Court sale or something else? Bank-owned homes, private auctions, tax sales and fakes
Short answer
A real Italian court sale is ordered by a judge, run by a court-appointed delegate, published in public court notices, and ends with a decree that clears the mortgages. Bank-owned homes, private online auctions and notary auctions are ordinary sales with a deed. Anyone asking for a deposit into a personal account is not running a court sale.
Key facts
- A court sale comes from a foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare) or an insolvency (liquidazione giudiziale), under a judge.
- Private online auctions, estate-agent auctions and bank resales are ordinary sales: a notary deed, often agent fees, and no court decree.
- The tax collector cannot start a forced sale of a debtor's only home where they live, unless it is a luxury home, and its own sales follow the tax collection law.
- In a court sale the deposit goes only to the account or channel stated in the notice for that procedure, never to a person.
- Nobody can promise you a win, sell you a secret list of court sales that are not public, or reserve a lot for a fee.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What makes a sale a court sale?
- Are there bank-owned (REO) homes in Italy?
- Is a private online auction in Italy a court sale?
- Is a notary auction a court sale?
- Can the tax collector auction a home in Italy?
- Pre-auction deals with the debtor
- Comparing the kinds of sale
- How do you spot a fake Italian court auction?
- What a genuine court sale looks like
- If you think you have been targeted
- Why the difference matters to you
Search for "Italian foreclosures" or "auction homes in Italy" and you meet a mixture of things that look alike. Some are real court sales. Some are homes that a bank or a loan investor is reselling. Some are private auctions run by an agency or an online platform, using the word asta because it sells. A few are not sales at all, but attempts to take a deposit from someone who does not know how the system works.
They are not the same, and the differences matter. A court sale gives you a judge's decree that orders the mortgages and seizures on the home to be cancelled. A private auction gives you an ordinary purchase, with an ordinary contract and whatever protection that contract offers. A fake sale gives you nothing. This guide explains what each kind of sale is, who is selling, what the buyer receives, and the signs that tell a genuine court sale from an imitation.
What makes a sale a court sale?
A court sale (vendita giudiziaria) has one defining feature: the seller is not the owner. A judge orders the property sold, against the owner's wishes, so that creditors can be paid from the price. There are two main routes.
- Foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare). A creditor, usually a bank or a loan investor, has the property seized and asks the court to sell it. The enforcement judge (giudice dell'esecuzione) supervises the case and usually delegates the sale to a professional: a notary, lawyer or accountant on the court's list.
- Insolvency (liquidazione giudiziale, called fallimento in cases opened before 15 July 2022). A court-appointed liquidator (curatore) sells a failed business's assets, or in some cases a person's, for all the creditors together, under a judge's supervision. Our guide to bankruptcy and foreclosure sales explains how the two differ.
Whatever the route, a genuine court sale has the same signs. It is published in public Italian court notices, by law, before the offer deadline. The notice names the court, the case, the judge and the delegate or liquidator. It comes with the sale order and the court expert's report, the *perizia*. Offers go to the delegate in the form the notice sets, with a deposit to the procedure. And the buyer receives the home through a court decree, or in some insolvency sales a deed followed by a judge's order to cancel the charges, rather than through a private contract with the owner.
Our guide to how Italian court auctions work covers the full process. The rest of this guide is about everything that is not a court sale, and why it matters which one you are looking at.
Are there bank-owned (REO) homes in Italy?
In the United States, a home that fails to sell at the foreclosure auction often goes back to the lender and becomes real estate owned, REO. The bank then sells it through a realtor like any other home. Our guide to Italian and US foreclosure auctions sets out the other differences. In Britain and Australia, the lender usually sells a repossessed home itself, through an agent or a private auction.
Italy works differently. The bank does not take the home back on default. It has to go through the court, and the court sells the home to whoever bids. A bank or loan investor ends up owning the home only if it buys it, either by bidding like anyone else or by asking the court to assign the property to it instead of selling it to a low bidder (assegnazione). Even then, the creditor has to pay the price in the usual way, setting it against what it is owed.
