Court auction or estate agent? Two ways to buy a home in Italy compared
Short answer
In Italy you can buy through an estate agent and a notary, or at a court auction. Neither is always cheaper. The agent route gives choice, negotiation, conditions and the seller's warranties. A court auction has no commission or notary deed and can start below market, but you buy as seen, with no conditions and a deposit at stake.
Key facts
- An estate agent's commission is agreed with the agent and is often charged to both buyer and seller; a court sale has none.
- In a private sale the seller owes legal warranties for defects; in a forced sale article 2922 of the Civil Code excludes them.
- A court offer is irrevocable and carries a deposit of at least 10%, lost if the winner does not pay the balance on time.
- Taxes follow the same rules on both routes, and an individual buying a home can be taxed on its cadastral value rather than the price either way.
- At auction the judge's decree orders recorded mortgages and seizures cancelled; in a private sale the seller must clear them.
- Neither route is cheaper in general: the total cost and the risks you take decide.
12,300+properties for sale by Italian courts
8,000+go to auction in the next 30 days
in 2 daysnext auction day across Italy, Monday, 90+ properties
Contents
- What is the difference between buying at auction and through an agent?
- Is it cheaper to buy at auction or through an agent in Italy?
- Viewing and checking the home
- What do you know before you commit?
- How binding is each step?
- What does each route cost?
- How long does each route take?
- Can you get a mortgage on each route?
- Who clears the old mortgages and charges?
- What happens if something is wrong after you buy?
- Choice: what can you actually buy?
- Can an estate agent or realtor help you buy at a court auction?
- Auction vs estate agent: side by side
- Who should buy through an agent, and who at auction?
Most homes in Italy change hands the ordinary way. A buyer finds a house through an estate agent (agenzia immobiliare), makes an offer, signs a preliminary contract with a deposit, and completes before a notary. A smaller number are sold by the courts, because the owner could not pay their debts and a creditor asked a judge to sell. Both routes end with the buyer owning the home. Almost everything in between is different.
This guide compares the two, step by step, for a buyer who has not yet decided which way to go. It tries to be honest both ways: for many buyers the agent route is the better one. If you already know you want a court sale, start with whether court auction homes are worth it instead.
A word on terms. What the British call an estate agent, North Americans call a realtor or real estate agent and Australians a real estate agent. Italian law calls the role a mediatore, a go-between who brings buyer and seller together. A court auction is Italy's foreclosure or repossession sale, run by the court from start to finish.
What is the difference between buying at auction and through an agent?
Buying through an estate agent
The agent markets the home for the seller, shows it, and passes offers between the two sides. Once an offer is accepted, buyer and seller usually sign a preliminary contract, called a compromesso or contratto preliminare, and the buyer pays a deposit. A few weeks or months later both sides sign the deed (rogito) before a notary the buyer has chosen, the balance is paid, and the keys change hands.
Buying at a court auction
There is no seller in the usual sense. A judge orders the sale, a court expert values the home and writes a report, the perizia, and a delegate, usually a lawyer, notary or accountant, runs the sale. Anyone except the debtor can make a sealed offer with a deposit by the deadline in the public court notice. On the auction day the delegate opens the offers and, if there is more than one, runs a short contest. The winner pays the balance by a fixed date, and ownership passes by the judge's transfer decree, not by a deed.
Is it cheaper to buy at auction or through an agent in Italy?
With an agent, the price starts as the seller's asking price. You can offer less, ask for repairs, or walk away. A seller with time on their side may refuse; a seller who must move may accept far less. The final price is whatever two people agree.
At auction, the price starts from a court valuation. The expert values the home and usually deducts something because a forced sale comes with no warranty. The judge sets the starting price from that figure, and offers from 75% of it are valid. If a round passes with no valid offer, the next one can start lower, and after several failed rounds the cuts add up. If several people bid, the contest starts from the highest offer and the price rises.
