Court auction basics

Foreclosure or bankruptcy sale? The two kinds of court auction in Italy, and VAT on company sales

Short answer

Italian court auctions come from two kinds of case. A foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare) sells one debtor's property for the creditors under the Code of Civil Procedure. A bankruptcy sale, called liquidazione giudiziale under the Business Crisis Code, sells a failed business's assets through a court-appointed liquidator. The rules, the people and sometimes the tax differ, notably VAT on company sales.

Key facts

  • Foreclosure sales follow the Code of Civil Procedure; bankruptcy sales follow the Business Crisis Code (Legislative Decree 14/2019).
  • Bankruptcies on petitions filed from 15 July 2022 are called liquidazione giudiziale; earlier ones remain fallimenti.
  • In a foreclosure a delegate runs the sale for the judge; in a bankruptcy the liquidator (curatore) sells under a programme, supervised by a delegated judge.
  • Bankruptcy sales use competitive procedures; as in a foreclosure, offers are valid from 75% of the stated price.
  • The delegated judge can suspend a sale for serious reasons, or stop it when the price is far below a fair one.
  • A sale by a VAT-registered company can carry VAT instead of registration tax; the notice says which.
Italy’s court auctions in numbersSee what members get

12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts

8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days

in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties

Contents
  1. What is the difference between a foreclosure and a bankruptcy sale?
  2. Who runs a bankruptcy sale in Italy?
  3. How a bankruptcy sale is planned
  4. How bankruptcy sales run
  5. Can the judge stop a bankruptcy sale?
  6. How are the old mortgages cleared?
  7. Occupied property in a bankruptcy
  8. When does VAT apply instead of registration tax?
  9. Foreclosure or bankruptcy: the differences at a glance
  10. What buyers should watch in a bankruptcy sale
  11. Are bankruptcy sales better value?

Most people who follow Italian court auctions meet the phrase aste fallimentari, bankruptcy auctions, sooner or later. They look much like other court sales: a notice, a starting price, a deadline for offers and a deposit. But they come from a different kind of case, run under a different law by different people, and they can carry a different tax. Knowing which kind of sale you are looking at changes what you should expect.

This guide explains the two kinds of Italian court auction, foreclosure sales and bankruptcy sales, who runs each, how their sale rules differ, how the old mortgages are cleared, and when VAT applies instead of registration tax. It explains the taxes only in general terms: a lawyer or commercialista confirms which tax applies to each sale.

What is the difference between a foreclosure and a bankruptcy sale?

Foreclosure: esecuzione immobiliare

A foreclosure (esecuzione immobiliare) is one creditor's action against one debtor. A bank or other creditor with a court order or a mortgage has the property seized (pignoramento) and asks the court to sell it. The debtor is often a private person or family, and the home is often the one they live in. Other creditors can join, but the case is about that property and those debts. The rules are in Book III of the Code of Civil Procedure, from article 555 onwards. Our guide to how Italian court auctions work covers this route in full.

Bankruptcy: liquidazione giudiziale, formerly fallimento

A bankruptcy is a collective case. When a business is insolvent, the court opens a procedure that takes over all its assets for all its creditors together. For decades this was the fallimento, under the Bankruptcy Law of 1942. The Business Crisis and Insolvency Code (Codice della crisi d'impresa e dell'insolvenza, Legislative Decree 14 of 12 January 2019) came into force on 15 July 2022 and renamed it liquidazione giudiziale. Cases whose petition was filed before that date still run as fallimenti under the old law; later ones are liquidazioni giudiziali. In everyday Italian the sales are still called aste fallimentari. Bankruptcy sales have deep roots: our short history of Italian court sales traces them back to Rome.

Once a business is in liquidazione giudiziale, its individual creditors can no longer start or continue their own foreclosures on its property (article 150 of the Code). A foreclosure already running can be taken over by the liquidator or closed, so the property ends up being sold inside the bankruptcy. One exception: a lender holding a mutuo fondiario, a special type of mortgage loan, can start or continue its own foreclosure even after the insolvency opens, as the Court of Cassation has held. The property is then sold at an ordinary foreclosure sale, and the insolvency procedure checks what that lender may keep. A lawyer can confirm how this applies to a given case.

