Court papers and red flags

Shops, offices, garages and hotels at auction: commercial lots and going concerns

Short answer

Italian court auctions sell many shops, offices, garages, warehouses and hotels, and bankruptcies sometimes sell whole going concerns. A binding business lease runs six years renewable, nine for hotels, and the tenant's right to buy first does not apply. Licences belong to the business, not the building, and some parking spaces can be sold only under strict conditions.

Key facts

  • Every unit has a cadastral category, a tax label such as C/1 for shops, A/10 for offices and C/6 for garages; the lawful use comes from the planning permits, not the category.
  • Which tax applies depends on who sells: registration tax when the debtor is a private person, the VAT rules when it is a VAT-registered company. A lawyer or commercialista confirms each case.
  • A business lease that binds the buyer lasts at least six years, nine for hotels, and renews for the same period unless the landlord has a legal reason to refuse.
  • The commercial tenant's right to buy first (Law 392/1978, article 38) does not apply to forced sales, according to settled case law.
  • In a bankruptcy sale of a going concern the buyer is not liable for the old business debts unless agreed, but employment protections apply, with possible union agreements.
  • Parking spaces built under the Tognoli law can be sold separately only under strict conditions, usually as an outbuilding of another home in the same town.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. What do Italian cadastral categories mean for commercial property?
  2. VAT or registration tax on a commercial lot?
  3. What happens to a commercial tenant when the shop is sold at auction?
  4. Does the tenant's right to buy first apply at a court auction?
  5. Buying a going concern from a bankruptcy
  6. Are licences included when you buy a shop or hotel at auction?
  7. Hotels and guesthouses
  8. Garages and parking spaces at auction
  9. Shops and offices in residential buildings
  10. Who checks what on a commercial lot?
  11. Are commercial lots at Italian court auctions good value?

Not every Italian court auction is a home. A large share of lots in the public Italian court notices are commercial: a corner shop in a market town, an office floor above a bank, a row of garages, a warehouse on an industrial estate, a seaside hotel, a restaurant with its kitchen and licence, or the whole business of a failed company. Some come from foreclosures against people who owned a shop as an investment. Many come from bankruptcies, where a company's premises and sometimes its whole operation are sold for its creditors.

Commercial lots follow the same court procedure as homes, but they raise questions homes do not: which tax applies, whether a business tenant can stay, whether the tenant can buy first, what happens to employees, whether the licence goes with the building, and whether a parking space can legally be sold on its own. This guide explains those questions in general terms, for readers who know commercial real estate from elsewhere and for first-time buyers who simply want a garage. A lawyer and a commercialista confirm how they apply to any particular lot.

What do Italian cadastral categories mean for commercial property?

Every Italian building unit is recorded in the land registry (catasto) with a category that describes its type. The category is a tax classification, used to calculate the cadastral income on which property taxes are based. The categories used for commercial property include:

  • A/10: offices and private studios (uffici e studi privati), often a flat used by a professional.
  • C/1: shops and workshops selling to the public (negozi e botteghe), including bars and many restaurants.
  • C/2: storerooms and warehouses (magazzini e locali di deposito), including cellars and lofts recorded separately.
  • C/3: workshops for crafts and trades (laboratori per arti e mestieri).
  • C/6: garages, parking spaces, stables and coach houses (autorimesse, rimesse, stalle, scuderie).
  • C/7: closed or open-sided sheds and canopies (tettoie).
  • The D group, buildings for special purposes: D/1 factories, D/2 hotels and guesthouses run for profit, D/7 buildings for industrial uses, D/8 buildings built or adapted for commercial uses such as shopping centres and large stores, among others.

Two cautions. The category is a tax label, not a planning permit: a unit recorded as C/1 is lawful as a shop only if the town's permits say so, and a change of use, for instance turning a shop into a home, usually needs a planning procedure and may not be allowed at all. And the cadastral records are sometimes out of date. The court expert's report, the perizia, is meant to compare the records, the permits and the building as it stands.

VAT or registration tax on a commercial lot?

Who sells decides the tax. When the debtor is a private person, a commercial unit is sold with registration tax at the ordinary rate on the price, plus fixed mortgage and cadastral taxes. The option to pay registration tax on the cadastral value instead of the price (prezzo valore) is for homes and their outbuildings bought by private individuals, so it does not help with a shop or office. First home relief does not apply to commercial units either, except for an outbuilding such as a garage bought with or for a main home.

