Homes with Superbonus works at auction: unfinished works, tax credits and the risks
Short answer
Homes with Superbonus works reach Italian court auctions, often with works unfinished. A tax office claim for a Superbonus that was not due is aimed at the person who claimed it, not at the auction buyer. Leftover deductions rarely help a buyer, and unfinished works, irregular building work and condominium debts are the real risks. A commercialista confirms each case.
Key facts
- The Superbonus was a building tax deduction under article 119 of Decree-Law 34/2020, often taken as a transferable credit or an invoice discount.
- When requirements were not met, the law directs recovery at the beneficiary, with suppliers and credit buyers jointly liable only where they took part in the breach intentionally or with gross negligence.
- Leftover deductions pass to an individual buyer on a sale unless the parties agree otherwise; how that works at a court sale is not settled in clear guidance.
- The simplified notice for Superbonus works (CILAS) does not legalise older irregular building work.
- Scaffolding left on a building usually belongs to the contractor or a hire firm, not to the debtor, and is not part of the lot.
- A separate ten-year rule can tax gains on selling a home where Superbonus works were finished.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What was the Superbonus?
- Why do Superbonus homes end up at court auctions?
- Can the tax office claim the Superbonus back from the auction buyer?
- Do unused Superbonus deductions pass to the auction buyer?
- What do unfinished works and abandoned scaffolding mean for a buyer?
- Superbonus works in a block of flats
- Superbonus works, the CILAS and building irregularities
- Selling later: the ten-year rule
- Where does the real risk sit in a Superbonus home?
- Is a Superbonus home at auction worth considering?
Few Italian laws changed the look of streets as fast as the Superbonus. For a few years scaffolding went up on houses and blocks of flats across the country, wrapped in netting printed with builders' names. Many projects were finished and left homes warmer, safer and worth more. Others stopped half way, when credits could not be sold, contractors ran out of money or owners ran into debt. Some of those homes, finished and unfinished, appear in the public Italian court notices, and the word Superbonus in a court report makes many buyers nervous.
This guide explains what the Superbonus was, why homes with Superbonus works reach court auctions, whether the tax office can come after the buyer, what happens to any deductions not yet used, what unfinished works and abandoned scaffolding mean in practice, how the simplified works notice (CILAS) relates to building irregularities, and where the real risk sits. It describes the rules in general terms. It is not tax advice: a commercialista or lawyer confirms how they apply to a particular home.
What was the Superbonus?
The Superbonus was created by article 119 of Decree-Law 34 of 19 May 2020, the Decreto Rilancio, converted into Law 77 of 17 July 2020. It gave a tax deduction, at 110% of the eligible cost for much of its life and at lower rates later, for two kinds of works on homes and blocks of flats:
- Energy works. Insulating the walls and roof (the familiar cappotto, an insulating coat on the facade) and replacing heating systems, together with linked works such as new windows, solar panels and batteries, provided the building rose by at least two energy classes.
- Earthquake works. Strengthening structures to reduce seismic risk, known as the sismabonus.
The deduction was spread over several years. But the feature that made the scheme so widely used was in article 121 of the same decree: instead of deducting the cost from their own tax, owners could take a discount on the builder's invoice (sconto in fattura), leaving the builder with a tax credit, or turn the deduction into a credit and sell it (cessione del credito) to a bank or other buyer. That let people with little income or savings have works done for little or nothing up front. Later laws reduced the rates, tightened the controls and closed the credit options for most new works. For a court auction buyer, the details of each change matter less than the result: a large stock of homes with works that were started under one set of rules and, sometimes, never finished.
Why do Superbonus homes end up at court auctions?
A home reaches a court auction because its owner, or the business that owns it, did not pay a debt. The Superbonus can be part of the story in several ways:
- The owner borrowed to pay for the share of the works not covered by the bonus, or for works that turned out not to qualify, and could not repay.
- The contractor took the invoice discount, could not sell the credits on, and stopped work or went bankrupt, leaving the owner with an unfinished building and disputes.
- The tax office found that requirements were not met and claimed back the bonus from the owner, with interest and penalties, adding a tax debt to the others.
- A building company that renovated its own stock of flats with Superbonus works failed, and its flats are sold in its bankruptcy.