Smaller debtors: liquidazione controllata

Consumers, professionals, farmers and small businesses that fall below the thresholds for liquidazione giudiziale have their own procedure under the same Code, the liquidazione controllata (article 268 onwards). A liquidator sells their assets in much the same way. You may meet homes from these cases too, sold under rules close to those of a bankruptcy sale.

For buyers the practical point is simple. A notice from a foreclosure names an enforcement judge and a delegate. A notice from a bankruptcy names a delegated judge and a liquidator, and usually the company. The notice and its papers say which kind of case it is.

Who runs a bankruptcy sale in Italy?

In a foreclosure

  • The enforcement judge (giudice dell'esecuzione) supervises the case, orders the sale and signs the transfer decree.
  • The delegate (professionista delegato), a notary, lawyer or accountant, runs the sale for the judge.
  • The custodian looks after the property and shows it to people thinking of bidding.
  • The court expert values the property and writes the perizia.

In a bankruptcy

  • The court (tribunale) opens the procedure with a judgment and appoints the people who will run it.
  • The delegated judge (giudice delegato) supervises the procedure, authorises the sales and decides disputes about them.
  • The liquidator (curatore), usually a lawyer or accountant, manages and sells the assets. In the old fallimento the same person was usually called the bankruptcy trustee.
  • The creditors' committee (comitato dei creditori) represents the creditors and approves the liquidator's sale programme.
  • Experts appointed by the liquidator value the assets.

Our guide to who runs an Italian court sale explains the foreclosure roles in more detail. The glossary has short entries on the *curatore* and on *fallimento* and *liquidazione giudiziale*.

How a bankruptcy sale is planned

A foreclosure sale follows the judge's sale order. A bankruptcy sale follows a plan. Under article 213 of the Business Crisis Code, the liquidator must prepare a liquidation programme within sixty days of drawing up the inventory, and in any event within 150 days of the judgment opening the case. The programme sets out how and when each asset will be sold. The delegated judge authorises it to go to the creditors' committee, which approves it. After that, the judge authorises individual sales as long as they follow the approved programme.

The programme also sets the pace. The liquidation as a whole should be completed within five years of the opening judgment, which the judge can extend in complex cases. And if an asset fails to sell after six attempts, the law presumes that carrying on is pointless. The liquidator can then, with the committee's authorisation, give up selling it, after which creditors may pursue it individually, which can mean the same property coming back later as an ordinary foreclosure.

Cover of The Courtdoor BriefingFree PDF
The Courtdoor Briefing · free PDF

Italy’s court auction homes, in three pages

Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.

  1. 01Where the homes are
  2. 02The 75% rule
  3. 03Three typical homes
  4. 04A court sale in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

How bankruptcy sales run

Article 216 of the Business Crisis Code sets the rules for selling. Its key phrase is procedure competitive, competitive procedures. The liquidator, or a delegate for the sales, must sell through a procedure that lets anyone compete, with publicity that ensures the widest information and participation, on the basis of the experts' valuation. The liquidator may use specialist firms to run the sale; where the sale is online, it runs on an approved platform named in the notice.

Within that frame the liquidator has more freedom than a foreclosure delegate. In practice many bankruptcy sales look very like foreclosure sales, but some details differ, and they are set in each notice:

  • The deposit. The law says an offer is ineffective if the bidder does not pay the deposit in the amount stated. That amount is set in the notice and need not match the usual foreclosure figure.
  • The 75% floor. As in a foreclosure, offers are valid even if they are up to a quarter below the price stated in the notice or order.
  • Publicity. The notice must be published at least thirty days before the sale, a period the judge can shorten only in cases of absolute urgency.
  • The pace. For property the liquidator must hold at least one sale attempt in the first year and two in each following year.
  • Price cuts. After the third deserted attempt the price can be cut by up to half of the last one. In a foreclosure the cut of up to half comes after the fourth.
  • Payment. The sale can allow the price to be paid in instalments, applying the Code of Civil Procedure rules where they fit.
  • Viewings. People thinking of bidding have a right to examine the property within fifteen days of asking, or another term set by the judge, through the channel the notice states, without meeting one another.