So an auction price is lower than an agent's price only when three things line up: the valuation was realistic, few people bid, and the problems that pushed the price down are ones you can live with. A low starting price that reflects an occupant with a binding lease, unpaid charges or building work that cannot be legalised is not a bargain; it is the market pricing a problem.
We do not publish average auction discounts: the gap between an auction price and a private price depends on the home, the place, the papers and the competition on the day.
Viewing and checking the home
Through an agent, you can usually visit as often as you need, take a builder or surveyor (geometra) with you, ask the seller questions, and make your offer conditional on what the checks find. If a survey shows damp or a planning problem, you can renegotiate or ask the seller to fix it before the deed.
At auction, viewings are a right but are run by the court's custodian, often on a set day, with limited time. The custodian is neutral: they show the home and describe its state, but they will not negotiate, promise anything or tell you what to bid. A surveyor can come at your cost, but what they find is yours to take on, not to bargain over. See who checks what before you bid.
Free PDFItaly’s court auction homes, in three pages
Where the homes are and what they start at, the 75% rule many buyers miss, and how a court sale works in four steps.
- 01Where the homes are
- 02The 75% rule
- 03Three typical homes
- 04A court sale in four steps
What do you know before you commit?
The agent route: what the seller and agent must tell you
In a private sale your information comes from three places: the seller, the agent and your own checks. The seller must provide an energy performance certificate (APE) from the start of negotiations. The deed must state the building permits for the home, or it is void, and the seller must declare that the land registry plans match the home as it stands. That does not guarantee the home matches its permits: irregularities can survive a private sale, so your surveyor's check still matters. The difference is that you can make the offer conditional on what they find, or negotiate.
The agent has a legal duty too. Under article 1759 of the Civil Code, a mediatore must tell the parties the circumstances known to them that bear on the value and safety of the deal and could affect whether it goes ahead. Italian courts have often read this as covering facts a careful professional should have found out, not only what the agent actually knew. An agent is not your adviser, though: they are usually paid by both sides, and their duty is to be truthful and diligent, not to argue your case.
The auction route: the court's report
At auction there is no seller to ask. Instead the court's expert writes a detailed report on the home: what it is, the right being sold, its planning status, its land registry records, who lives there, known arrears and the valuation. It was written for the court, sometimes months earlier, from what the expert could see and find, and it comes with no promise that it is complete. Our guide to the perizia explains what it contains and where its limits lie.
In short: a private buyer has less paper up front but people to hold responsible; an auction buyer has more paper up front and almost nobody to hold responsible afterwards.
How binding is each step?
Offer, compromesso and caparra
In a private sale you usually sign a written offer (proposta d'acquisto), often on the agent's form, which binds you for a stated time and becomes an agreement once the seller accepts. A preliminary contract with a deposit follows and fixes the price, any conditions and the date for the deed. Operation Sicily covers these steps in detail (see the link at the end of this guide).
The deposit is usually a caparra confirmatoria under article 1385 of the Civil Code. If the buyer backs out without good reason, the seller keeps it. If the seller backs out, the buyer can claim back double. The side not at fault can instead ask a court to enforce the contract, or end it and claim damages. All of this is negotiable: you can add conditions, such as a mortgage being granted or a survey being satisfactory, and agree what happens if they fail.
The court offer and its deposit
At auction there is nothing to negotiate. Your offer goes in with a deposit of at least 10% of what you offer, set by the notice. Under article 571 of the Code of Civil Procedure the offer is irrevocable, with narrow exceptions. If you win, you must pay the balance by the date in the notice, at most 120 days from the award unless the court has allowed instalments, which article 569 permits for good reason within twelve months. If you do not, article 587 lets the judge declare you forfeit: the deposit is kept as a penalty, the home is sold again, and if it then sells for less you can be ordered to pay the difference. Our guide to a valid offer and the deposit covers the rules in full.
There are no conditions. You cannot make a court offer subject to a mortgage, a survey or the sale of your own home. Whatever might stop you paying has to be settled before you bid.