After the banking troubles of the 2010s, Italian banks sold large portfolios of bad loans to specialist investors, and these are managed by debt servicers. Some servicers use companies set up to buy homes at court sales when the price falls too low, then resell them later at a better price. Those resales are the closest thing Italy has to REO.
What you get when you buy from a bank or servicer
A home resold by a bank, servicer or one of their companies is an ordinary private sale. The seller owns it outright, usually because it bought it at a court sale and received the decree. You buy with a preliminary contract and a deed signed before a notary, the rogito, just as you would from a private owner. Estate agents often handle these sales and charge their usual commission, and the notary checks the title before the deed.
There is no 75% rule, no offer deadline set by a court, no deposit to a procedure account and no decree. The price is whatever the seller asks and accepts. You can negotiate, make an offer conditional on a mortgage, or walk away before you sign a binding contract. On the other hand, the seller has no reason to sell cheaply: an investor who bought at a court sale wants a profit on the resale.
Some of these homes are sound purchases, with more time and normal contract protections. Just do not mistake them for court auctions.
Short sales and "saldo e stralcio"
Americans know the short sale: the owner sells for less than the mortgage, with the lender's agreement. Italy has a similar arrangement, usually called saldo e stralcio: the creditor accepts a lump sum smaller than the debt and releases its mortgage. The section on pre-auction deals below explains how this connects to court cases.
Is a private online auction in Italy a court sale?
The word asta is not protected. Anyone can call a sale an auction, and many private businesses do. Estate agencies run timed auctions for their clients. Online platforms run private property auctions for owners who want a fast sale. Some of these look very like court sales: a starting price, a deadline, a deposit, online bidding.
They are not court sales. There is no judge, no seizure, no court-appointed delegate and no decree. The seller is the owner, or someone acting for the owner, and the sale ends with a normal notary deed. In practice that means:
- The rules come from the platform's or agency's own terms, not from the Code of Civil Procedure. They can change from one sale to the next.
- Fees are usually higher. Private auctions often charge the buyer a commission or a buyer's premium, on top of the notary's fees and taxes. Court sales charge no buyer's premium; you pay taxes and a share of the delegate's fee for the transfer, set by ministerial tariff.
- The seller may be able to withdraw, or set a hidden reserve price below which they do not have to sell. In a court sale, the starting price and the lowest valid offer are printed in the notice.
- Any mortgage on the home has to be cleared by the seller, with the bank's agreement, at or before the deed. No court orders it cancelled.
- The protections are those of an ordinary sale. The seller gives the usual legal warranties unless the contract excludes them, whereas a court sale comes with none.
None of this makes private auctions bad. For some homes they are a sensible way to sell. But a buyer who believes a private auction is a court sale may assume protections that do not exist, or pay fees that a court sale would not charge. Read the terms, and if the word "court" or "tribunal" is used, ask which court, which case and which judge. A genuine court sale has all three.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
Is a notary auction a court sale?
Notaries take part in auctions in two quite different ways, which confuses many buyers.
First, notaries are often the delegates in court sales. When a judge delegates a foreclosure sale to a notary, the sale is still a court sale in every sense: the notary acts for the court, the notice is a public court notice, and the buyer receives a judge's decree.
Second, notaries also run voluntary auctions (aste volontarie) for private sellers and public bodies who choose to sell by auction. A town council selling an old school, a charity selling a legacy, or a family selling an inherited house can ask a notary to run a formal auction. These are not court sales. Nobody has seized the property. The seller sets the conditions, the notary makes sure the auction runs fairly, and the winner signs a notary deed like any other buyer.
Voluntary auctions run by a notary are usually well organised and transparent, and the notary checks the title before the deed. But the buyer takes on whatever the seller's contract says about mortgages, defects and occupants. There is no judge's decree to cancel charges, and no custodian to free the home.
Can the tax collector auction a home in Italy?