When the debtor is a VAT-registered company, as in most bankruptcies, a sale of business premises can be exempt or carry VAT, and the mortgage and cadastral taxes become a percentage of the price; our guide to bankruptcy and foreclosure sales sets out the rule. Which tax applies to a particular sale, and what it means for you, is for a lawyer or commercialista to confirm.

What happens to a commercial tenant when the shop is sold at auction?

Many shops and offices at auction are let, and for an investor a sitting tenant paying rent can be the attraction. Whether the tenant stays depends first on whether the lease binds the buyer. The rule is the same as for homes, in article 2923 of the Civil Code: a lease with a legally certain date (data certa) before the seizure binds the buyer, usually because it was registered with the tax office. A lease of more than nine years that was not recorded in the property registers binds the buyer only for nine years from the start. A lease at a rent a third or more below a fair rent, or below the rent of earlier leases, does not bind the buyer.

How long business leases last

Leases of premises for business use are governed by Law 392 of 27 July 1978, still known by its old nickname of equo canone. Its rules give business tenants far more protection than many readers expect from the United States, Canada or Australia, where commercial lease terms are largely negotiated:

  • Minimum length. At least six years for commercial, industrial, craft and professional uses, and at least nine years for hotels and theatres (article 27). Hence the familiar 6+6 and 9+9.
  • Automatic renewal. At the end of the first term the lease renews for the same period, unless the landlord refuses for one of the reasons the law allows, such as needing the premises for their own or their family's use or for major rebuilding, given with long notice (articles 28 and 29). After the second term either side can end it with notice.
  • Goodwill indemnity. When a lease of premises open to the public ends for reasons other than the tenant's default or the tenant's own notice, the landlord must pay the tenant an indemnity for loss of goodwill, normally eighteen months of the latest rent, twenty-one for hotels, and twice that if a similar business opens in the premises within a year (article 34).

For an auction buyer this means a binding business lease can run for many years after the decree, at the agreed rent, and getting the premises back early is rarely possible. If you want the shop for yourself, a sitting tenant with years left is a serious obstacle. If you want income, remember that a tenant in arrears is a problem the court sale passes to you. From the decree, the rent is yours and so are the landlord's duties. Our guide to occupied homes at auction explains how occupants without a binding lease are moved out.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Does the tenant's right to buy first apply at a court auction?

Under article 38 of Law 392/1978, a landlord who wants to sell business premises let to a tenant whose business deals with the public must first offer them to the tenant, by a notice served through a court bailiff, at the same price and terms. The tenant has sixty days to accept. If the landlord sells to someone else without the notice, or at a lower price than offered, article 39 lets the tenant buy the premises back from the buyer within six months of the sale being recorded.

At a court sale, this right does not apply. The law gives it when the landlord intends to sell, and Italian courts have long held that it is excluded in forced sales, in bankruptcy sales and in similar compulsory transfers, because the transfer is not the owner's voluntary choice. The tenant can of course bid like anyone else. Some insolvency routes that are closer to a voluntary sale, such as certain sales under a creditors' arrangement, have been treated differently by some courts, and a lawyer confirms the position where the lot comes from one.

Other rights to buy first need checking separately. The State's right over listed buildings does apply at court sales, as our guide to listed and historic buildings at auction explains, and a historic shop in a protected palazzo can be caught by it.

Buying a going concern from a bankruptcy

A bankruptcy liquidator does not have to sell a company's assets one by one. Under article 214 of the Business Crisis and Insolvency Code (Legislative Decree 14 of 12 January 2019), the business or branches of it should be sold as a whole where that is likely to bring creditors more than a piecemeal sale. Italians call the business as a going concern the azienda, and its sale a cessione d'azienda. A lot can then include the premises, or the lease of them, the equipment, the stock, the brand, the customer contracts and sometimes the staff.

The old debts

Normally, under article 2560 of the Civil Code, someone who buys a business is also liable for its debts shown in the books. In a bankruptcy sale the rule is different: unless the parties agree otherwise, the buyer is not liable for debts arising from running the business before the transfer (article 214, paragraph 3, of the Code). That is a large part of what makes buying from a liquidator attractive.

The employees

Employees are not simply left behind. Article 191 of the Code applies the rules on transfers of undertakings to sales in insolvency, including article 47 of Law 428 of 29 December 1990, which requires the unions to be informed and consulted, and, with them, the protection in article 2112 of the Civil Code, under which staff move to the new owner with their rights. In insolvency the law allows agreements with the unions that change those terms, for instance on how many staff move across or on what conditions. What applies to a given sale depends on the agreements reached and the conditions of sale, and a labour lawyer should read them before you bid.