There is also a second route. In the programme the liquidator can propose that the delegated judge sells a property under the Code of Civil Procedure rules, so far as they fit (article 216, paragraph 3). In that case the sale looks and runs like a foreclosure sale, with a sale order and a transfer decree.

Bankruptcies can also sell property in blocks, or as part of a whole business or branch of it (article 214). A hotel, a factory with its land, or a builder's remaining stock of flats may be offered together. For a private buyer looking for one home, those lots are rarely suitable, but the notice makes the composition clear.

The rules above are the general ones. Each bankruptcy sale has its own notice, and the notice is what binds you: read the deposit, the offer method, the payment term and the transfer route in it, not in a general guide.

Can the judge stop a bankruptcy sale?

This is the most important difference for a buyer, and the one most often missed. Article 217 of the Business Crisis Code gives the delegated judge two powers.

Suspending the sale

On a request from the debtor, the creditors' committee or another interested party, and after hearing the committee, the judge can suspend the sale operations by a reasoned decree when there are serious and justified reasons.

Stopping the sale when the price is too low

The same people can ask the judge, within ten days of the liquidator filing the sale documents, to prevent the sale from being completed when the price offered is markedly lower than one considered fair. The liquidator must file those documents within five days of the end of each sale. And where the price offered is below the stated price by no more than a quarter, the judge can prevent completion if there is concrete evidence that a new attempt will very probably reach at least the stated price.

In other words, winning a bankruptcy sale is not quite the end of the story. For a short period after the sale, the result can be challenged on price. In practice this is uncommon, and a sale at or near the stated price after proper publicity is rarely stopped. But a buyer who wins with a low offer on a valuable asset should know the power exists, and should not commit money elsewhere until the period has passed. Foreclosure law has a similar but narrower power: after the price is paid, the judge can suspend a sale if the price is markedly below a fair one (article 586 of the Code of Civil Procedure).

How are the old mortgages cleared?

In a foreclosure, the judge's transfer decree both transfers the property and orders the registers to cancel its mortgages and seizures (article 586 of the Code of Civil Procedure). In a bankruptcy sale the same result comes by a slightly different route. Under article 217, paragraph 2, of the Business Crisis Code, once the property is sold and the whole price collected, the delegated judge orders by decree the cancellation of mortgages and other charges giving priority, of registered seizures and attachments, and of any other restriction. The old Bankruptcy Law had the same rule in article 108.

So the buyer at a bankruptcy sale also receives the property free of the company's mortgages. As in a foreclosure, rights that are not debts can survive: easements, a lease that binds the buyer, some court claims. The papers should say what remains.

Deed or decree

One practical difference catches buyers out. In a foreclosure the transfer is always the judge's decree. In a bankruptcy sale run as a competitive procedure by the liquidator, ownership often passes by a notary's deed signed by the liquidator, followed by the judge's decree cancelling the charges. Where the judge sells under the civil procedure rules, there is a transfer decree as in a foreclosure. Which route applies changes the costs, because a notary's deed carries a notary's fee, and the notice usually says who chooses the notary and who pays. Our guide to buying costs explains the costs of the decree route.

Occupied property in a bankruptcy

In a bankruptcy the delegated judge makes an order to free the property when it is occupied by the debtor or by anyone whose right to stay cannot be enforced against the liquidator (article 216, paragraph 2). The liquidator carries out the order as the judge directs, even after the transfer, in the buyer's interest, unless the buyer releases the liquidator from that task. Where the debtor is a person, such as a sole trader, their own home has a special rule: so far as it is needed to house them and their family, it cannot be taken from that use until it is sold (article 147). A lease with a legally certain date before the procedure can bind the buyer, as in a foreclosure.

Most bankruptcy property is not lived in: offices, warehouses, shops, land and a builder's unsold flats are common. Where a home is occupied, the timing of possession is set by the judge's order and can take months, as in a foreclosure.

For members

Each home’s court papers, explained

Members get a buying costs box on every home, showing whether VAT or registration tax applies to that sale and what it adds to the price.

See membership
Court papers, in plain EnglishExample
  • OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
  • PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
  • CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you

When does VAT apply instead of registration tax?