Italy's tax and social security debts are collected by a public body, the collection agent (agente della riscossione). For most of the country that role is held by Agenzia delle Entrate-Riscossione. Like any creditor, it can register a mortgage on a debtor's property and, in some cases, force a sale. Its sales follow special rules in the tax collection law (Presidential Decree 602 of 1973, whose rules are carried into the Consolidated Law on payments and collection, Legislative Decree 33 of 2025), rather than the ordinary foreclosure rules.
The protection for a debtor's only home
The most important rule for families is this. The collection agent cannot start a forced sale of a property if it is the debtor's only property, used as a home, and the debtor is registered as living there. The protection does not cover luxury homes or the top cadastral categories for houses (A/8 villas and A/9 castles and palaces). So in practice the tax collector does not foreclose on an ordinary family's only home.
For other property, the agent can start a forced sale only if the total debt is above €120,000, only after it has registered a mortgage on the property, and only after six months have passed without payment. It also cannot go ahead if the property's value, after deducting mortgages that rank ahead, is below that same threshold. These conditions make tax-collector sales uncommon compared with ordinary foreclosures.
Two details are easy to miss. The first-home protection applies to sales started by the tax collector. If a bank forecloses on the same home, the tax collector can join that case as a creditor, and the home can be sold in the ordinary way.
How a tax-collector sale runs
A sale started by the tax collector is a genuine forced sale, but it is run by the collection agent itself under the tax collection law, not by a court-appointed delegate. The enforcement judge deals with disputes, any assignment of the property to the State and the payment of the proceeds to creditors. The notice sets dates for up to three rounds, at least 20 days apart. The starting price is fixed by formula: three times the property's value worked out from its cadastral income, as for registration tax. Where the property has no cadastral income yet, the land registry office assigns one first. The deposit for each round is 10% of the starting price. If a round fails, the next one starts a third lower. If the third round also fails, the collector can ask the judge to assign the property to the State at the third round's starting price.
For a buyer, the key point is that a tax-collector sale is a genuine forced sale with its own rules, which differ from those of the ordinary court sales most guides describe, including ours. The notice states the conditions. A lawyer should read it with you, because assumptions carried over from ordinary foreclosures, such as the 75% offer floor or the length of the offer window, may not hold.
Pre-auction deals with the debtor
Before a home reaches the auction, the case can end, or change course, in several ways. Buyers sometimes hear about these as "buying before the auction" or "buying the debt". They are real, but they are routes that the owner and the creditors control, not the buyer.
Saldo e stralcio
The debtor, often with an adviser, agrees with the creditor to pay less than the full debt in exchange for the creditor releasing its mortgage and stopping the case. The money for that settlement sometimes comes from selling the home privately to a buyer the owner has found. The buyer then buys from the owner with a notary deed, and the notary makes sure the creditor's release and the cancellation of the mortgage happen with the payment.
This works only if every creditor in the case agrees. A home under seizure cannot simply be sold by its owner: under the Civil Code, a sale made after the seizure has no effect against the creditors in the case. So the buyer in a private deal has to be certain that the case will be closed and every charge lifted. That is legal work for the notary and lawyers, and it is not something a buyer should attempt on the strength of a conversation with the owner.
Other routes the debtor controls
- Paying off the debt. The debtor can pay what is owed, with interest and costs, and the case ends.
- Conversion (conversione del pignoramento). Before the sale is ordered, the debtor can ask the judge to replace the property with a sum of money, which can be paid in instalments where the judge allows it.
- Direct sale (vendita diretta). Under the Cartabia reform, for cases started after 28 February 2023, the debtor can ask the judge, before the hearing that orders the sale, to sell to a buyer the debtor has found, at no less than the court's valuation, with a deposit. If others make better offers, a competition follows. Our guide to the Cartabia reform explains it.
- The creditors withdraw. If every creditor with an enforceable claim gives up the case, it ends.
Courtdoor does not suggest contacting owners whose homes are in court. Families lose these homes, and an approach from a stranger who has read about their debts in a court notice is rarely welcome. If a deal is possible, it will come through the owner's own advisers, the creditors and the court.