Leases of the business before the sale

Liquidators often lease a going concern to an operator while they look for a buyer, to keep it alive. With the authorisation of the judge overseeing the procedure and a favourable opinion from the creditors' committee, the lease contract can give that operator a right to buy first when the business is sold (article 212 of the Code), and the notice of sale then explains how it works. A bidder who wins may find the sitting operator entitled to match the price.

For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members get a buying costs box on every lot, with an estimate of the taxes and fees on top of the price.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

Are licences included when you buy a shop or hotel at auction?

Usually not with the building. In Italy the permission to run a business, whether a shop, a bar, a restaurant or a hotel, is an administrative matter tied to the business and the person running it, not to the walls. Most activities are started by filing a certified notice with the town (SCIA), and some need a licence or authorisation, sometimes limited in number, as with some bar and restaurant licences in certain areas. A building bought at auction comes with its lawful planning use, not with a right for you to trade in it.

When a going concern is sold, the new owner generally takes over the running of the business by filing its own notice of takeover (subingresso) and meeting the personal requirements for the activity. Whether a particular authorisation can pass, and on what conditions, depends on the sector and on regional and local rules. A buyer who wants to trade from the premises should have a professional check the permits before bidding, not after.

Hotels and guesthouses

Hotels are among the most eye-catching commercial lots, and among the most complex. A hotel building is usually in the D/2 category. If it is sold as a building, the buyer receives the walls and fittings, not the hotel business: its classification in stars, its operating permits, its staff, its bookings and its reputation all belong to the operator. If it is sold as a going concern, more comes with it, along with the employment and contract questions above.

  • Use. Some regions and towns bind hotel buildings to hotel use in their planning rules, so turning one into flats or a private villa may not be allowed, or only with conditions.
  • Leases. A hotel let to an operator is protected by the nine-year minimum and renewal rules, with a larger goodwill indemnity.
  • Safety and compliance. Fire safety, accessibility and health rules for hotels are demanding, and a building that has been closed for some time may need significant work before it can open again.
  • Seasonality and condition. Seaside and mountain hotels in financial trouble have often gone without maintenance for years.

For most private buyers a hotel lot is a business investment requiring specialist advice, not a large home with extra bedrooms.

Garages and parking spaces at auction

Garages (box auto) and parking spaces are the commercial lots private buyers meet most often, sometimes sold with a flat, sometimes on their own. They are usually in category C/6. A garage bought alone is a modest purchase, but it carries a few legal traps.

Outbuildings of a home

A garage, cellar or parking space is often an outbuilding (pertinenza) of a home: a thing set aside for the lasting service of another (article 817 of the Civil Code). Sold with the home, it shares the home's tax treatment, including first home relief for one outbuilding of each category, as our guide to first home relief at auction explains. Sold separately, it usually pays the ordinary rate.

Tognoli law parking

Many garages and parking spaces under or beside blocks of flats were built under article 9 of Law 122 of 24 March 1989, known as the Tognoli law, which made it easier to build parking for the residents of a building. Those spaces carry a legal bond to the homes they serve. For spaces built on private land, the law allows the space to be sold separately from the home only if, at the same time, it becomes an outbuilding of another home in the same town. For spaces built on land owned by the town, under a surface right, a separate sale is void unless the agreement with the town allows it or the town authorises the deed.

At a court sale this can limit who may buy a garage, or require the buyer to bind it to a home they own in the same town. How the rules apply in a forced sale is not uniform from court to court. A buyer who does not own a home in the town should have a lawyer confirm any such condition before bidding on a separate Tognoli garage.

Older buildings and shared parking

Older planning rules required new buildings to set aside space for parking (article 41-sexies of the town planning law of 1942). For some buildings, depending on when they were built, the courts have held that the flat owners have a right to use those spaces, which can survive a sale of the spaces to someone else. Open parking spaces in a courtyard can also turn out to be shared condominium areas rather than separate units. These are questions for a lawyer with the building's permits and deeds in hand, and the perizia should flag them.

