How court sales run: without incanto, online, mixed or in person
Short answer
Almost every Italian court sale is a vendita senza incanto: sealed offers by a deadline, opened together, with a contest only if two or more are valid. Most run online, as asynchronous (raises over a set period), synchronous (everyone connected at once) or mixed (online and in the room). The open incanto is rarely ordered.
Key facts
- Vendita senza incanto means a sale by sealed offers, not a sale without bidding: a contest follows when there are two or more valid offers.
- The judge may order an open incanto only where it is likely to fetch a price more than half above the value set by the court.
- The law makes online sales the rule, unless that would harm the creditors or slow the case.
- The three online formats are asynchronous, synchronous and mixed, defined by decree 32 of 26 February 2015 on online sales.
- The notice of sale states which format applies, and every time in it is Italian time.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What does vendita senza incanto mean?
- Why is the incanto so rare?
- Online by default
- How do asynchronous, synchronous and mixed sales differ for a bidder?
- Strengths and drawbacks of each format
- Which time zone do Italian court sales use?
- What stays the same whatever the format
- What do bidders most often get wrong about the formats?
- Who chooses the format, and can it change?
Read a few Italian court notices and the same phrases keep appearing: vendita senza incanto, modalità asincrona, sincrona mista. They sound technical, and they are, but each one answers a simple question a bidder needs settled before sending an offer. How will the sale run? Will I need to be online at a set moment, or in a room in Italy? How long does the bidding last, and what happens if nobody else turns up?
This guide explains the two legal forms of court sale, why one of them has almost disappeared, and the three ways a sale can run online, plus the paper sale that still exists in some places. For each, it covers what it means for you as a bidder, its strengths and its drawbacks, and what to think about if you are bidding from another time zone. It describes the rules, not the technical steps, which differ from sale to sale and are set out in each notice. For the whole buying process from offer to keys, start with how Italian court auctions work.
What does vendita senza incanto mean?
The Italian Code of Civil Procedure has always known two ways of selling a seized home. Articles 570 to 575 deal with the sale without incanto. Articles 576 to 587 deal with the sale with incanto. The word incanto means an open auction, the kind where bidders gather and outbid each other in turn. The English translation that confuses most people is "sale without auction", because a sale without incanto can still end in lively bidding. A better translation is "sale by sealed offers".
The sale without incanto (vendita senza incanto)
In a vendita senza incanto, anyone except the debtor can send a written offer by a deadline set in the notice. The law sets limits on the first offer window: the sale order gives between 90 and 120 days in which offers can be made. Each offer states a price, how and when the buyer will pay, and comes with a deposit of at least one tenth of the price offered. The offers stay sealed until the opening, which the law places on the day after the deadline.
At the opening, the delegate, or the judge where no delegate has been appointed, checks every offer. What happens next depends on how many valid offers there are.
- None: the round is deserted, and a new round is set, usually at a lower price.
- One: it wins if it matches the starting price. If it is lower, but no more than a quarter lower, the delegate can still accept it, unless a better price looks likely from a new sale or a creditor has asked to take the home.
- Two or more: the bidders are invited to a contest (gara) starting from the highest offer.
Our guide to the starting price, the 75% lowest offer and auction day goes through these outcomes in detail, with a worked example.
Two features make the sale without incanto different from an auction in the US, the UK or Australia. First, your offer is a commitment before you know whether anyone else is interested. Under article 571 it is irrevocable, with narrow exceptions. Second, once the award is made, it is final. Nobody can come along a week later and reopen the sale by offering more.
The sale with incanto (vendita con incanto)
The incanto is the older open auction. Bidders register by lodging a deposit set in the sale order, of up to one tenth of the starting price (article 576), and then gather at a public session. The first bid must beat the starting price, and each bid after it must beat the last by at least the minimum raise set in the sale order. Article 581 sets the rhythm: when three minutes pass after the last bid without a higher one, the lot goes to the last bidder.
Even then the award is only provisional. Under article 584, anyone can make a new offer within ten days, as long as it is at least one fifth higher than the price reached, with a double deposit. If such an offer arrives, a new contest is held. A bidder who registered but did not take part without good reason gets back only nine tenths of the deposit.