Comparing the kinds of sale
The same home can look the same in a photo whatever route it is sold through. What changes is who sells, which rules apply and what you receive.
- Foreclosure court sale: judge and delegate, public notice by law, offers from 75% of the starting price, deposit to the procedure, decree that cancels mortgages and seizures. Sold as seen.
- Insolvency court sale: the liquidator sells under a judge and an approved programme. Similar protections, a freer format, and VAT if the seller is a company.
- Tax-collector sale: a forced sale run by the collection agent itself under the tax collection law, with its own pricing and rounds. Not used against an ordinary family's only home.
- Bank or servicer resale, private online auction, estate-agent auction or voluntary notary auction: an ordinary sale by the owner, with a notary deed, often agent fees or a buyer's premium, and the seller clears the mortgage.
- Pre-auction deal: a private sale by the owner, possible only if every creditor agrees to close the case.
If you are buying an ordinary home rather than a court sale, the route runs through estate agents, a preliminary contract and a notary. Operation Sicily explains how estate agents work in Sicily, and the same principles apply across Italy.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get the court papers for every home explained in plain English, so it is always clear what kind of sale it is.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
How do you spot a fake Italian court auction?
Court sales attract scammers for an obvious reason. The prices look low, the process is unfamiliar, and many buyers are abroad and cannot easily check what they are told. The schemes change, but they rely on a small number of tricks, and each one breaks a rule that every genuine court sale follows.
The deposit paid to the wrong place
In a real court sale, the deposit (cauzione) is part of the offer. It goes to the account named in the notice for that procedure, or through the channel the notice sets, and nowhere else. The account belongs to the procedure, not to a person. If you do not win, it comes back to you the same way.
So treat any request to pay a deposit, a booking fee or a "reservation" to a private person, an agency, a personal account, a foreign account, a payment app or a cryptocurrency wallet as a sign that the sale is not genuine. The same goes for bank details sent by email or messaging app that differ from the notice. Fraudsters can copy a real notice, change the account and send it from an address that looks official. If the details in front of you do not match what the court notice says, do not pay.
Promises of a certain win
Nobody can guarantee you a court sale. The winner is decided by the offers, in the open, under the delegate and the judge. Anyone who says they can make sure you win, reserve a lot for you, keep other bidders away or "arrange" a lower price is either lying or proposing a crime. Interfering with a public auction, by threats, gifts, collusion or fraud, is an offence under article 353 of the Italian Criminal Code, a rule with a long history behind it.
Secret lists and insider access
Every court sale must be published in a public court notice before the offer deadline. There is no hidden list of court sales that only insiders can see, and no "off-market" court auction. Anyone selling a secret list, a pre-release, or homes "not yet published" is offering something that cannot exist. Courtdoor charges for explanation, organisation and reports on homes that are already public, never for access to sales that are hidden, because there are none.
Fake court agents and officials
Judges, delegates, custodians and court clerks do not cold-call buyers, do not advertise on social media, and do not ask for money by email, text or messaging app. A delegate is a registered professional, usually a lawyer, notary or accountant, appointed in the sale order for that case. A custodian looks after the property for the court and can show it to interested buyers, but does not take offers or deposits. Nobody is a "court agent" who sells homes on commission.
Be wary of anyone who claims a title that sounds official but appears in no notice: "court broker", "tribunal agent", "auction officer", "official foreclosure representative". In Italy the people who run a court sale are named in the court's own papers, and their role is set by law. Our guide to who runs a court sale explains each one.
Fees for things that are free
Some charges in a court sale are real: the taxes on the transfer, the buyer's share of the delegate's fee, a stamp duty on the offer, and the fees of any lawyer or surveyor you choose to hire. Others are not. You do not pay the court to see the papers, which are published with the notice. You do not pay the custodian to view the home. You do not pay anyone a "registration fee" to be allowed to bid. If someone asks for money for any of these, ask what law requires it.
What a genuine court sale looks like
Rather than looking for one trick, it is easier to know the shape of a real sale. Every genuine Italian court sale has these features, and a fake usually lacks several of them.