What does each route cost?
The taxes are the same on both routes. Registration tax and the two fixed taxes follow the same rules, first home relief is available on both, and an individual buyer (not a business) can ask for the tax on a home to be worked out on its cadastral value rather than the price, the prezzo-valore rule, at a court sale as in a private one; the Constitutional Court confirmed it applies to court sales too. When the seller charges VAT, different rules apply on both routes. Our guide to court auction buying costs gives the rates and works through each item with an example; a lawyer or commercialista confirms each case.
The other costs are where the routes part:
- Agent route: the agent's commission, plus VAT. It is agreed with the agency, is negotiable, and is often charged to both buyer and seller.
- Agent route: the notary's fee for the deed, agreed with the notary, plus the notary's searches and registration costs.
- Auction route: no commission, no buyer's premium and no notary deed. Instead, half of the delegate's fee for the transfer, set by a ministerial scale, plus expenses.
- Auction route: sometimes the duties for cancelling the old mortgages and seizures, where the notice puts them on the buyer.
- Both routes: a lawyer or surveyor if you use one, and a notary's fee for the mortgage deed if you borrow.
On paper the auction route is cheaper to complete. What it saves at completion it can give back later: arrears the building can claim, planning fixes that a private buyer could have asked the seller to sort out, or priced in, before the deed, and the cost of waiting for an occupied home. Condominium arrears for the current and previous year can be claimed from a new owner on either route, but in a private sale the seller usually settles them at the deed; at auction nobody does that for you.
How long does each route take?
In a private sale the timetable is agreed. The preliminary contract names a date for the deed, and buyer and seller can move it by agreement. Keys are usually handed over at the deed, with the home empty, because that is what the contract says.
At auction the court sets the timetable. The notice fixes the deadline for offers and the auction day. After the award you have the term in the notice to pay, and the decree follows once the delegate has the money and the paperwork; how long that takes varies between courts. Before the award a sale can be postponed or suspended, for example if the debtor settles with every creditor; after the award, a case that ends because the debtor pays does not take the home back from the winner.
Possession is the bigger difference. If the home is occupied by the owner's family, they can usually stay until the decree, and the custodian then frees it under a court order at the procedure's cost. That can take weeks or many months. Our guide to occupied auction homes explains who leaves and when. Anyone who must move in on a fixed date is usually better served by a private sale.
The buying costs, worked out for each home
Members get a buying costs box on every home, worked out for its price and type, with the arrears and planning issues from its court papers.
See membership- Registration tax, 9% of €38,400
- €3,456
- Mortgage and cadastral taxes
- €100
- Your part of the delegate’s fee
- fixed scale
- Taxes on top of the price
- €3,556
Can you get a mortgage on each route?
Through an agent, a mortgage works as it does elsewhere: your contract can be subject to the loan, and the loan is paid out at the deed, before the same notary.
At auction, article 585 of the Code of Civil Procedure lets a bank pay the balance straight to the procedure, with the new mortgage recorded alongside the decree. It works, but the timing is tight and the risk is yours: the deposit cannot be borrowed, the offer cannot be conditional on the loan, and if the bank says no after you win, the deadline does not move. Buyers who borrow usually need an approval in principle before they bid. Fewer banks lend on auction homes to buyers living abroad, so cash counts for more at auction than through an agent.
Who clears the old mortgages and charges?
In a private sale the seller must deliver the home free of mortgages unless the contract says otherwise. If the seller still owes money on a loan, it is normally paid off from the price at the deed, and the lender's mortgage is then cancelled.
At auction the judge does it. The transfer decree orders the registers to cancel the recorded mortgages and the seizures, including those recorded after the seizure, whatever the debtor still owes. This is one of the real strengths of a court sale. Its limits matter too: the decree does not remove easements, leases that bind the buyer, certain other recorded rights, or arrears that the law lets a building claim from a new owner. An auction buyer has to find those in the papers before bidding.
What happens if something is wrong after you buy?