This is the tax point that most separates company sales from sales of a private person's home. A private person who is not in business never charges VAT. A VAT-registered company does, in some cases, and the forced nature of the sale does not change that. The rules below apply whenever the debtor is a VAT-registered business, in a bankruptcy or in an ordinary foreclosure against a company. The procedure, through the delegate or the liquidator, handles the invoice on the debtor's behalf, and the notice usually states whether the price is plus VAT.

Homes sold by companies

Under article 10, number 8-bis, of the VAT Decree (Presidential Decree 633 of 1972), sales of residential buildings by businesses are exempt from VAT, with exceptions. The main one: a company that built or substantially renovated the building charges VAT if it sells within five years of finishing the work, and may choose to charge it after five years. Bankrupt building companies are therefore a common source of homes sold with VAT. Other companies, for example one that owned a flat as an investment, normally make an exempt sale, which is taxed like a private sale.

  • Exempt sale of a home: registration tax at 9%, or 2% with first home relief, never less than €1,000, plus €50 each in mortgage and cadastral tax.
  • Home sold with VAT: VAT at 10%, or 4% with first home relief, or 22% for luxury categories, plus €200 each in registration, mortgage and cadastral tax.

For a private buyer, a sale with VAT is usually more expensive than an exempt one, because 10% VAT on the whole price outweighs the 9% registration tax it replaces, and the €200 fixed taxes are higher than €50. The gap is smaller with first home relief, where 4% VAT replaces 2% registration tax. The option to pay registration tax on the cadastral value rather than the price (prezzo valore) applies only to sales without VAT, so it is not available when VAT is charged.

Commercial property

Offices, shops, warehouses and other business premises (immobili strumentali) follow article 10, number 8-ter. Their sale is exempt unless the builder or renovator sells within five years, or the seller opts to charge VAT. Either way, mortgage and cadastral taxes are 3% and 1% of the price, and registration tax is €200. A private buyer pays any VAT on top of the price. A VAT-registered business buyer is treated differently, and that is a matter for its own adviser.

Building land

Building land sold by a VAT-registered business is subject to VAT at the standard rate. Agricultural land is taxed differently. Land lots in bankruptcies are common, and the notice should state the tax treatment.

What this means for a buyer

The tax treatment is fixed by who the seller is and what is sold, not chosen by you. For a private buyer, VAT is a real cost. When you compare a bankruptcy lot with a foreclosure lot, compare the total cost, not the price: the same price can mean very different taxes. A lawyer or commercialista confirms the position for each sale.

Foreclosure or bankruptcy: the differences at a glance

  • Law: Code of Civil Procedure for foreclosures; Business Crisis Code (or the old Bankruptcy Law for older cases) for bankruptcies.
  • Who sells: a delegate under the enforcement judge; a liquidator under a delegated judge, following a programme the creditors approve.
  • Sale method: sealed offers and bidding under the sale order; competitive procedures under the programme, often similar in practice.
  • Deposit: at least 10% of the offer in a foreclosure; the amount the notice states in a bankruptcy.
  • Price cuts: in a foreclosure, up to a quarter a round and up to half after the fourth deserted round; in a bankruptcy, up to half after the third.
  • After the sale: the judge can stop a bankruptcy sale for a markedly low price on a request within ten days of the filing.
  • Transfer: judge's decree in a foreclosure; notary's deed or decree in a bankruptcy, with a decree cancelling the charges.
  • Seller: often a private person in a foreclosure; a company in a bankruptcy, so VAT can apply.

What buyers should watch in a bankruptcy sale

  1. Which law applies. A fallimento begun on a petition filed before 15 July 2022 follows the old Bankruptcy Law, a liquidazione giudiziale the new Code. The broad rules are similar, but the details in the notice are what count.
  2. The deposit and offer rules in the notice, which can differ from the foreclosure norm.
  3. The transfer route: deed or decree, who chooses the notary, and who pays the notary and the cancellation duties.
  4. VAT. Whether the price is plus VAT, at which rate, and what that adds to your total.
  5. The window after the sale in which the result can be challenged on price.
  6. What is in the lot: one home, a block of flats, a share, or part of a business.
  7. Occupancy and any lease that binds the buyer.
  8. Condominium arrears. As in a foreclosure, the building may try to claim unpaid charges for the current and previous year from the new owner; some points are argued differently in insolvency cases, so read what the notice says.
  9. The state of the property. Bankrupt companies rarely maintain what they own, and unfinished buildings are common.

