

No. Only the owner in the case can file the request, once, before the sale is ordered. Other buyers can take part only if the offer is published for competing bids after a creditor objects.

Who pays to evict occupants after an Italian court auction under the Cartabia rules?

Nobody charges the buyer. The custodian carries out the order to free the property on the judge's instructions and at no cost to the buyer, unless the buyer chooses to release the custodian from the task.

What is the anti-money-laundering declaration after winning an Italian auction?

A written statement, due within the balance term, giving the buyer's details, the source of the money and any beneficial owner. In cases started after February 2023, missing it leads to forfeiture, like an unpaid balance.

Did the Cartabia reform change the 75% minimum offer or price cuts?

No. The 75% lowest offer, the 10% deposit, the 120-day balance term and the cuts of up to a quarter per failed round all stayed as they were. The changes are in the custodian, orders to free the property, delegate deadlines and the direct sale.

Sources

  1. Legislative Decree 10 October 2022 no. 149 (Cartabia reform), article 35: when the new rules apply (Normattiva)
  2. Code of Civil Procedure, article 491: a foreclosure starts with the seizure (Normattiva)
  3. Code of Civil Procedure, article 559: appointing the custodian (Normattiva)
  4. Code of Civil Procedure, article 560: the custodian's duties and orders to free the property (Normattiva)
  5. Code of Civil Procedure, article 568-bis: the direct sale (Normattiva)
  6. Code of Civil Procedure, article 569-bis: how the direct sale runs (Normattiva)
  7. Code of Civil Procedure, article 591-bis: delegating the sale (Normattiva)
  8. Implementing provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, article 179-ter: the list of sale delegates (Normattiva)
  9. Code of Civil Procedure, article 585: the balance and the buyer's declaration (Normattiva)
  10. Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree (Normattiva)
  11. Code of Civil Procedure, article 587: forfeiture for a buyer who does not pay (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.