Italian court auctions vs German Zwangsversteigerung: 10 differences for German bidders
Short answer
An Italian court auction and a German Zwangsversteigerung both sell seized property under court control, but work differently. Italy uses sealed offers sent by a deadline, a 75% floor in every round, a deposit of at least 10% of your offer, and ownership only by a judge's decree after the balance is paid, within 120 days at most.
Key facts
- Germany auctions in a live hearing at the Amtsgericht; Italy collects sealed offers by a deadline, mostly online.
- Germany's 5/10 and 7/10 limits fall away once the award has been refused under them; Italy's 75% floor applies in every round.
- The German Sicherheitsleistung is 10% of the Verkehrswert; the Italian deposit is at least 10% of the price you offer.
- In Germany the Zuschlag makes you owner; in Italy only the transfer decree does, after the balance is paid.
- Italy's decree clears mortgages and seizures; Germany can leave prior rights on the property.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
German buyers who come to Italian court auctions usually know their own system well. Some have bought at a Zwangsversteigerung, many have sat in the public seats at an Amtsgericht to watch one, and nearly all know the words: Verkehrswert, Gutachten, Bargebot, Zuschlag. That knowledge is useful, because Italy and Germany share the basic idea of a forced sale run under court control. It is also a trap, because many of the rules that German bidders take for granted do not exist in Italy, and some work the other way round.
This guide first sums up how a German forced sale works under the Zwangsversteigerungsgesetz (ZVG), then sets out ten differences that matter when you bid in Italy. It keeps to the auction process. For the Italian sale from start to finish, read how Italian court auctions work, and for the rules that apply to every buyer from abroad, buying from abroad.
How does a Zwangsversteigerung work in Germany?
In Germany, a creditor with an enforceable claim applies to the local court, the Amtsgericht acting as enforcement court (Vollstreckungsgericht), which orders the forced sale and records it in the land register (Grundbuch). The sale is handled by a Rechtspfleger, a court officer with legal training. The court appoints an expert, whose report (Gutachten) values the property, and then fixes the market value (Verkehrswert) by formal decision.
The auction date (Versteigerungstermin) is announced publicly well in advance, at least six weeks before the hearing. The hearing is held in a courtroom. The Rechtspfleger reads out the conditions, including the lowest bid the law allows (geringstes Gebot), which covers the costs and the rights ranking ahead of the creditor who is pursuing the sale. Those prior rights usually stay on the property (bestehenbleibende Rechte), and the cash part of the bid (Bargebot) is what bidders compete over. Bidding then runs openly for at least 30 minutes.
A creditor can ask a bidder to provide security (Sicherheitsleistung) of one tenth of the Verkehrswert, which must be paid before the hearing by transfer to the court, or by a cheque of the kind the law accepts, never in cash. In the first hearing, if the highest bid together with the rights that stay on the property is below half the Verkehrswert, the court must refuse the award. If it is below seven tenths, a creditor who would lose out can ask for it to be refused. Once the award has been refused under either limit, neither applies at the next hearing.
If the award (Zuschlag) is granted, the highest bidder (Ersteher) becomes owner with it, at once, even before the Grundbuch is corrected. The Bargebot is paid later, at the distribution hearing (Verteilungstermin), with interest from the date of the Zuschlag. The Zuschlag also serves as an order for possession against occupiers who have no right to stay, and the court then asks the land register office (Grundbuchamt) to enter the new owner.
The Italian sale in brief
In Italy, a creditor has the property seized (pignoramento) and asks the court to sell it. The judge (giudice dell'esecuzione) appoints an expert, whose report, the perizia, values the property, and a custodian (custode giudiziario) who looks after it. The judge then orders the sale and almost always delegates it to a professional, the professionista delegato, usually a notary, lawyer or accountant.
The delegate publishes a public court notice with the starting price (prezzo base), the lowest valid offer, the deposit and the deadline. Buyers send sealed offers with their deposit by that deadline. On the opening date the delegate opens all offers together; a single valid offer can win, and two or more lead to a contest from the highest. The winner pays the balance within the term in the notice, at most 120 days, and the judge signs the transfer decree (decreto di trasferimento). If nobody makes a valid offer, the delegate fixes a new round at a lower price. Our guides to the starting price and the auction day and price cuts explain both stages.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
What are the differences between a Zwangsversteigerung in Germany and Italy?
1. Who runs the sale
In Germany the Rechtspfleger runs the whole auction in court, in person. In Italy the judge oversees the case, but the sale itself is delegated to an outside professional who works from their own office and, in most sales, online. You deal with the delegate for the sale and with the custodian for the property; the judge appears mainly at the start and at the decree.