Practical points

  • Size. Some older garages are too small for many modern cars; dimensions matter as much as the price.
  • Access. The ramp, gate and lane to the garage may cross shared or neighbouring land, through an easement.
  • Charges. A garage in a condominium carries its share of the building's costs, and the building can claim the debtor's arrears for the current and previous year from you.
  • Use. A garage recorded as C/6 is for parking and storage. Using it as a workshop or a home needs permits and is often not allowed.
For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members get a lot report for every commercial lot, with its tenant, lease, use and parking conditions set out and the red flags listed in plain English.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

Shops and offices in residential buildings

Many shops and offices at auction are units in ordinary blocks of flats: a ground-floor shop, a first-floor office. Two points deserve attention. The condominium's rules (regolamento di condominio) can forbid certain uses, such as restaurants because of cooking smells, or limit opening hours and signs, and a rule adopted in the right form binds a new owner. And turning a shop or office into a home is a change of use that may need permits, and must meet the town's standards for homes, on ceiling height, light, ventilation and minimum size, which a ground-floor shop often cannot. Buying a shop cheaply in the hope of converting it is a common mistake. Our guide to building irregularities explains why uses and permits matter so much in Italy.

Who checks what on a commercial lot?

Commercial lots are sold with no warranty, like every court sale, and more of their value sits in documents than in bricks. A lawyer reads the lease, if there is one, because it decides whether you are buying vacant premises or a tenancy that may run for up to twelve years, or eighteen for a hotel, and what indemnity could fall due at the end. A surveyor or architect compares the lawful planning use with what you intend, since a change of use can be slow or impossible. A commercialista confirms the tax on the sale and, for a going concern, reads the books and contracts that pass to you, while a labour lawyer looks at any staff and union agreements.

Garages and hotels each add their own specialist: for a Tognoli garage, a lawyer on who may buy it; for a hotel, an engineer on what reopening would take. Our guide to who checks what before you bid explains how these roles fit together on any lot, and our guide to the risks of buying at an Italian court auction puts them in the wider picture.

Are commercial lots at Italian court auctions good value?

They can be. Commercial lots often attract fewer bidders than homes, especially outside big cities, and prices can fall through several rounds, as our guide to price cuts explains. A let shop with a reliable tenant, or a garage in a town short of parking, can be a sensible purchase. But the value depends on things the price does not show: the lease, the use, the tax, the condition and the local demand. Behind many of these lots is a business that closed and people who lost their jobs or their livelihood. A buyer who understands what the lot really is, and what comes with it, is in the best position to make it work again.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

Can a commercial tenant buy first when the shop they rent is sold at an Italian court auction?

No. The tenant's right to buy first under article 38 of Law 392/1978 applies when the landlord chooses to sell, and the courts exclude it in forced and bankruptcy sales. The tenant can still bid like anyone else.

Does a business lease survive an Italian court auction?

Yes, if it has a legally certain date before the seizure and a rent not a third or more below a fair one. The buyer becomes the landlord, bound by the six-year or nine-year terms and renewals of Law 392/1978.

Am I liable for the debts of a business I buy from an Italian bankruptcy?

Not unless you agree to take them on. In a bankruptcy sale the buyer of a going concern is not liable for debts from running it before the transfer. Employment protections still apply, subject to agreements with the unions.

Does a hotel bought at an Italian court auction come with its licence?

Not if only the building is sold. Permits to run a hotel belong to the business and its operator. If the going concern is sold, the new owner usually files its own notice to take over, subject to the sector's rules.

Can anyone buy a garage at an Italian court auction?

Usually, but some garages built under the Tognoli law can only be sold separately if they become an outbuilding of another home in the same town, and those on town-owned land need the town's consent. A lawyer confirms any condition before you bid.

What do cadastral categories C/1, C/6 and A/10 mean on an Italian auction lot?

C/1 is a shop, C/6 a garage or parking space, A/10 an office. The D group covers special buildings such as hotels (D/2) and factories. The category is a tax label; the lawful use comes from the planning permits.

Sources

  1. Law 392/1978, article 27: minimum length of business leases (Normattiva)
  2. Law 392/1978, article 34: indemnity for loss of goodwill (Normattiva)
  3. Law 392/1978, article 38: the tenant's right to buy first (Normattiva)
  4. Civil Code, article 2923: leases that bind the buyer at a forced sale (Normattiva)
  5. Civil Code, article 2112: employees on the transfer of a business (Normattiva)
  6. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code (Legislative Decree 14/2019), article 214: sale of a going concern (Normattiva)
  7. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code, article 191: employment on transfers in insolvency (Normattiva)
  8. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code, article 212: lease of the business (Normattiva)
  9. Law 122/1989 (Tognoli law), article 9: parking spaces bound to homes (Normattiva)
  10. VAT Decree (Presidential Decree 633/1972), article 10: exempt and taxable property sales (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.