- The Superbonus has nothing to do with it: the owner's debts arose for other reasons, and the works are simply part of the home being sold.
The last case is common. A finished, properly documented Superbonus renovation is a benefit to a buyer, not a risk: better insulation, a new heating system, sometimes solar panels and structural strengthening. The risks below come from works that were unfinished, irregular or disputed.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
Can the tax office claim the Superbonus back from the auction buyer?
This is the fear most buyers have, and the law is reassuring on the main point. Under article 121, paragraph 5, of Decree-Law 34/2020, when the requirements for the deduction turn out to be missing, even in part, the tax office recovers the amount not due from the beneficiaries: the people who were entitled to the deduction because they owned the home, or had another qualifying right over it, and paid for the works. It adds interest and penalties. Under paragraph 6, the supplier who gave the invoice discount and the buyers of the credit are jointly liable with the beneficiary only where they took part in the breach intentionally or with gross negligence.
An auction buyer is none of these. The buyer did not order or pay for the works and did not claim the bonus. A claim to recover a Superbonus is a tax debt of the person who claimed it, not a charge that runs with the building. If that person owes the tax office money, the tax office is one more creditor in their affairs. It can take part in the foreclosure like any other creditor, and any mortgage it registered on the home is cancelled by the judge's transfer decree along with the bank's, as our guide to what happens after you win explains.
Where a buyer can still be affected
- Leftover deductions. If, unusually, the buyer takes over deductions not yet used (see below), and the tax office later finds the works did not qualify, the buyer could lose the instalments still to come.
- Criminal investigations. Some Superbonus frauds led to criminal seizures. Those usually concern credits, but where a court report mentions a criminal seizure or confiscation on the property itself, a lawyer must look at it before you bid, because criminal measures follow their own rules and are not always cleared by the decree.
- The building, not the tax. A recovery claim does not pass to you, but the physical result of the works does: if they were unfinished or done badly, that becomes your building.
How a recovery claim is handled against a debtor whose home has been sold is a matter between the debtor and the tax office. It does not undo the sale. A lawyer confirms the position where the papers show a recovery claim or a dispute about the bonus.
Do unused Superbonus deductions pass to the auction buyer?
Where the owner chose to deduct the cost from their own income tax over several years, rather than taking the invoice discount or selling the credit, some instalments may still be unused when the home is sold. The general rule for building deductions is in article 16-bis, paragraph 8, of the income tax code (Presidential Decree 917 of 1986): on the sale of the home, deductions not yet used pass to the buyer, if the buyer is an individual, for the remaining years, unless the parties agree otherwise. Tax office guidance applies the same rule to the Superbonus on an ordinary sale.
At a court sale there is no agreement between seller and buyer: the judge transfers the home by decree. Whether, and how, unused instalments then pass to the auction buyer is not settled in clear public guidance. The default rule points towards the buyer, since there is no seller's agreement to the contrary, but practitioners take different views. In practice the question rarely decides anything, for three reasons:
- Most Superbonus works were paid through the invoice discount or a credit sale. In those cases there are no deductions left to pass on: the credits belong to the builder or the bank that bought them.
- To use a deduction, the buyer needs Italian income tax to deduct it from. A buyer who lives abroad and has no Italian taxable income, or little of it, cannot benefit, and unused instalments are lost, not refunded.
- Using a deduction needs the paperwork: invoices, technical certifications, the energy and structural records, the filings made to the authorities. An owner who lost their home may not hand them over, and the court file rarely contains them.
So treat any unused deductions as a possible small bonus at most, never as part of the price. A commercialista confirms whether anything can pass to you, and how, before you count on it.
What do unfinished works and abandoned scaffolding mean for a buyer?
This is where the real cost of a troubled Superbonus home lies. Works stopped half way can leave a building in a worse state than before they began: walls stripped for insulation and left open to the weather, a roof partly replaced, old windows removed and openings boarded up, a new heating system half installed, scaffolding still standing months or years later.
What unfinished works can cost
Finishing someone else's project is often more expensive than starting fresh. A new contractor must check and take responsibility for work done by another firm, materials left on site may be damaged or missing, and parts done badly may have to be removed. Water getting into exposed walls and roofs causes damage that grows with every season. Nobody can put a reliable figure on this from a court report: it needs a builder or engineer on site. Courtdoor does not estimate renovation costs.