2. Sealed offers instead of a live hearing
A German Versteigerungstermin is a live auction: you come to court, or send someone, and bid openly. Italy works in two stages. Almost every Italian sale is a sale without auction (vendita senza incanto): first sealed offers by a deadline, then a contest only if there are two or more valid offers. Most sales are online, either with all bidders connected at once or with raises over a set period, often a day or more. Some are mixed, with bidders online and in person. You cannot simply turn up on the day: if you did not send a valid offer by the deadline, you cannot bid at all.
3. The starting price is not the Verkehrswert
German bidders think in fractions of the Verkehrswert. Italy has a similar valuation, the market value in the perizia, but the number that matters is the starting price. The expert usually applies a discount to the market value for the lack of a warranty and the risks of a forced sale, and the judge sets the starting price from that. So even in the first round, the starting price is normally below the market value, and the lowest valid offer is a quarter below the starting price. Comparing an Italian starting price with a German Verkehrswert compares two different things.
4. A floor in every round, and price cuts between them
In Germany the 5/10 and 7/10 limits protect the debtor and creditors only until the award has once been refused under them; at the next hearing, a bid at the geringstes Gebot can win. Italy works the other way. In every round, an offer below 75% of the starting price is void. Instead of dropping the limits, Italy lowers the price: after a round with no valid offer, the starting price can be cut by up to a quarter, and after the fourth deserted round by up to half. A home can pass through several rounds, each with a lower starting price and a lower floor, but there is never a round with no floor at all.
5. The deposit: 10% of your offer, with the offer
The German Sicherheitsleistung is one tenth of the Verkehrswert, the same for every bidder, and only due if someone asks for it. The Italian deposit (cauzione) is always required, and it is at least 10% of the price you offer, or more if the notice asks. It goes with the offer, by bank transfer to the procedure's account, and must be credited by the time the notice sets, often before the offer deadline. A late deposit makes the offer void. A losing bidder gets it back, a winner sees it set against the price, and a winner who does not pay the balance forfeits it. Our guide to the valid offer and the deposit covers the details.
6. Who may bid, and who may bid for you
In Germany even the debtor may bid, though creditors can demand higher security from them, and anyone holding a publicly certified power of attorney (öffentlich beglaubigte Vollmacht) can bid for you. In Italy the debtor is barred from bidding. In a sale without incanto, only you or an Italian lawyer (avvocato) with a special power of attorney (procura speciale) can make the offer and bid. A relative, a friend or an estate agent cannot, however clearly you have authorised them. Our guide to bidding through a lawyer explains the power of attorney.
7. When you become the owner
This is the difference German buyers most often get wrong. The German Zuschlag transfers ownership at once; the price follows at the Verteilungstermin. In Italy the order is reversed. Winning is the award (aggiudicazione), which binds you but does not make you owner. You must first pay the balance, within the term in the notice and at most 120 days, and only then does the judge sign the transfer decree. Ownership passes with the decree, not with the award. Until then, the debtor is still the owner on paper. Our guide to the transfer decree follows those steps.
8. What you take on with the property
In Germany you take over the rights that rank ahead of the pursuing creditor, which the geringstes Gebot lists, and you must count them as part of your price. In Italy the decree orders the cancellation of all mortgages and seizures, whatever their rank; there is nothing comparable to bestehenbleibende Rechte for mortgages. Some things do survive: easements, a lease that was registered or dated before the seizure, and some rights of use. Condominium arrears also work differently. In Germany, unpaid Hausgeld has a privileged rank and is paid from the proceeds, within limits. In Italy the buyer is jointly liable with the former owner for the condominium charges of the current and the previous year.
Tenants are treated differently too. A German Ersteher has a special right to end a lease at the first permitted date, subject to tenant protection. In Italy a lease that binds the buyer cannot be ended early in this way, and the buyer takes it on as it stands, with a limited exception for a rent far below a fair level.
9. The Gutachten and the perizia, and seeing the property
German experts often cannot enter the property, because the owner does not let them in, and many Gutachten rely on an outside inspection. In Italy the custodian has the right to access the property for the court, the expert usually inspects inside, and people interested in buying can ask the custodian to view it, free of charge. The perizia also goes further than most Gutachten on one point that matters a great deal in Italy: whether the building matches its permits and the cadastral plans. Irregular building work is common, and some of it cannot be put right.
10. No Grundbuch in most of Italy
Germany has a land register in which the entry itself creates rights, and the public can rely on what it says. Most of Italy has no such register. Italian registers are kept by owner's name, not by plot, and title rests on a chain of recorded deeds going back at least 20 years, which the court file must document; the land registry (catasto, comparable to the German Liegenschaftskataster) holds cadastral data, not ownership. The decree is then recorded in the registers as the buyer's deed. The exception is the former Austrian areas, including South Tyrol, Trentino and parts of Friuli Venezia Giulia, which keep a land book of German origin. Our guide to the Tavolare land register explains it.