British and Australian readers will recognise the room auction; American readers will recognise the courthouse-steps foreclosure sale. The ten-day window for a higher offer has no close equivalent in either, and it is one of the reasons the incanto fell out of favour: a buyer who won in the room could not be sure of keeping the home.
Why is the incanto so rare?
Reforms in 2015 changed the balance between the two forms. Article 503 of the Code of Civil Procedure says the incanto can be ordered only where the judge thinks it likely that a sale in that form would reach a price more than half above the value of the property, as set under article 568. Few homes in a foreclosure meet that test, so the sale by sealed offers has become the normal method almost everywhere.
Article 569, which governs the judge's sale order, reflects the same change. The order sets the starting price determined under article 568, the lowest valid offer, the deposit, the offer window and the term for paying the balance, and it sets the opening hearing for the day after offers close. It mentions the incanto only "where provided", that is, in the rare cases where it is still allowed.
So when you see vendita senza incanto in a notice, read it as the ordinary sale. A notice with an incanto is unusual enough that it deserves a lawyer's reading, because the rules on deposits, provisional awards and later offers are different. Our history of Italian court sales tells the longer story of how the open auction gave way.
Online by default
Reforms made in 2015 and 2016 turned the online sale into the default. Article 569, fourth paragraph, tells the judge to order that the deposit, the offers, the bidding and the payment of the price are handled by electronic means, unless that would harm the creditors' interests or the swift running of the case. The detailed technical rules sit in decree 32 of 26 February 2015, made under article 161-ter of the implementing provisions of the Code.
That decree defines three online formats. Courts choose between them in their sale orders, and practice varies: some courts use one format for almost everything, others switch between them depending on the type of property or the stage of the case. You do not choose. The notice of sale tells you which one applies to that round.
The asynchronous online sale (asta asincrona)
In an asynchronous sale, the decree says bids are made only online, within a set period, without the judge or delegate and the bidders needing to be connected at the same time. Offers are opened first. If there are two or more valid offers, the contest begins and stays open for a length of time set by the sale order, often a day or more. During that window each bidder can raise whenever they like. Every participant is told about each new raise by email and text message. When the window closes, the highest bid and the list of raises go to the delegate, who proceeds to the award.
Many sale orders add an extension: if a raise arrives in the last minutes of the window, the window is extended by a short period, so that the others have a chance to answer. The decree itself does not fix a length or an extension, so the details come from the sale order and the notice, and they differ between courts.
The synchronous online sale (asta sincrona)
In a synchronous sale, the decree says bids are made only online, "in the same unit of time", with everyone connected at once. It feels like a live auction held over the internet. The offers are opened, and if there are two or more valid ones, the contest starts straight away. Each bidder has a short time, set in the sale order, to raise. When that time passes without a higher bid, the contest ends and the highest bidder wins.
The whole thing can be over in minutes. That is its appeal for courts, and its main demand on you: you must be connected, ready and clear about your limit at the moment the session opens.
The mixed sale (asta sincrona mista)
In a mixed sale, bids can be made at the same time both online and in person before the judge or delegate. Under article 22 of the decree, where the judge orders it, offers may be sent online or on paper, deposited at the court office or the place the notice names. Those who offered online take part online; those who offered on paper attend in person. The contest runs as a single synchronous session, with raises from the room and from the screen counted together.
Mixed sales exist so that people without the tools for an online offer can still bid. For a buyer abroad, they can be confusing: you need to know which route you used and be present in the matching way.
The paper sale
Where the judge decides that an online sale would harm the creditors or slow the case, the sale can run entirely on paper. Offers go in a sealed envelope to the delegate or the court office, with only the details the law allows written on the outside, and a banker's draft for the deposit can go inside. Bidders attend the opening in person, and any contest happens in the room. These sales are the exception, and the notice always says when a sale runs this way.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
How do asynchronous, synchronous and mixed sales differ for a bidder?
From a bidder's point of view the formats differ in three things: when you need to be available, how fast decisions are made, and how much room there is for second thoughts.