A private seller owes the buyer the legal warranties of the Civil Code. Under article 1490 the seller answers for defects that make the home unfit for use or noticeably reduce its value, and the buyer has short time limits to report a defect and bring a claim (article 1495). The parties can agree to limit these warranties, but not where the seller hid a defect in bad faith.
A forced sale carries none of that. Article 2922 of the Civil Code says that in a forced sale there is no warranty for defects, and the sale cannot be challenged for an unfair price. Notices repeat it as visto e piaciuto, sold as seen. If the roof leaks, there is no seller to claim against. The narrow exception is a home fundamentally different from the one described. The sold as-is guide explains how far that goes.
One protection does survive. If someone later proves a right that takes the home away from the buyer, article 2921 of the Civil Code lets the buyer recover the price: from the procedure if it has not yet been shared out, or from each creditor the part they received and from the debtor anything left over.
That is why checks before bidding matter so much more at auction: what a private buyer can claim afterwards has to be found beforehand.
Each home’s court papers, explained
Members get every home's court papers explained in plain English, with occupancy, arrears and red flags, so the comparison is made on facts.
See membership- OccupiedThe owner still lives there; the custodian frees it after the decree, at no cost to you
- PlanningA closed-in balcony differs from the plans; the expert says it can be legalised
- CondominiumUnpaid fees for this year and last are listed; they can be claimed from you
Choice: what can you actually buy?
Through agents you can look at most of the homes for sale in a town, at any time, in any condition from ruin to turnkey.
At auction you can only buy what the courts are selling in that area at that time. The homes are whatever the courts have been asked to sell, from flats to farmhouses, garages, land and shares of homes, and many need work. The range is narrower and uneven, which is why court sale buyers tend to be flexible on place and patient on timing.
Court sales are public by law, and nobody can sell you access to a hidden list. If someone offers you a home "before it goes to auction", read our guide to court sales, bank resales and private auctions first: a sale by an owner in foreclosure needs every creditor to agree, and some offers are not what they seem.
Can an estate agent or realtor help you buy at a court auction?
Not as an agent. There is no seller to represent and no commission in a court sale, and in the ordinary form of sale only an Italian lawyer (avvocato) with a special power of attorney can make an offer or bid for someone else. An agent, a property finder, a friend or a relative cannot. Some agencies and consultants offer paid help with court sales; that is a private service with its own fee, and the deposit always goes to the account named in the court notice, never to them.
Auction vs estate agent: side by side
- Price: agent route, an asking price you negotiate; court auction, a starting price from a court valuation, offers from 75%, rises if others bid.
- Viewing: agent route, as often as you like; court auction, with the custodian, on set terms.
- Conditions: agent route, you can add them; court auction, none.
- Mortgage: agent route, the contract can depend on the loan; court auction, no condition, so approval is needed before you bid.
- Deposit: agent route, a caparra, lost if you back out, doubled if the seller does; court auction, at least 10%, returned if you lose, kept if you win and do not pay.
- Fees: agent route, commission and the notary's deed fee; court auction, half the delegate's fee, no commission, no deed.
- Title: agent route, the notary checks and the seller clears mortgages; court auction, the decree orders mortgages and seizures cancelled.
- Warranty: agent route, the seller's legal warranties; court auction, none.
- Timing: agent route, a date you agree, usually with the keys at the deed; court auction, set by the court, and an occupied home can take months to be freed.
- Choice: agent route, most of the market; court auction, what the courts are selling at the time.
Who should buy through an agent, and who at auction?
The agent route usually suits
- Buyers who need to move in or start works on a known date.
- People who want a home in one particular town or street.
- Anyone relying on a mortgage that is not yet approved, or on selling another home first.
- Buyers who want a turnkey or near-turnkey home.
A court auction usually suits
- Buyers who would rather pay half a delegate's fee than a commission and a notary's deed fee, and can do without the conditions and warranties those buy.