Every deadline, worked out for each home
Members get every home explained in plain English, German, Dutch or Italian, with a bidding plan for its deposit, lowest valid offer and deadlines, and a bid-from-abroad checklist.
See membership- Offer deadlineOffer and deposit lodged12 Mar
- AuctionOffers opened; bidding if more than one13 Mar
- Balance duePrice less deposit, plus costs11 Jul
- Transfer decreeWeeks to months after paymentSep
What is the same in both countries?
Some things will feel familiar. In both countries a court controls the sale, the property is valued by a court expert, the sale is public by law, and anyone, including foreigners, can take part. Neither system gives a warranty: you buy the property as it is, with what the papers say and what they miss. Creditors can take part in both, and in both a co-ownership dispute, for example between heirs, can lead to a court sale of the whole property; in Germany that is the Teilungsversteigerung.
Who does what when you bid from Germany?
As EU citizens, German buyers can buy in Italy on the same terms as Italians, and EU and EEA citizens do not need to check reciprocity. Buyers of other nationalities who live in Germany should have a lawyer confirm their position before they bid.
Your Italian lawyer is the person who acts for you in the sale. The lawyer makes the offer and bids under a special power of attorney, which you sign before a German notary. Under a German-Italian treaty from 1969 on public documents, a power signed before a German notary is exempt from legalisation and from the apostille; the lawyer confirms the form the court accepts and arranges the Italian translation. To complete the purchase you also need an Italian tax code (codice fiscale), which the Italian tax authorities issue; your German tax number does not replace it.
Your bank moves the money. The deposit and later the balance go in euros to the procedure's account, so there is no exchange risk, but transfers take time and the deposit counts only once it is credited. The delegate runs the sale and the custodian shows the property; both work for the court, and neither can advise you on whether to bid. Court papers are in Italian. In South Tyrol many are also in German, but not all, and the legal terms do not always match German usage.
Instead of the Grunderwerbsteuer, Italy charges registration tax (imposta di registro) plus fixed mortgage and cadastral duties. How they are worked out depends on the buyer and the property, so a lawyer or commercialista confirms the figure for your case. Italy and Germany share a time zone, so deadlines and online sessions fall in your working day.
Common mistakes German bidders make in Italy
- Treating the starting price as the Verkehrswert and the lowest valid offer as a bargain threshold, when both are already discounted.
- Waiting for a later round in the hope that the limits fall away, as at a German hearing after the award was refused. In Italy the floor stays; only the price falls, and the case can end before the next round.
- Planning to turn up on the day and bid, without having sent an offer and deposit by the deadline.
- Sending the deposit as 10% of the starting price when the offer is higher, or sending it too late.
- Assuming the property is theirs from the award, and making plans or signing contracts before the decree.
- Asking a friend or relative in Italy to bid with a notarial power, as would work in Germany.
- Overlooking condominium arrears and building irregularities, which in Italy often matter more than in Germany.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
Is there a 7/10 limit at Italian court auctions?
No. Italy has no 5/10 or 7/10 rule. Instead, in every round, an offer below 75% of the starting price is void. If a round ends with no valid offer, the starting price is lowered for the next round.
Is the Italian deposit 10% of the market value, as in Germany?
No. The German security is 10% of the Verkehrswert. The Italian deposit is at least 10% of the price you offer, or more if the notice asks, and it must be paid with the offer, not at the hearing.
Does a German notary's power of attorney work for an Italian court auction?
It can, if it is a special power for the sale, given to an Italian lawyer, with an Italian translation; the 1969 German-Italian treaty usually removes the need for an apostille. Only a lawyer can bid for you in Italy; a relative cannot.
Are there bestehenbleibende Rechte at an Italian court auction?
No. Unlike a German sale, where rights ranking ahead of the pursuing creditor can stay, the Italian transfer decree orders all mortgages and seizures to be cancelled. Easements, some leases and condominium arrears for the current and previous year can still follow the property.
Can I bid at an Italian court auction in person, as at a German Amtsgericht?
Only if the sale is mixed or held in person, and only if you sent a valid offer with the deposit by the deadline. Most Italian sales run online, and nobody can join the contest without a prior offer.
Can an Italian court auction buyer end a lease early, like a German Ersteher?
No. Italy has nothing like the German special right to give notice. A lease that binds the buyer, because it has a legally certain date before the seizure, runs on as agreed, and the buyer becomes the landlord. The only exception is a rent more than a third below a fair rent, which does not bind the buyer.
Sources
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 567: register certificates or notary's certificate in the court file (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: offers, the 75% floor and the deposit (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 579: who may bid, and lawyers (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 591: new rounds and price cuts (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2923: leases that bind the buyer (Normattiva)
- Implementing provisions of the Civil Code, article 63: condominium charges (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