Availability
An asynchronous sale asks for attention over a period rather than at a moment. You can raise at any time in the window, but in practice the bidding often concentrates near the end, so you need to be reachable then. A synchronous or mixed sale asks you to be present, online or in person, at a precise time, and for the whole session.
Speed
In a synchronous session, each raise has a short reply time. Decisions are made under pressure, and a bidder who has not fixed a ceiling in advance can go past it. An asynchronous sale gives time to think between raises, but that time cuts both ways: a rival who would have stopped in the heat of the moment may come back the next morning with a fresh bid.
Representation
In every format, a lawyer with a special power of attorney can bid for you. For a buyer abroad this often matters more than the format itself. A lawyer in Italy can attend a mixed sale in person, follow an asynchronous contest during Italian working hours and handle a synchronous session without your having to be awake at three in the morning. Our guide to bidding through a lawyer explains the power of attorney and the apostille.
The single-offer case
In all three online formats, as in the paper sale, a contest only happens if there are two or more valid offers. Many homes, especially after a price cut, attract a single offer. In that case the format hardly matters: there is no bidding, and the delegate decides on the one offer. A lot of the drama people expect from an auction never happens.
Strengths and drawbacks of each format
No format is better for buyers in general. Each one suits some people more than others.
Asynchronous
- Strengths: no need to be online at a single moment; time to think between raises; suited to bidders in distant time zones, if the window covers their waking hours.
- Drawbacks: the contest can run over a day or more, so nerves and attention are tested for longer; late raises and extensions can stretch the end; rivals have time to reconsider and come back.
Synchronous
- Strengths: quick and clear, often over in minutes; everyone sees the same thing at the same time; no uncertainty hanging over a night.
- Drawbacks: you must be connected at a fixed Italian time; short reply windows reward preparation and punish hesitation; a lost connection at the wrong moment can cost you the home.
Mixed
- Strengths: open to bidders who cannot or will not use the online route; bidders in the room and online compete on equal terms.
- Drawbacks: two sets of rules to understand; in-person attendance means being in Italy or sending a lawyer; the room can feel different from the screen.
Paper
- Strengths: no digital signature or certified email needed; simple for local buyers.
- Drawbacks: in-person delivery and attendance; for a buyer abroad, almost always a lawyer; the deposit often by banker's draft, which is awkward from outside Italy.
Every deadline, worked out for each home
Members get a bidding plan for each home that states its sale format, its key dates and times, and what that format asks of them.
See membership- Offer deadlineOffer and deposit lodged12 Mar
- AuctionOffers opened; bidding if more than one13 Mar
- Balance duePrice less deposit, plus costs11 Jul
- Transfer decreeWeeks to months after paymentSep
Which time zone do Italian court sales use?
Every time in an Italian notice, from the offer deadline to the opening and the end of the bidding window, is Italian time. Italy uses Central European Time, one hour ahead of UTC in winter and two hours ahead in summer. The UK and Ireland are one hour behind Italy; the US East Coast usually six hours and the West Coast nine; eastern Australia eight to ten hours ahead and New Zealand ten to twelve. These are rough gaps for planning, not a substitute for checking the exact time on the day. Our guide to buying from abroad covers deadlines and holidays.
There are a few weeks each spring and autumn when the gaps shift by an hour, because North America, Europe and the southern hemisphere change their clocks on different dates. Sales held in those weeks are the ones where buyers abroad most often get the time wrong.
Time zones also shape which format suits you. For a buyer in Sydney, a synchronous session at 10 a.m. Italian time is an evening event, which is manageable. For a buyer in California, it is the middle of the night. An asynchronous window that closes in the Italian afternoon lands in the Californian early morning and late at night in eastern Australia. Many buyers in the Americas and Oceania use a lawyer in Italy for exactly this reason.
Offer deadlines usually fall on an Italian working day, and the deposit must be credited by the time the notice sets. Italian public holidays, local saints' days and the August holidays all affect when banks and professionals are available.
