Court auction basics

Homes from vacant estates in Italy: buying from an eredità giacente, an inventory estate or the State

Short answer

When nobody accepts an Italian inheritance, the court appoints a curator to manage the estate (eredità giacente). The curator can sell a home only with the court's authorisation, by auction or private sale, signing a notary's deed. A creditor may instead foreclose against the estate, leading to a court auction. Title and mortgages work differently in each case.

Key facts

  • An estate is vacant (giacente) when the heirs have not accepted it and none holds any of its property; the court then appoints a curator (art. 528 of the Civil Code).
  • The curator may sell a home only with the court's authorisation, given by decree and only in cases of necessity or evident advantage (art. 783 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
  • A curator's sale is usually completed by a notary's deed signed by the curator, not by a judge's transfer decree, so mortgages are not cleared in the same way as in a foreclosure.
  • A creditor can also foreclose against the vacant estate; the home is then sold at an ordinary court auction with a transfer decree.
  • An heir who accepts with benefit of inventory, and the State when there are no other heirs (art. 586 of the Civil Code), can also end up selling estate homes, each under its own rules.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. What is an eredità giacente?
  2. Why are homes from vacant estates sold?
  3. Four routes from a vacant estate to a sale
  4. How is a curator's sale run?
  5. Notary's deed or transfer decree: why it matters
  6. Does the buyer get a clean title?
  7. What condition are homes from vacant estates in?
  8. Who lives in a home from a vacant estate?
  9. Taxes and costs when you buy from an estate
  10. What if an heir turns up after the sale?
  11. Risks particular to estate sales
  12. A note on respect

This page is for buyers: people thinking of buying an Italian home that is being sold because its owner died and nobody took on the inheritance, or because the heirs accepted it only up to the value of what it holds. If you are an heir yourself, or a creditor of someone who has died, the questions you face are different, and an Italian lawyer is the right person to advise you.

Homes from vacant estates appear in public Italian court notices and look much like other court sales. But the route by which they reach the market, the person who signs on the seller's side and the way the buyer receives the title can all differ from an ordinary foreclosure. This guide explains what a vacant estate is, why its homes are sold, the four routes a sale can take, and what a buyer should understand before making an offer.

This is a general explanation of Italian law. Practice varies a great deal between courts. A buyer should have the papers for any particular home read by an Italian lawyer.

What is an eredità giacente?

Under Italian law a person does not become an heir simply because someone has died. A person called to inherit, the chiamato, becomes an heir only by accepting the inheritance, expressly or by conduct, and in general has ten years to decide (art. 480 of the Civil Code). Until someone accepts, the estate belongs, in a sense, to nobody in particular.

Usually the family accepts within weeks or months. Sometimes nobody does: the heirs live abroad, or fear the debts, or have renounced one after another. Meanwhile the house stands empty, bills arrive and a bank wants its mortgage paid.

Article 528 of the Civil Code covers this. When the person called has not accepted and is not in possession of any of the estate's property, the court of the district where the succession opened appoints a curator of the estate (curatore dell'eredità giacente). It does so on the request of anyone with an interest, such as a creditor, or of its own motion. From then on the estate is giacente, lying vacant, and the curator manages it.

What the curator does

The curator is usually a lawyer or accountant appointed by the court. Article 529 of the Civil Code sets out the job: draw up an inventory, assert the estate's rights, answer claims against it, administer it, deposit its money as the court directs, and account for the administration. The curator acts under the supervision of a judge, who can replace them at any time, and any act beyond ordinary administration needs that judge's authorisation (art. 782 of the Code of Civil Procedure).

The curator is not an heir and owns nothing. They act for the estate until an heir accepts, which ends the curatorship (art. 532 of the Civil Code), the assets are used up paying the debts, or the estate passes to the State.

Why are homes from vacant estates sold?

A curator is meant to preserve the estate, not to sell it off. For movable goods the law takes a practical line: the curator must arrange their sale within thirty days of the inventory unless the judge decides otherwise, because furniture and cars lose value and are easily lost. For buildings the rule is stricter. Article 783 of the Code of Civil Procedure says the court may authorise the sale of property by a decree in chambers only in cases of necessity or evident advantage.

In practice the reasons are familiar:

  • Debts. The estate owes a mortgage, taxes or condominium fees and holds no cash to pay them.
  • Running costs. An empty house still carries local property tax, insurance, condominium charges and repairs, which slowly eat away the estate.
  • Deterioration. A home left empty for years loses value; selling sooner may protect what is left.