- It has a court, a case number and a judge, and is published in public Italian court notices, in Italian, before the offer deadline.
- It is run by a court-appointed delegate or, in an insolvency, a liquidator, whose name and role appear in the court's papers.
- It comes with the sale order and the court expert's report, published with the notice, not sent privately on request.
- It states the starting price, the lowest valid offer, the deposit, the deadline, the format of the sale and how offers are made.
- The deposit goes only to the account or channel the notice names for the procedure.
- Offers are opened and decided by the delegate, in the open, and every bidder has the same rules.
- The buyer receives the home through the court, not through a private contract with a middleman.
If something about a sale does not fit this shape, stop and ask a lawyer. An Italian lawyer can confirm with the court whether a case and a sale exist, who the delegate is, and what the notice actually says. That costs far less than a lost deposit.
If you think you have been targeted
If you have paid money to someone you now suspect, act quickly. Contact your bank at once and ask it to try to recall or freeze the transfer; the first hours matter. Keep every message, email, receipt and bank detail. Report the matter to the police in your own country and to the Italian postal and communications police, who handle online fraud. If the scam used the name of a real professional, tell that professional too, so they can warn others.
Never pay a second fee to someone who offers to recover the first: recovery scams are common after any fraud.
Why the difference matters to you
Knowing which kind of sale you are looking at changes who you deal with, which fees apply, how fast you must move and what you own at the end. A court sale can be the cheapest route, with no warranty and fixed deadlines. A private auction or bank resale is easier, but rarely at court-sale prices.
Neither is right or wrong. What goes wrong is mistaking one for the other: paying a buyer's premium because you thought you were at a court sale, or assuming a decree will clear a mortgage that a private seller has to clear. If you are weighing up whether a court sale suits you at all, our guide on whether Italian court auction homes are worth it sets out the trade-offs, and our guide to buying costs shows what a court sale really costs.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
Are Italian bank-owned homes the same as court auction homes?
No. A bank or loan investor owns a home only after buying it, usually at a court sale. When it resells, the sale is an ordinary private purchase with a notary deed and often agent fees, not a court sale with a judge's decree.
Is a private online property auction in Italy a court sale?
No. Private auctions run by platforms or estate agencies are ordinary sales by the owner under the organiser's own terms. There is no judge or decree, the seller must clear any mortgage, and buyers often pay a commission or buyer's premium.
Can the Italian tax collector auction off someone's only home?
Not by starting the sale itself. Under the tax collection law, the collection agent cannot force the sale of a debtor's only property used as their home where they are registered as living, unless it is a luxury home. It can still join a sale started by another creditor.
Where does the deposit go in a genuine Italian court sale?
Only to the account or channel named in the court notice for that procedure. It never goes to a person, an agency or a personal account. Bank details sent by email that differ from the notice are a warning sign.
Can someone guarantee I will win an Italian court auction?
No. The result depends on the offers, decided in the open by the court-appointed delegate. Anyone promising a win or offering to keep rivals away is lying or proposing a crime under article 353 of the Criminal Code.
Can I buy a home from the owner before it goes to auction?
Only if every creditor in the case agrees to settle and lift the charges, usually through a notary. A sale made after the seizure has no effect against the creditors, so a private deal without their agreement leaves the buyer exposed.
Sources
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 591-bis: delegating the sale to a professional (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 568-bis: the direct sale requested by the debtor (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 495: conversion of the seizure (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2913: sales after the seizure have no effect against the creditors (Normattiva)
- Presidential Decree 602 of 1973, article 76: forced sales by the tax collector, rules carried into Legislative Decree 33 of 2025 (Normattiva)
- Presidential Decree 602 of 1973, article 81: second and third rounds in tax-collector sales, rules carried into Legislative Decree 33 of 2025 (Normattiva)
- Business Crisis Code, article 216: sales in judicial liquidation (Normattiva)
- Criminal Code, article 353: interfering with public auctions (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