What stays the same whatever the format
The format changes how the sale feels, not the rules that decide it. In every sale without incanto, online, mixed or on paper:
- The starting price and the lowest valid offer, 75% of the starting price, are printed in the notice. There is no undisclosed reserve.
- Every offer needs a deposit of at least one tenth of the price offered, and the notice can ask for more.
- An offer is irrevocable once made, with narrow exceptions set by article 571.
- If there is one valid offer, the delegate decides on it; if there are two or more, a contest follows from the highest.
- If nobody raises in the contest, the best offer wins, judged on the price, the deposit, the payment terms and any other useful element.
- The award is final once made. There is no ten-day reopening as there is after an incanto.
- The balance is paid within the term set in the notice, which the law caps at 120 days from the award, with instalments over up to twelve months allowed only for good reasons.
Our guide to making a valid offer covers the offer and the deposit in depth.
What do bidders most often get wrong about the formats?
"Without auction means there is no bidding"
Not so. The phrase senza incanto only rules out the old open-auction procedure. Whenever there are two or more valid offers, there is a contest, and it can be as keen as any room auction.
"Online means I can snipe at the last second"
Bidders used to online marketplaces expect to win with a last-second bid. In an asynchronous court sale, many sale orders extend the window when a raise arrives near the end, which takes most of the advantage out of sniping. In a synchronous sale there is no fixed end: the contest closes only when the reply time passes without a raise.
"Auction day is one day"
In a synchronous or mixed sale, the opening and the contest usually happen in a single session. In an asynchronous sale, the bidding stage can run over a day or more. Either way, the work that decides the result, from reading the papers to arranging the deposit, happens weeks before.
"A mixed sale lets me turn up and bid"
Only if you have made a valid offer on paper, with its deposit, by the deadline. Nobody can walk into the room on the day and join the contest without an offer. The same is true online: the contest is open only to those whose offers were valid.
"The format tells you how competitive a home will be"
It does not. Courts choose the format for reasons of their own, such as workload, local practice and the tools their delegates use. Competition depends on the home, its price and its problems.
Who chooses the format, and can it change?
The enforcement judge chooses in the sale order, within the limits of article 569 and the 2015 decree. When a sale is delegated, the delegate runs each round under that order. The format can change between rounds if the judge changes the order, for example after several deserted rounds. Each notice states the format for its round, so always read the notice of the round you are bidding in, not an earlier one.
Courts also issue their own guidelines and standard orders, which explains why two homes in different cities can be sold under noticeably different rules on reply times, extensions and deposits. Our guide to who runs an Italian court sale explains the roles of the judge, the delegate and the custodian.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
What does vendita senza incanto mean?
A court sale by sealed offers. Bidders send written offers with a deposit by a deadline; the offers are opened together, and a contest follows only if two or more are valid. It is the normal form of Italian court sale. The phrase does not mean there is no bidding.
What is the difference between vendita con incanto and senza incanto?
With incanto, registered bidders outbid each other in an open session and the award is provisional for ten days, during which anyone can offer a fifth more. Without incanto, sealed offers are opened together, any contest follows, and the award is final. The incanto is rarely ordered.
What is an asta asincrona?
An online court sale in which, after the offers are opened, bidders raise over a set period, often a day or more, without being connected at the same time. Each raise is notified to the others, and many sale orders add extra time when a raise arrives near the end.
What is an asta sincrona mista?
A mixed court sale in which some bidders take part online and others in person before the delegate, in the same session. Those who sent an online offer bid online; those who sent a paper offer attend in person. All raises count together.
Which time zone applies to an Italian court sale?
Italian time, for every deadline and session. Italy is one hour ahead of the UK, usually six ahead of New York and nine ahead of Los Angeles, and eight to ten hours behind eastern Australia, depending on the season.
Can the sale format change between rounds?
Yes. The judge sets the format in the sale order and can change it, for example after deserted rounds. Each notice states the format for its own round, so read the current notice rather than an earlier one.
Sources
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 503: when the incanto may be ordered (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 569: the sale order and online sales (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: offers in a sale without incanto (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 573: the contest between bidders (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 581: how an incanto runs (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 584: offers after an incanto (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