Do not assume that a building incentive will pay for finishing the job. The bonuses for building works have changed many times, the generous rates of the Superbonus are not there for most buyers, and what is available depends on who you are, what you do and when. A commercialista says what applies when you buy.
The scaffolding is probably not yours
Scaffolding left on a building usually belongs to the contractor or to a hire firm, not to the owner whose debts led to the auction. It is therefore not part of the lot, and the buyer does not acquire it. That creates practical problems. The hire firm may want to collect it, or may want unpaid hire before it does. If the contractor is bankrupt, its liquidator deals with it. If the scaffolding stands on a public pavement, the town may require a permit and fees for the space it occupies. Getting it taken down safely, by someone entitled to do so, can take time and money.
Safety and responsibility
Under Italian law the person who has a thing in their custody is responsible for damage it causes, unless they prove an unforeseeable event (article 2051 of the Civil Code), and the owner of a building answers for damage caused by its collapse or parts falling from it unless they prove it was not due to poor maintenance or a construction defect (article 2053). Before the sale, the court custodian manages the property and can ask the judge to authorise urgent safety works. From the transfer decree, the building and its risks are yours: loose netting, unstable scaffolding, an open roof or a site that children can get into become your responsibility. Arrange insurance and a safety check from the date of the decree, not from the day you get the keys.
Viewing matters more than usual. The custodian shows the home to people thinking of bidding, and an unfinished building site is a place where a professional's eye is worth paying for. Our guide to who checks what before you bid explains which professional covers which question.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get a lot report for every home, with Superbonus works, unfinished works and related disputes picked out as red flags in plain English.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Superbonus works in a block of flats
Many Superbonus projects were on the shared parts of blocks of flats: the facades, the roof, the central heating. The owners decided the works together in the condominium meeting, and each owner's share of the bonus related to their own flat. If you buy a single flat at auction in such a building, several things follow.
- The shared works are the condominium's, not the debtor's alone. If they are unfinished, finishing them is a decision for all the owners, and you will pay your share of whatever is decided after you become an owner.
- The condominium may be in dispute with the contractor, or the contractor with the condominium. Legal costs and any sums the condominium has to pay are shared among owners.
- Arrears follow the flat to a limited extent. The building can claim from the new owner the debtor's unpaid charges for the current and previous year (article 63 of the implementing provisions of the Civil Code). Charges for extraordinary works approved before the sale raise their own questions about who pays.
- The flat's own works, such as new windows paid through the bonus, may be finished even if the shared ones are not, or the other way round.
The minutes of the latest condominium meetings and a statement from the administrator are the best guides to what is going on, and a buyer's lawyer normally asks for them. Our guide to liens, condo fees and easements explains what a buyer can be asked to pay.
Superbonus works, the CILAS and building irregularities
Works under the Superbonus, other than demolition and rebuilding, were treated as extraordinary maintenance and could be started with a simplified notice to the town, the CILA Superbonus or CILAS (article 119, paragraph 13-ter). Its key feature was that it did not require the technician to certify that the existing building was fully lawful, its stato legittimo. That was meant to speed up works on buildings with old paperwork gaps.
Buyers sometimes take a CILAS as proof that a building is in order. It is not. The law says expressly that filing it leaves untouched any assessment of whether the building itself is lawful. Any irregular work that existed before the Superbonus is still irregular afterwards, and a CILAS does not legalise it. The same paragraph also limits when the tax office can withdraw the bonus on planning grounds: mainly where no CILAS was filed, where the works differ from what was declared, where the required details were missing or where the declarations made were untrue.
For a buyer, that means two separate questions:
- Is the building lawful as a whole? This is the ordinary planning question for any auction home, with the same tools and limits, including the auction buyer's special window to apply for legalisation of some older works. Our guide to building irregularities at auction explains it.
- Were the Superbonus works themselves done as declared? Works that go beyond the CILAS, such as balconies enlarged, a loft converted or a roof raised along the way, are irregular in their own right, and may need a different permit or have to be undone.