Heirs often refuse an inheritance because the deceased left more debts than assets, and accepting outright would make them personally liable. So a home from a vacant estate is often worth less than what was owed on it, which shapes the price and, often, the condition of the building.

Four routes from a vacant estate to a sale

1. The curator sells, with the court's authorisation

This is the classic vacant estate sale. The curator asks the court for authorisation to sell, usually attaching a valuation, and the court decides whether a sale is justified and on what terms. The decree typically sets the price or starting price and the method of sale. This is not a foreclosure: nothing has been seized. It is a sale by the estate itself, under court supervision.

2. A creditor forecloses against the estate

Often the push comes from a creditor, such as a bank with a mortgage. An enforceable title against someone who has died, such as a judgment or a notarised mortgage loan, can be enforced against their heirs (art. 477 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Where nobody has accepted, there is no heir to pursue, so creditors commonly ask for a curator to be appointed precisely so they have someone to bring the case against. The curator stands in court for the estate, and the creditor seizes and sells the home in an ordinary foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare).

For a buyer, this route looks exactly like any other court auction, with a delegate, a custodian, an expert's report and a transfer decree. Everything in our guide to how Italian court auctions work applies.

3. An heir sells an estate accepted with benefit of inventory

An heir who fears hidden debts can accept with benefit of inventory (accettazione con beneficio d'inventario). The declaration is made before a notary or the court clerk and recorded (art. 484 of the Civil Code), an inventory is drawn up, and the effect is that the heir's own assets stay separate from the estate's: the heir answers for the deceased's debts only up to the value of what they inherited (art. 490).

The price of that protection is control. An heir who sells estate property without the court's authorisation (art. 747 of the Code of Civil Procedure) and the prescribed forms loses the benefit and becomes liable without limit (art. 493 of the Civil Code). Where the estate has to be wound up for its creditors, the heir sells with a notary's assistance and pays creditors in their order of priority (art. 498 and art. 499). The seller is the heir, and the sale is a supervised voluntary sale, not a forced one.

For requests made after 28 February 2023, under the Cartabia reform (Legislative Decree 149 of 10 October 2022), some authorisations for deeds concerning inherited property can be given by the notary who will sign the deed, as an alternative to the court (art. 21 of that decree). How widely it is used for these estates varies. Either way, a valid authorisation must exist before the deed is signed.

4. The State inherits

When there is nobody left entitled to inherit, the estate passes to the State (art. 586 of the Civil Code). The State acquires it by law, without accepting and without the option of renouncing, and answers for the deceased's debts only up to the value of what it receives. Often a curatorship comes first and, when it closes, the curator hands what remains to the body that manages State property. Any later sale follows the rules for selling public property, outside the scope of this guide.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

How is a curator's sale run?

The codes say when a curator may sell, but little about how. The court's decree fills the gap, and it varies more than anything else here. Broadly, there are two approaches.

A competitive sale

Many courts prefer a sale in which anyone can compete, to get the best price. The decree may order a sale on the pattern of a court auction: a valuation by an expert, a published notice, sealed offers with a deposit, a contest between bidders on a set day, and an award to the highest offer. Some courts borrow the foreclosure rules, so far as they fit; others run a lighter procedure with publicity and offers but fewer formalities. The deposit, the minimum offer, the payment term and the method of bidding are all set in the decree and the notice, not by a single national rule.

A private sale at an authorised price

Other courts, especially for modest homes or where a buyer has already come forward, authorise the curator to sell privately at no less than a stated price, sometimes after publicity so that better offers can come in.

Whichever approach applies, the sale ends with the curator signing as seller before a notary, with the court's authorisation cited in the deed. The notary checks the authorisation, the ownership chain in the property registers and the usual planning and energy documents. The conditions of sale say who chooses the notary and who pays the fees, usually the buyer.

There is no custodian in the foreclosure sense: the curator holds the keys and arranges access. And the valuation behind an authorisation request is not bound by the detailed rules for a foreclosure report, so its depth varies.

Notary's deed or transfer decree: why it matters

At a foreclosure sale, ownership passes by the judge's transfer decree (decreto di trasferimento), which also orders the registers to cancel the mortgages and seizures on the home (art. 586 of the Code of Civil Procedure). Our guide to closing and the transfer decree explains that step. A curator's sale normally works differently.