Every court sale, foreclosure or bankruptcy, is sold as seen with no warranty for defects. The papers are your main protection, and the court valuation report is the first thing to understand.

Are bankruptcy sales better value?

Not as a rule. Bankruptcy sales are no cheaper by nature than foreclosures. Some go well below value because they are unusual, large or in poor condition; others draw strong interest because a building company's new flats are in good order. The faster cut after three failed attempts can bring prices down sooner, and many bankruptcy homes are empty, which saves the wait for possession. Against that, VAT can raise the cost, and the window to challenge a low price adds a little uncertainty. For how cuts work in general, see our guide to failed rounds and price cuts.

If you are new to court sales, it can help to see how they compare with other ways of buying, such as bank-owned homes and private online auctions. Our guide to court sales compared with other routes sets them side by side, and our comparison of Italian and US foreclosure auctions shows how the Italian system differs from North American foreclosures.

Your next step

Ready to look at real homes?

Start free

The Courtdoor Briefing

  1. 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
  2. 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
  3. 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
  4. 04How a court sale works, in four steps

Unsubscribe any time.

Membership

See every home, not just a third

Founder price · for a limited time
£49a year, or £4.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
€59a year, or €5.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
US$64a year, or US$6.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
CA$94a year, or CA$9.49 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
A$99a year, or A$9.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member
NZ$119a year, or NZ$11.99 a month, kept for as long as you stay a member

After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month

After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month

After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month

After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month

After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month

After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month

  • Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
  • A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
  • Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
  • A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
  • Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
What a member seesExample
Exact price
€38,400
Auction
13 Mar
Red flags
2
Become a founder member

Cancel online any time.

Questions buyers ask

What is an asta fallimentare?

It is a sale of property belonging to a bankrupt business, run by the court-appointed liquidator (curatore) under a delegated judge. Bankruptcies on petitions filed from 15 July 2022 are called liquidazione giudiziale, but the sales are still widely called aste fallimentari.

What is the difference between a foreclosure and a bankruptcy auction in Italy?

A foreclosure sells one debtor's property for its creditors under the Code of Civil Procedure, run by a delegate for the enforcement judge. A bankruptcy sale sells a failed business's assets for all its creditors under the Business Crisis Code, run by a liquidator following an approved programme.

Do I pay VAT when buying at an Italian bankruptcy auction?

Sometimes. If the seller is a VAT-registered company and the sale falls under VAT, for example a builder selling within five years of finishing the works, VAT replaces most of the registration tax. Many company sales of homes are exempt. The notice says which applies.

Can a bankruptcy sale in Italy be cancelled after I win?

Yes, in narrow cases. Within ten days of the liquidator filing the sale papers, the debtor, creditors' committee or others can ask the delegated judge to stop the sale if the price is markedly below a fair one. It is uncommon after a properly advertised sale.

Does a bankruptcy sale clear the company's mortgages?

Yes. Once the property is sold and the whole price paid, the delegated judge orders the cancellation of mortgages, seizures and other charges by decree. Easements and a lease that binds the buyer can survive.

Is there a notary at an Italian bankruptcy sale?

Often. When the liquidator sells by competitive procedure, ownership commonly passes by a notary's deed signed by the liquidator, with a separate decree cancelling the charges. When the judge sells under civil procedure rules, a transfer decree is used instead. The notice says which.

Sources

  1. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code (Legislative Decree 14/2019), article 213: the liquidation programme (Normattiva)
  2. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code, article 216: how assets are sold (Normattiva)
  3. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code, article 217: the delegated judge's powers and cancelling charges (Normattiva)
  4. Business Crisis and Insolvency Code, article 150: no individual enforcement after opening (Normattiva)
  5. Bankruptcy Law (Royal Decree 267/1942), article 108: older cases (Normattiva)
  6. Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree in a foreclosure (Normattiva)
  7. VAT Decree (Presidential Decree 633/1972), article 10: exempt and taxable property sales (Normattiva)

General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.