- Anyone who values a title cleared by the judge's decree more than a seller's promise to pay off a loan at the deed.
- Buyers who prefer a price set by published rules and open bidding to a private negotiation.
- People willing to do before bidding the checks that a seller's warranty would otherwise cover afterwards.
Plenty of buyers look at both. The fair comparison is between two finished, usable homes, with every cost, delay and risk counted on both sides, not between two prices. The guide on whether court auction homes are worth it, linked at the start, sets out who auctions suit and who they do not.
Ready to look at real homes?
The Courtdoor Briefing
- 01Where the homes are, and what they start at
- 02The 75% rule many buyers miss
- 03Three typical homes, and what to watch for
- 04How a court sale works, in four steps
See every home, not just a third
After the founder offer closes: £100 a year or £10 a month
After the founder offer closes: €120 a year or €12 a month
After the founder offer closes: US$130 a year or US$13 a month
After the founder offer closes: CA$190 a year or CA$19 a month
After the founder offer closes: A$200 a year or A$20 a month
After the founder offer closes: NZ$240 a year or NZ$24 a month
- Town, exact price, dates and the court’s own listing
- A plain English report on each home’s papers, with red flags
- Alerts for new homes and price drops, at least 7 days before free visitors
- A bidding plan for each home, with every deadline worked out
- Price history and saved searches across all of Italy
- Exact price
- €38,400
- Auction
- 13 Mar
- Red flags
- 2
Cancel online any time.
Questions buyers ask
Is it cheaper to buy a house at auction or through an estate agent in Italy?
Sometimes, not always. Auction prices start from a court valuation and can fall after failed rounds, and there is no agent's commission. But you buy with no warranty, may pay arrears and legal fixes, and may wait for possession. Compare total costs, not prices.
Do you pay estate agent commission when buying at an Italian court auction?
No. A court sale has no agent and no commission. The buyer pays the taxes and half of the delegate's fee for the transfer. If you hire an agency or consultant to help, that is a separate private fee.
Should a first-time buyer from abroad use an estate agent or a court auction in Italy?
Usually an estate agent if you need a fixed moving date, a mortgage that is not yet approved, or a home in one particular street. A court auction can suit buyers with cash or a loan agreed in principle, flexible on place and timing, who have the court papers checked before bidding.
Does an Italian estate agent have to tell me about problems with a house?
Yes. Article 1759 of the Civil Code requires the agent to tell both parties what they know that bears on the value and safety of the deal, and courts have often extended this to what a careful agent should have checked. The agent is not your adviser, though.
Can I pull out of an Italian property purchase after paying a deposit?
In a private sale, backing out usually costs you the caparra, unless a condition in the contract fails. At a court auction your offer is irrevocable; a losing bidder gets the deposit back, but a winner who does not pay the balance on time loses it.
Which gives more legal protection in Italy, a court auction or a private sale?
For defects, a private sale: the seller owes legal warranties. For title, often a court sale: the judge's decree orders recorded mortgages and seizures cancelled. At auction you need the checks before bidding, because nothing can be claimed afterwards.
Sources
- Civil Code, article 1755: the estate agent's commission from each party (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 1759: the agent's duty to disclose (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 1385: the confirmatory deposit (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 1490: the seller's warranty for defects (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 1495: time limits for defect claims (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2921: the buyer's claim if the home is lost to a third party's right (Normattiva)
- Civil Code, article 2922: no warranty in a forced sale (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 569: the term for paying the balance and instalments (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 571: the irrevocable offer and its deposit (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 585: paying the balance, with a mortgage if needed (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 586: the transfer decree and cancellations (Normattiva)
- Code of Civil Procedure, article 587: a winner who does not pay (Normattiva)
- Legislative Decree 192 of 19 August 2005, article 6: the energy performance certificate in a sale (Normattiva)
- Implementing provisions of the Civil Code, article 63: condominium arrears and the new owner (Normattiva)
General information on Italian law, checked against the sources above. Not legal advice.