  • How title passes. In a curator's sale, by the notary's deed, a contract. In a foreclosure against the estate, by the transfer decree as usual.
  • Mortgages and other charges. No law gives the curator's sale an automatic cleansing effect like the decree's. In an estate wound up by an heir under benefit of inventory, the law says mortgages cannot be cancelled until the buyer has deposited the price as the court directs or the ranked creditors have been paid (art. 499 of the Civil Code), and curator's sales are commonly handled the same way. In practice the price pays off the mortgage holders and the cancellation follows.
  • Warranty. The rule that a forced sale carries no warranty for defects (art. 2922 of the Civil Code) is written for forced sales, but the conditions of a curator's sale often state that the home is sold as it stands, and once the estate is wound up there is little left to claim against.
  • Occupants. A transfer decree can be enforced against anyone living there without a right to stay. A deed binds the estate that sold, not a third party in the house, so removing such an occupant can mean separate court proceedings.
  • Costs. A deed carries the notary's fees on top of the taxes; a transfer decree carries the delegate's fee for the transfer instead. Our guide to buying costs covers the decree route.

A curator's sale therefore sits between a court auction and a private sale: supervised and authorised by a court, but completed like a private sale. Our comparison of court sales with bank-owned homes and private auctions explains why the decree's protection matters.

Does the buyer get a clean title?

Usually, yes, but less automatically than at a foreclosure.

In a foreclosure against the estate, the transfer decree orders the cancellation of the seizures and mortgages. What survives is what survives any court sale: easements, a lease that binds the buyer, some court claims recorded before the seizure. Our guide to liens, condo fees and easements explains what the decree clears and what it does not.

In a curator's sale or an heir's sale under benefit of inventory, the clean title depends on the mortgage holders being paid out of the price and the entries in the registers being cancelled on that basis. Where the price covers the mortgages, this is routine. Where it does not, the court's decree and the creditors decide how the charges are dealt with, and further formal steps may be needed. Some courts have been willing to order the cancellation themselves once the price is paid; others have not, and the law does not settle the point. This is the main legal question a buyer's lawyer should answer before an offer.

The chain of ownership

The other title question is the chain of owners in the property registers. The deceased must appear as owner, and the curator's appointment or the heir's acceptance must connect the deceased to the sale. Gaps are common where earlier inheritances were never recorded; the notary, or in a foreclosure the notarial certificate and the expert, should catch them. Our guide to inheritance and co-ownership sales describes the problem of unrecorded acceptances in more detail.

For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members get a plain English report for each home that says what kind of procedure it comes from, who is selling and how the title is expected to pass.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

What condition are homes from vacant estates in?

A vacant estate often means a home that has stood empty since its owner died, sometimes since well before. By the time a sale is authorised, it may have been closed for years.

  • Contents. The deceased's furniture and belongings may still be inside. Who clears what is left at handover depends on the conditions of sale.
  • Neglect. Empty homes suffer from damp, failed boilers, roof leaks and break-ins, and utilities are often disconnected.
  • Old irregularities. Changes made decades ago without permits are as common here as in other court sales.
  • Condominium arrears. A buyer can be held jointly liable with the previous owner for contributions of the current and previous year (art. 63 of the implementing provisions of the Civil Code); a lawyer confirms how this applies to the route of sale.

Who lives in a home from a vacant estate?

Most are empty. A relative who lived with the deceased may have stayed on. A surviving spouse living in the home is rare in a true vacant estate, because a person called to inherit who is in possession of estate property cannot leave the estate vacant (art. 528 of the Civil Code), and a spouse in possession who does not make an inventory in time is treated as having accepted outright (art. 485). Where the spouse has renounced, or the home is sold by an heir under benefit of inventory or in a foreclosure, the spouse's right to live in the family home (art. 540 of the Civil Code) can matter a great deal, and a lawyer should check how it is treated. A tenant with a lease agreed by the deceased may also be in place, and a lease with a certain date before the sale can bind a buyer (art. 1599 of the Civil Code), as it can in a foreclosure.

Finally, empty homes sometimes attract people with no right to be there at all. In a foreclosure the transfer decree and the custodian deal with this; our guide to occupied homes explains how. In a curator's sale there is no transfer decree to enforce, so the conditions of sale should say whether the home is handed over empty, and what happens if it is not.

For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members also get a lawyer summary pack for each home, to hand to their own Italian lawyer with the points to confirm.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

Taxes and costs when you buy from an estate

The deceased was usually a private person, and neither the curator nor the estate is in business, so a sale from a vacant estate normally carries registration tax rather than VAT, along with the fixed mortgage and cadastral taxes. First home relief can apply where the buyer meets its conditions.

Where the sale is completed by a notary's deed, the notary calculates the taxes, collects them and registers the deed; where it is a transfer decree, the court route described in our costs guide applies. How the taxable value is measured can differ between the routes; the notary or a commercialista confirms each case.