Insulation added to the outside of walls also changes measurements: a thicker wall can affect distances from neighbours and the cadastral plan. The law allows some extra thickness for insulation, but the cadastral records may not have been updated after the works. Our guide to the court report explains how the court expert describes planning and cadastral status. A new energy certificate, the APE, should exist for a finished Superbonus project, because the two-class improvement had to be shown.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get a lawyer summary pack for any lot, setting out the works, the disputes and the questions to put to a lawyer or commercialista.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Selling later: the ten-year rule
Superbonus works can affect what happens when you sell. Separate from the ordinary five-year rule, a gain on selling a property where Superbonus works were finished less than ten years before the sale can be taxed, with exceptions for inherited homes and homes that were the seller's main home for most of the period. Tax office guidance limits the rule to the first sale after the works. Whether a court sale counts as that first sale, so that your own later resale is outside it, is a question for a commercialista with the dates of the works in hand. Our guide to selling or renting out an auction home explains both rules in full.
Where does the real risk sit in a Superbonus home?
Rarely in the tax office. For a Superbonus home, three questions decide most of the value: whether the works were finished, whether they were on the flat or on the shared parts of the building, and whether anything on site belongs to someone else. An engineer or builder who sees the site answers the first, the condominium administrator's records and a lawyer answer the second, and the third is a question of who owns the scaffolding and who may take it down.
Disputes with a contractor, a tax office claim or a criminal seizure are the points a lawyer reads the file for first, because each changes what you are buying. A surveyor confirms whether the works match what was declared and whether the building was lawful before them. And because the home is sold with no warranty, as our guide to sold as-is and the court valuation explains, whatever the experts find becomes your problem, not the seller's. Our guide to the risks of buying at an Italian court auction sets these alongside the others.
Is a Superbonus home at auction worth considering?
Often, yes, when the works were finished. A home that gained two energy classes, a new heating system and sometimes structural strengthening can be good value at auction, and the Superbonus history behind it is mostly the previous owner's concern. An unfinished project is a different purchase: closer to buying a building site than a home, with costs that only an on-site inspection can estimate. It suits a buyer with time, a reliable builder and a budget that does not depend on any tax incentive. As with every court sale, there is usually a family or a failed business behind the lot, and the unfinished works are part of their story too.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
Does the buyer of an auction home have to repay a Superbonus the owner should not have had?
No. The law directs recovery at the beneficiary who claimed the bonus, with suppliers and credit buyers jointly liable only if they knowingly or through gross negligence took part in the breach. It is the debtor's tax debt, and any mortgage securing it is cancelled by the transfer decree.
Can I use the remaining Superbonus instalments on a home bought at a court auction?
Rarely in practice. On a sale, unused deductions normally pass to an individual buyer, but how that works with a court decree is unclear, most Superbonus works were paid by credit transfer, and you need Italian income tax to deduct from. A commercialista confirms it.
Who owns the scaffolding left on a Superbonus home sold at auction?
Usually the contractor or a scaffolding hire firm, not the debtor, so it is not part of the lot. Removing it can mean dealing with the hire firm or a bankrupt contractor's liquidator, and the town may charge for public space it occupies.
Does a CILAS mean an Italian home has no building irregularities?
No. The CILAS let Superbonus works start without certifying that the whole building was lawful, and the law says filing it leaves that question open. Older irregular work stays irregular, and works beyond what was declared are irregular too.
What happens to unfinished Superbonus works on the shared parts of a block of flats?
They remain the condominium's responsibility. The owners decide together how to finish them, and as a new owner you pay your share of what is decided. Disputes with the contractor and arrears for the current and previous year can also affect you.
Is a home with finished Superbonus works a risk at auction?
Usually not a special one. Finished, documented works add value: better insulation, a new heating system, sometimes structural strengthening. The ordinary checks still apply, and selling within ten years of the works can raise a separate tax question.
Sources
- Decree-Law 34/2020 (Decreto Rilancio), article 119: the Superbonus and the CILAS, paragraph 13-ter (Normattiva)
- Decree-Law 34/2020, article 121: invoice discount, credit transfer and recovery from beneficiaries (Normattiva)
- Income tax code (Presidential Decree 917/1986), article 16-bis: building deductions and their transfer on a sale (Normattiva)
- Income tax code, article 67: capital gains, including letter b-bis on the Superbonus (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2051: liability for things in one's custody (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2053: liability for a building's collapse (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