Clearing the house, repairing years of neglect and reconnecting utilities also fall on the buyer from handover.

What if an heir turns up after the sale?

The curator's job ends when an heir accepts (art. 532 of the Civil Code), but acceptance does not undo what the curator has properly done. The curator represents the estate, a court decision against the curator binds those who later accept, and an heir who accepts takes the estate as the curator's administration has left it, including the price in place of the home.

What matters is that the sale was properly authorised and within the curator's powers. An act a curator carries out beyond their powers, or without the authorisation the law requires, is open to challenge. That is why the notary checks the court's decree and why a buyer's lawyer should see it too.

Risks particular to estate sales

Beyond the general risks of any court-supervised purchase, these belong to estate sales:

  • Misreading the route. A notice that mentions an estate may describe a foreclosure, a curator's sale or an heir's sale. The protections, the costs and the way title passes differ between them.
  • Thin paperwork. A curator may know the home only from the inventory, and the valuation may be shorter than a foreclosure report.
  • Slow timetables. Each step of a curator's sale needs the judge's approval. Completion can take longer than buyers expect.
  • Variation between courts. The same kind of sale can be run quite differently in two neighbouring courts. The decree and the conditions of sale always prevail over general rules.

A note on respect

Behind every vacant estate is someone who died, sometimes with no family close by, and heirs who may have refused the inheritance because accepting it would have meant taking on debts they could not pay. A curator's sale is how Italian law settles what a person left behind and pays the people they owed. Buyers are fully entitled to bid. But the belongings in the house were someone's life, and relatives who come to collect a keepsake deserve patience. Questions about a home are for the person the court has appointed, never for family members.

None of this makes an estate home a poor purchase. Many are sound houses that came to market only because nobody was in a position to take them on. Their main risks are legal ones, and those can be checked before you bid.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What does eredità giacente mean when an Italian home is for sale?

It means the owner has died, nobody has yet accepted the inheritance and no heir holds any of the estate's property, so the court has appointed a curator to manage it. The curator can sell a home only with the court's authorisation.

Is a home from a vacant estate in Italy sold at a court auction?

Sometimes. If a creditor forecloses against the estate, the home is sold at an ordinary court auction with a transfer decree. If the curator sells it, the court authorises the sale and sets the method, which may be a competitive auction-style sale or a private sale at a minimum price.

Who signs the deed when a vacant estate sells an Italian home?

The curator of the estate, as seller, before a notary, citing the court decree that authorised the sale. Where the heirs accepted with benefit of inventory, the heirs sign with the required authorisation. In a foreclosure against the estate, the judge's transfer decree replaces any deed.

Are the mortgages cancelled when you buy from an Italian vacant estate?

Not automatically, as they are by a transfer decree. In a curator's sale the mortgage holders are normally paid from the price and the entries cancelled on that basis. Where the price does not cover the debts, the court's decree and the creditors decide how, so a lawyer should check before you pay.

Can an heir take back an Italian home after the curator has sold it?

Not if the sale was properly authorised and within the curator's powers. Acceptance ends the curatorship but does not undo the curator's proper acts; the heir receives the estate as administered, including the price. A sale made without the required authorisation can be challenged.

Do I take on the deceased owner's debts by buying a home from an Italian estate?

No. The buyer pays the price, not the deceased's debts. But the mortgages on the home must be dealt with as part of the sale, and a buyer of a flat can be held jointly liable for condominium charges of the current and previous year.

Sources

  1. Civil Code, article 528: appointment of the curator of a vacant estate (Normattiva)
  2. Civil Code, article 529: the curator's duties (Normattiva)
  3. Civil Code, article 532: end of the curatorship on acceptance (Normattiva)
  4. Civil Code, article 484: acceptance with benefit of inventory (Normattiva)
  5. Civil Code, article 493: loss of the benefit for unauthorised sales (Normattiva)
  6. Civil Code, article 499: liquidation of an inventory estate and mortgages (Normattiva)
  7. Civil Code, article 586: the State as heir (Normattiva)
  8. Code of Civil Procedure, article 747: authorisation to sell inherited property (Normattiva)
  9. Code of Civil Procedure, article 782: the curator under the judge's supervision (Normattiva)
  10. Code of Civil Procedure, article 783: sale of the vacant estate's property (Normattiva)
  11. Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree (Normattiva)
  12. Legislative Decree 149 of 10 October 2022, article 21: notarial authorisations (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

Where a curator sells by notary's deed, the purchase is completed much like a private sale; for that route, Operation Sicily explains what an Italian notary does in a private sale.